Muskie Discussion Forums

Forums | Calendars | Albums | Quotes | Language | Blogs Search | Statistics | User Listing
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )
Moderators: Slamr

View previous thread :: View next thread
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]

Muskie Fishing -> Lures,Tackle, and Equipment -> Calcutta D w power handle
 
Message Subject: Calcutta D w power handle
Boss
Posted 3/19/2014 2:06 PM (#700602)
Subject: Calcutta D w power handle




Posts: 58


thinking about picking up a calcutta D w this power handle for a Double 10 reel.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAAlDlulAA4

im a lefty so options are limited.

i've narrowed my options down to 5.4 NACL or Calcutta D with power handle.

same IPT, but the D has lower gear ratio....does this mean it will be easier on the retrieve than the NACL?

i realize nobody has used the D with power handle yet...but those who have a D, do you think the power handle would make it good reel for 10's? Not looking to burn just use it comfortably all day
Cal
Posted 3/19/2014 2:18 PM (#700604 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Posts: 177


Location: ON
If 10's is what you're after I would give the nod to the lower gear ratio anyday.

Sunshine
Posted 3/19/2014 2:56 PM (#700616 - in reply to #700604)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Location: Waukesha, WI, USA
Used a 401d all last summer throwing 10's. Bought a second one because I was so impressed.
Nershi
Posted 3/19/2014 3:16 PM (#700619 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle




Location: MN
There is no need for a power handle on the D IMO. The handle is plenty big. They pull 10's fine without one with the right rod. Great reel for regular retrieve for 10 & 13's and you can burn 8's and smaller pretty good.
msky3
Posted 3/20/2014 7:20 AM (#700773 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: RE: Calcutta D w power handle





Posts: 309


Location: Elgin IL
I like the way it feels but have not casted yet.


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(IMG_20140320_071047_852_1_1_1.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments IMG_20140320_071047_852_1_1_1.jpg (80KB - 442 downloads)
Yooper Padre
Posted 3/20/2014 7:27 AM (#700776 - in reply to #700619)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Posts: 337


Location: Watersmeet, Michigan
Nershi - 3/19/2014 3:16 PM

There is no need for a power handle on the D IMO. The handle is plenty big. They pull 10's fine without one with the right rod. Great reel for regular retrieve for 10 & 13's and you can burn 8's and smaller pretty good.


I agree 100% While I've upgraded the handles on most of my reels, the stock handle on the Calcutta D is plenty big to comfortably retrieve anything you'll be throwing.

Fr. K
Slamr
Posted 3/20/2014 9:51 AM (#700804 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Posts: 7039


Location: Northwest Chicago Burbs
If you're looking for one...

http://muskie.outdoorsfirst.com/videos/01.13.2014/6649/Shimano.D.Po...
rjhyland
Posted 3/20/2014 8:30 PM (#700942 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Posts: 456


Location: Kansas City BBQ Capitol of the world
I like the stock handle on the D but this new handle intrigues me. I'd like to hear more once guys start using it.

Ron
curleytail
Posted 3/21/2014 6:47 AM (#701001 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: RE: Calcutta D w power handle




Posts: 2687


Location: Hayward, WI
Cool. It looks like the handle is from a Daiwa Saltist so it should be pretty heavy duty. Looks like the throw, or length of this handle isn't much longer than the standard paddle handle, but the big rubber grip would be nice to hang on to.

First I need to worry about getting a 400D.
Zinox
Posted 3/21/2014 7:33 AM (#701015 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle




Posts: 1100


What's the lenght of the Daiwa handle vs the stock handle ?
From center to knob.
PIKEMASTER
Posted 3/21/2014 8:38 AM (#701024 - in reply to #701015)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Location: Latitude 41.3016 Longitude 88.6160
Zinox - 3/21/2014 7:33 AM

What's the lenght of the Daiwa handle vs the stock handle ?
From center to knob.

On the Shimano 400D the handle is 55mm from the hole to the paddle, 110mm total long. On the 400TE it was on 90mm total !!!!
On the Lexa both the Power handle and stock handle are 60mm from the hole to the paddle, 120mm total.

Warning Will Robinson !!!!
There is a reason Shimano does not have a power handle for the 300/400 Calcutta D reels from the factory, there is only 1/2 of a spool pin on the spool shaft so the first time the reel engages on a cast say good buy to the spool pin and spool, and the pinion gear. Parts are VERY COSTLY to replace on the D reels, U have been warned.
kodiak
Posted 3/21/2014 9:09 AM (#701028 - in reply to #701024)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Posts: 1224


Location: Okoboji
PIKEMASTER - 3/21/2014 8:38 AM

Zinox - 3/21/2014 7:33 AM

What's the lenght of the Daiwa handle vs the stock handle ?
From center to knob.

On the Shimano 400D the handle is 55mm from the hole to the paddle, 110mm total long. On the 400TE it was on 90mm total !!!!
On the Lexa both the Power handle and stock handle are 60mm from the hole to the paddle, 120mm total.

Warning Will Robinson !!!!
There is a reason Shimano does not have a power handle for the 300/400 Calcutta D reels from the factory, there is only 1/2 of a spool pin on the spool shaft so on the first time the reel engages on a cast say good buy to the spool pin and spool, and the pinion gear. Parts are VERY COSTLY to replace on the D reels, U have been warned. :-O




interesting...i will love to see the posts 3 months from now. quick question though, what if you engage it on a cast with the paddle handle? whats the diff?
PIKEMASTER
Posted 3/21/2014 11:25 AM (#701062 - in reply to #701028)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Location: Latitude 41.3016 Longitude 88.6160
kodiak - 3/21/2014 9:09 AM

PIKEMASTER - 3/21/2014 8:38 AM

Zinox - 3/21/2014 7:33 AM

What's the lenght of the Daiwa handle vs the stock handle ?
From center to knob.

On the Shimano 400D the handle is 55mm from the hole to the paddle, 110mm total long. On the 400TE it was on 90mm total !!!!
On the Lexa both the Power handle and stock handle are 60mm from the hole to the paddle, 120mm total.

Warning Will Robinson !!!!
There is a reason Shimano does not have a power handle for the 300/400 Calcutta D reels from the factory, there is only 1/2 of a spool pin on the spool shaft so on the first time the reel engages on a cast say good buy to the spool pin and spool, and the pinion gear. Parts are VERY COSTLY to replace on the D reels, U have been warned. :-O




interesting...i will love to see the posts 3 months from now. quick question though, what if you engage it on a cast with the paddle handle? whats the diff?

The paddle handle is Balanced and is very light in weight, where as the Single power handles are not, and they weigh alot more in weight so when you cast it is very easy to engage the reel on the cast. The power handle for the D is well engineered, alot of work went in to it so it would fit the D reel, I just don't like Power handles period, I did not like them on the TE reels and for sure don't like them for the D reels.
If you must have a power handle make sure keep a few more spool brakes on, so you don't backlash and keep the power handle facing upwards during the cast, that will help to keep the reel from engaging on the cast. Also keep your thumb on the cast button on the cast so it won't engage during the cast. Also don't over power the cast let the rod load and do the casting for you.
Propster
Posted 3/21/2014 11:39 AM (#701066 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle




Posts: 1901


Location: MN
If you keep the thumbar down all the way through the cast then you don't need to worry about the position of the handle. It can't engage then.
eightweight
Posted 3/22/2014 9:48 AM (#701225 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: RE: Calcutta D w power handle




Posts: 209


Go with the Calcutta , the Shimano's will last you a long long time


Boss - 3/19/2014 2:06 PM

thinking about picking up a calcutta D w this power handle for a Double 10 reel.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAAlDlulAA4

im a lefty so options are limited.

i've narrowed my options down to 5.4 NACL or Calcutta D with power handle.

same IPT, but the D has lower gear ratio....does this mean it will be easier on the retrieve than the NACL?

i realize nobody has used the D with power handle yet...but those who have a D, do you think the power handle would make it good reel for 10's? Not looking to burn just use it comfortably all day
Boss
Posted 3/24/2014 11:59 AM (#701671 - in reply to #700773)
Subject: RE: Calcutta D w power handle




Posts: 58


msky3 - 3/20/2014 8:20 AM

I like the way it feels but have not casted yet.


looks sweet.

wanna take a few casts in the backyard for me? LOL
msky3
Posted 3/31/2014 9:13 AM (#703430 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: RE: Calcutta D w power handle





Posts: 309


Location: Elgin IL
I tried out the new power handle and was impressed. The reel never engaged I casted hard and had the handle in all positions....seems balanced very well.
I know you don't need a PH for this reel but if it makes my 16 hr day a little
easier I'm all in. I plan on using this on 8s and 9s and some spinnerbaits on my spring
rod.


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(IMG_20140331_082505_230_1_1.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments IMG_20140331_082505_230_1_1.jpg (106KB - 257 downloads)
Boss
Posted 4/1/2014 11:51 PM (#703797 - in reply to #703430)
Subject: RE: Calcutta D w power handle




Posts: 58


Thanks for the update. Think I will be purchasing one when they're back in stock.

I've used a PH on other reels before and have never had them engage during the cast. I think it must be the way certain people cast or unbalanced PHs
kodiak
Posted 4/2/2014 8:14 AM (#703812 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Posts: 1224


Location: Okoboji
looks like the new saltist levelwind handle. the black saltist.
lennyg3
Posted 4/2/2014 8:13 PM (#703980 - in reply to #701062)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Posts: 483


Location: NE PA

PIKEMASTER - 3/21/2014 12:25 PM

kodiak - 3/21/2014 9:09 AM

PIKEMASTER - 3/21/2014 8:38 AM

Zinox - 3/21/2014 7:33 AM

What's the lenght of the Daiwa handle vs the stock handle ?
From center to knob.

On the Shimano 400D the handle is 55mm from the hole to the paddle, 110mm total long. On the 400TE it was on 90mm total !!!!
On the Lexa both the Power handle and stock handle are 60mm from the hole to the paddle, 120mm total.

Warning Will Robinson !!!!
There is a reason Shimano does not have a power handle for the 300/400 Calcutta D reels from the factory, there is only 1/2 of a spool pin on the spool shaft so on the first time the reel engages on a cast say good buy to the spool pin and spool, and the pinion gear. Parts are VERY COSTLY to replace on the D reels, U have been warned. :-O :-O




interesting...i will love to see the posts 3 months from now. quick question though, what if you engage it on a cast with the paddle handle? whats the diff?

The paddle handle is Balanced and is very light in weight, where as the Single power handles are not, and they weigh alot more in weight so when you cast it is very easy to engage the reel on the cast. The power handle for the D is well engineered, alot of work went in to it so it would fit the D reel, I just don't like Power handles period, I did not like them on the TE reels and for sure don't like them for the D reels.
If you must have a power handle make sure keep a few more spool brakes on, so you don't backlash and keep the power handle facing upwards during the cast, that will help to keep the reel from engaging on the cast. Also don't over power the cast let the rod load and do the casting for you.

 Are you saying to keep the knobfacing upward and perpendicular to the rod, or?

Boss
Posted 5/1/2014 11:14 PM (#709839 - in reply to #700602)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle




Posts: 58


Just got my power handle in the mail. Seems very well built. Balanced perfectly. I'll have better feedback in a few weeks
PIKEMASTER
Posted 5/2/2014 8:32 AM (#709878 - in reply to #703980)
Subject: Re: Calcutta D w power handle





Location: Latitude 41.3016 Longitude 88.6160
lennyg3 - 4/2/2014 8:13 PM

PIKEMASTER - 3/21/2014 12:25 PM

kodiak - 3/21/2014 9:09 AM

PIKEMASTER - 3/21/2014 8:38 AM

Zinox - 3/21/2014 7:33 AM

What's the lenght of the Daiwa handle vs the stock handle ?
From center to knob.

On the Shimano 400D the handle is 55mm from the hole to the paddle, 110mm total long. On the 400TE it was on 90mm total !!!!
On the Lexa both the Power handle and stock handle are 60mm from the hole to the paddle, 120mm total.

Warning Will Robinson !!!!
There is a reason Shimano does not have a power handle for the 300/400 Calcutta D reels from the factory, there is only 1/2 of a spool pin on the spool shaft so on the first time the reel engages on a cast say good buy to the spool pin and spool, and the pinion gear. Parts are VERY COSTLY to replace on the D reels, U have been warned. :-O :-O




interesting...i will love to see the posts 3 months from now. quick question though, what if you engage it on a cast with the paddle handle? whats the diff?

The paddle handle is Balanced and is very light in weight, where as the Single power handles are not, and they weigh alot more in weight so when you cast it is very easy to engage the reel on the cast. The power handle for the D is well engineered, alot of work went in to it so it would fit the D reel, I just don't like Power handles period, I did not like them on the TE reels and for sure don't like them for the D reels.
If you must have a power handle make sure keep a few more spool brakes on, so you don't backlash and keep the power handle facing upwards during the cast, that will help to keep the reel from engaging on the cast. Also don't over power the cast let the rod load and do the casting for you.

 Are you saying to keep the knobfacing upward and perpendicular to the rod, or?


If it is a right hand reel then turn the reel so the handle is facing up during the cast, your writch will thank you at the end of the day, and that will help to not engage the reel during the cast. I also keep my thumb pushing down on the cast button during the cast.
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete all cookies set by this site)