Muskie Discussion Forums

Forums | Calendars | Albums | Quotes | Language | Blogs Search | Statistics | User Listing
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )
Moderators: Slamr

View previous thread :: View next thread
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]

Muskie Fishing -> General Discussion -> If you had your choice...
 
Message Subject: If you had your choice...

Posted 9/21/2002 9:22 AM (#734)
Subject: If you had your choice...


Do you perfer Fat muskies or Long muskies.

Example:

1)46x26
2)48x23
3)50x21
4)52x19
5)54x17
6)All of the above!

What about a muskie really trips your trigger!


Posted 9/21/2002 12:46 PM (#45279)
Subject: If you had your choice...


Hey Jason,

Good Post. I think it all depends on where you fish. If I was fishing Sabaskong Bay, then I would take the 50x21, because that is a really nice fish up there. If I was on most MN waters, the 46x26 would be the fish I would want. That fish would out weigh all the others and it would be a freakish specimen. But, in general 1,2, or 3 would be very nice. The longer fish would be cool because of the length, but they would not even make 25lbs.

MN [;)]

Posted 9/21/2002 1:02 PM (#45280)
Subject: If you had your choice...


I agree with 1, 2 & 3.

Although I would take any of the choices especially the last with no argument.

-Phil C.

Posted 9/21/2002 1:17 PM (#45281)
Subject: If you had your choice...


I need to get my first 45"+ so i'll go with number 6[8)]

Posted 9/21/2002 1:25 PM (#45282)
Subject: If you had your choice...


Keep in mind this question is subconsciencely an indication in your choice of women too![:0]

Posted 9/21/2002 1:43 PM (#45283)
Subject: If you had your choice...


Well,

#6 is the obvious answer. Who in their right mind would want to catch only one of those five when you could catch them all!! [;)]

If I had to pick just one, I would go with the skinny 54"er. When telling the story, all I would have to do is add the phrase: "... imagine if I would have caught her in fall!" [:)]

Posted 9/21/2002 1:43 PM (#45284)
Subject: If you had your choice...


In response to sponge, give me the #4 tall and not deathly skinny, but filled out in the right areas. [:devil:]

-Phil C

Posted 9/21/2002 2:04 PM (#45285)
Subject: If you had your choice...


2 and 3. I prefer a fish to put up a good fight, I don't really look at the weight. Though a fatty will more likely than not swim through the drag and I just love the sound of a screaming reel!!![:bigsmile:]

Posted 9/21/2002 7:51 PM (#45286)
Subject: If you had your choice...


I definatly would say all of the above. I like to catch everything over 20lbs. [:p]

Hmmm a fat 46 or skinny 54 that would be an easy choice. [:praise:]

Posted 9/21/2002 8:57 PM (#45287)
Subject: If you had your choice...


I would take all of the above any time on any water, greed is good!!!http://www.mostlymuskies.com/gallery.htm

Capt. Larry

Posted 9/21/2002 9:42 PM (#45288)
Subject: If you had your choice...


i have cought 1 49x20 and 3 48x20 and by far the fish i brag most about to my friends is the 44x20 i got. this thing was a pig from heaven. short fat, long fat it just dosnt matter as long as its fat.

happy hunting
duck

Posted 9/22/2002 1:47 AM (#45289)
Subject: If you had your choice...


I will go with #6 also. As far as what trips my trigger, muskies and everything associated with it.(except dig in backlashes).[;)]

Posted 9/22/2002 6:47 AM (#45290)
Subject: If you had your choice...


From the information gathered thus far, it would appear that there may be both a hint of desperation and one of greed; most answers seem to indicate a desire for "anything", which in reality should stop one in their tracks + cause momentary reflection on quality verses quantity... annon + I feel that since the poll also indicates an individuals view of women, there is a slight concern for the way the peeps from "up there" conduct daily activities when it comes to serious life long choices. All I can say for now is to take time to "pause for the cause"![::)]

Posted 10/1/2002 10:17 AM (#45291)
Subject: If you had your choice...



Question: Do you perfer Fat muskies or Long muskies.

Answer: YES


Posted 10/1/2002 10:36 AM (#45292)
Subject: If you had your choice...


I would rather catch the 54, long and skinny is fine by me.

But I wouldn't complain if I caught all of them!

Mike Hulbert

Posted 10/1/2002 10:52 AM (#45293)
Subject: If you had your choice...


I would like to say that the muskies in Cass lake are better than the muskies in Pewaukee Lake inch for inch. With that said I would say the fatties are the best, unless you are all wrapped up with the numbers game, then length would be your choice. Give me fall like fish all year long.[:p]
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete all cookies set by this site)