Muskie Discussion Forums
| ||
| Moderators: Slamr | View previous thread :: View next thread |
| Jump to page : 1 2 3 Now viewing page 2 [30 messages per page] Muskie Fishing -> General Discussion -> PB casting or trolling? |
| Message Subject: PB casting or trolling? | |||
| tr7 |
| ||
Posts: 294 | Casting for me. I have never trolled for them though. | ||
| esoxfly |
| ||
Posts: 1663 Location: Kodiak, AK | I don't troll. My longest have come on casting gear, but my fattest one this past fall came on fly, and it was still 52. | ||
| MACK |
| ||
Posts: 1086 | Both. I'm tied for PB length fish with both casting and trolling. Weight? I dunno. Using the calculations, both were similar in weight...probably within a mere few of pounds of each other. | ||
| R Swain |
| ||
| Trolling, but I cast more than troll. | |||
| barbless-bob |
| ||
Posts: 70 | we have miles of productive waters here in canada making trolling a must in the arsenal, that said i still mainly cast, i started this post because i caught my 2 PB's trolling, (length, don't weight fish ), which i found strange . i'm glad to see it's a mixed bag for everyone. looking forward to wetting a few new baits in a few new spots this summer, | ||
| BigC |
| ||
Location: On the O | Trolling Cast 80% of the time now but used to troll 80%.....hmmmm | ||
| muskymedic5 |
| ||
Posts: 91 Location: Central Wisconsin | Best caught casting but only by 1/2". Mostly cast though. | ||
| Slimeduptuffy |
| ||
Posts: 151 Location: West of the metro, MN | My PB's have came from casting. But I hardly troll | ||
| wicked |
| ||
Location: sneaking out to get on the water ;-) | Casting but also cast more than I troll. | ||
| Bytor |
| ||
Location: The Yahara Chain | Casting, I cast 78% of the time. | ||
| jasond |
| ||
Posts: 187 Location: West Metro, MN | Casting...I cast 95% of the time though | ||
| ArmPit |
| ||
Posts: 452 Location: Waconia, MN | Casting 99%...... | ||
| Slow Rollin |
| ||
Posts: 619 | Casting.... gas is to expensive to be trolling around | ||
| trolling king |
| ||
Posts: 83 Location: Antioch IL | Longest casting Heaviest trolling I cast 99% of the time | ||
| they're out there |
| ||
| casting a 9" pink shallow running gramma | |||
| Born |
| ||
Posts: 153 Location: MN | Casting. | ||
| muskediem |
| ||
| wind powered drifting soaking a sucker | |||
| barbless-bob |
| ||
Posts: 70 | i think Slow Rollin is onto something | ||
| honkermusky |
| ||
Posts: 383 Location: SE Wisc and Vilas County | my pb was casting. most of my bigger fish have been from casting. i do troll a little and it seems like we get decent numbers but am yet to get a real good fish while trolling. | ||
| Matt DeVos |
| ||
Posts: 584 | My PB in Wisconsin was caught trolling. I cast and troll about equally in the WI waters I fish. My overall PB was caught casting in Canada, where I cast 99.9% of the time during the summer...and its about 50/50 in Canada in the fall. | ||
| Jerry Newman |
| ||
Location: 31 | I'm tied with my PB / trolling and casting... it would be an epic event for me if I could break the tie this year because I'm still only at #5 regarding my boats PB | ||
| Northwind Mark |
| ||
Posts: 566 Location: Elgin, IL | My big fat lazy Tourista a&& got my largest in Vilas jigging. Too lazy to cast or troll. | ||
| Shep |
| ||
Posts: 5874 | Trolling, 3 of the last 4 PB's for me. | ||
| byteme90k |
| ||
Posts: 220 Location: Pittsburgh, PA | trolling...99% troll | ||
| Mikes Extreme |
| ||
Posts: 2691 Location: Pewaukee, Wisconsin | Four Wisconsin 50's all trolling. Two canada monsters both trolling. I cast when its the best patterns and troll when they move deep. 30% casting 50% trolling and 20% suckers. Guess that's 70% trolling. | ||
| Pedro |
| ||
Posts: 670 Location: Otsego, MN | Casting.... 99% caster though. | ||
| Brad P |
| ||
Posts: 833 | Caught my PB length twice, once trolling, once on a sucker. Cast about 90% fo the time. Plan to troll more this season, especially when it is the more favorable pattern where I fish. | ||
| Chasin50 |
| ||
Posts: 378 Location: Michigan | Home water, with equal amounts casting/trolling, largest is trolling, but I have lost sevaral that were bigger casting. On other water - Casting with most of the time casting | ||
| FAT-SKI |
| ||
Posts: 1360 Location: Lake "y" cause lake"x" got over fished | casting double 10s | ||
| Guest |
| ||
| 6 fish over 50" and five have been caught dragging a sucker and the other was caught trolling after dark in July. I only drag suckers in the months of October and November. I would be interested in hearing if the guides who drag meat in the Fall catch most all of their biggest fish in this manner. | |||
| Jump to page : 1 2 3 Now viewing page 2 [30 messages per page] |
| Search this forum Printer friendly version E-mail a link to this thread |


Copyright © 2025 OutdoorsFIRST Media |