Muskie Discussion Forums
| Moderators: Slamr | View previous thread :: View next thread |
| Jump to page : 1 2 Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page] Muskie Fishing -> General Discussion -> If your largest fish is from WI how big? |
MRoberts |
| ||
Posts: 714 Location: Rhinelander, WI | |||
| MRoberts |
| ||
Posts: 714 Location: Rhinelander, WI | |||
| jlong |
| ||
Posts: 1937 Location: Black Creek, WI | |||
| RUMBLEFISH |
| ||
| AndrewR |
| ||
Posts: 300 Location: Minocqua, WI | |||
| CiscoKid |
| ||
Posts: 1906 Location: Oconto Falls, WI | |||
| curleytail |
| ||
46, Chippewa County. Plan on beating it next year...if I'm lucky.  curleytail | |||
| Muskydr |
| ||
| muskyfvr |
| ||
Posts: 223 Location: Minn. | |||
| Reef Hawg |
| ||
| Bigman |
| ||
Posts: 281 Location: ROckford IL | |||
| jonnysled |
| ||
Posts: 13688 Location: minocqua, wi. | |||
| A-ROZ |
| ||
Posts: 281 Location: Girdwood, Alaska | |||
| ToothyCritter |
| ||
Posts: 661 Location: Roscoe IL | |||
| nwild |
| ||
Posts: 1996 Location: Pelican Lake/Three Lakes Chain | 50.5, and not out of Pelican!  | ||
| captdoug |
| ||
| curleytail |
| ||
| PIKEMASTER |
| ||
Location: Latitude 41.3016 Longitude 88.6160 | |||
| jlong |
| ||
Posts: 1937 Location: Black Creek, WI | ToothyCritter - 2/25/2008 4:20 PM This poll brings me to ask a question. Would you rather catch a 50" slob with girth that is just plain sick? Or a 51" that is a nice fish but not as heavy? The 50" is in the 40 # class range & would out weigh the 51 by 10lbs give or take... Well... I think in general people would agree that FATTER is better.... since it implies BIGGER. If comparing two 48 inchers and one is 25 pounds and the other is 35 pounds.... I think most would agree that the 35 pounder is bigger. And if bigger is better... well??? Quite honestly, I think there is more to the catch than just the size of the fish. Here are two fish that I caught in 2007 that fit ToothyCritter's example (49 vs 51 inches). I'm tickled pink to have caught either one of them.... but I feel the shorter fish was "bigger" due to its weight. Attachments ----------------  11-10-07 49.JPG (116KB - 125 downloads) 7-18-07 JL 51.jpg (95KB - 112 downloads) | ||
| nwick |
| ||
| TET62 |
| ||
Posts: 109 Location: Spencer, Wisconsin | 42inch-18lbs caught on Pelican Lake was totally hung over pre-fishing the Hodag in 06' with a friend but the best day fishing ever when the photo came out. Attachments ---------------- DSC07113.JPG (138KB - 125 downloads) | ||
| Musky53 |
| ||
| Mikes Extreme |
| ||
Posts: 2691 Location: Pewaukee, Wisconsin | My largest Wisconsin fish is a 52.5-inch Pewaukee lake muskie. Attachments ---------------- 52.5x22muskie5x3.jpg (18KB - 114 downloads) | ||
| muskie! nut |
| ||
Posts: 2894 Location: Yahara River Chain | |||
| Joe Cal |
| ||
Posts: 294 Location: Bloomer, Wi | 50" from chippewa county, and to weigh in on the would you rather get a fatty or a long skinny. This was my 1st 50 and it had a split lower jaw so it was obviously not eating well but when I finally broke 50" it was an awesome feeling of accomplishment. Of course i wish it could of had a 27" girth but you get what you get. Attachments ---------------- Picture 037_edited.jpg (49KB - 117 downloads) | ||
| Coach Rob |
| ||
| agrimm |
| ||
Posts: 427 Location: Wausau | 48.5 from the 3 Lakes Chain in spring of 1990...very thin. 48 from small Minocqua area lake in July of 2007...healthy would rather catch the 48 any day. Attachments ---------------- July 4.jpg (54KB - 127 downloads) | ||
| GMACK |
| ||
| Lusox |
| ||
| bjb360 |
| ||
| Jump to page : 1 2 Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page] |
| Search this forum Printer friendly version E-mail a link to this thread |
