Muskie Discussion Forums

Forums | Calendars | Albums | Quotes | Language | Blogs Search | Statistics | User Listing
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )
Moderators: Slamr

View previous thread :: View next thread
Jump to page : 1 2
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]

Muskie Fishing -> General Discussion -> Five lure challenge
 
Message Subject: Five lure challenge
bturg
Posted 7/16/2023 5:36 PM (#1022313)
Subject: Five lure challenge




Posts: 716


What five lures are you taking to a big $$$$ tourney (make it 300k) on unknown waters in an unknown location anywhere in the muskies range. You can only bring one rod and five lures.

Be specific, model color size.
sworrall
Posted 7/16/2023 6:35 PM (#1022314 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 32879


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
Firetiger original Suick
Black Creature 1/4 Ounce 5/0
Black Suick Nitewalker
Violent Strike Black/Orange spinnerbait
Violent Strike Black Chattershad
Masqui-ninja
Posted 7/16/2023 7:19 PM (#1022316 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 1240


Location: Walker, MN
White Mag Dawg
Walleye Reg Medusa
Perch Shallow Mag Swimmin' Dawg
Lazer Cranberry Supermodel
Gold/Purple Trigger
TCESOX
Posted 7/16/2023 7:24 PM (#1022317 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 1257


2 oz. JAW Bait willow leaf spinner bait (no longer made)
black and green Rabid Squirrel
dark colored changeable weight Suick
walleye or sucker pattern Shallow Swimmin' Dawg
perch colored 10" Slammer
muskymartin67
Posted 7/16/2023 7:52 PM (#1022320 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 786


Location: Delavan, WI
Black widow top raider
White glider, HR or Modivator
Blk/Gold dbl 10
8" jointed believer in perch
Red October ninja tube mid depth in gold
39 degrees
Posted 7/16/2023 8:03 PM (#1022321 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 108


10 inch perch wieghted suick, yellow/gold fudally hawg spin spinnerbait, cisco jointed depth raider, walleye orange tail mag dog, 8/9 bucktail black silver.
Rudedog
Posted 7/17/2023 5:57 AM (#1022329 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: RE: Five lure challenge




Posts: 624


Location: S.W. WI
MAG DAWG- White belly Walleye.
JR COWGIRL- Gold/Copper.
TOPRAIDER- any color.
10" shallow Minnow- Homemade- (walleye)
9" Big game twitch- (Walleye)
Brett Waldera
Posted 7/17/2023 7:29 AM (#1022334 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 108


1. Black/Silver Raddog Spinnerbait
2. Regular Medussa- Walleye
3. 12" Warner Crank CIsco
4. Red October Tube Whitetail walleye
5. 8/9 Stagger brown/ gold
RJ_692
Posted 7/17/2023 7:38 AM (#1022335 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 357


One rod will be St. Croix Long Ranger 401 Tranx for a reel

1. Northland Bionic Bucktail spinnerbait (old style). Black / White with nickel & gold blades
2. #8 Colorado single blade bucktail (home made) in a flame pattern.
3. 10" Firetiger Suick
4. Large Swim Jig with paddle tail (home made) in a white / chartreuse pattern.
5. 7" Big game twitch bait. White perch
Kirby Budrow
Posted 7/17/2023 7:51 AM (#1022336 - in reply to #1022335)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 2315


Location: Chisholm, MN
1. Red October Tube
2. Hawg wobbler
3. Pounder Bulldawg
4. Jr. Cowgirl Laser Shad
5. Black/black cowgirl
mikie
Posted 7/17/2023 8:32 AM (#1022338 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Location: Athens, Ohio
First, I wouldn't fish such an event. ever. This would make an interesting Fall challenge on this site, tho: pick a weekend and have folks sign up for five baits; see who gets fish for bragging rights.
Anyway, two Muskie Treats, a gold cowgirl, topraider, and Goldie the Sledge would keep me busy for the day. m
chuckski
Posted 7/17/2023 10:29 AM (#1022342 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 1341


1. Baby Depth Raider Miller Perch
2.. Large Eddie blue white
3. 9" Wt. Bobbiebait org. Perch (yellow strips)
4. Single spin spinnerbait silver/purple
5. Pfluger Globe Yellow The only color I have of a DQ'ed lure
bloatlord
Posted 7/17/2023 11:19 AM (#1022343 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 96


1. Mid medussa, black and orange
2. Grenade, black and nickel
3. Ridgeway Customs Jerk, bullhead
4. Counterpunch, bullhead
5. Believer, 10 inch



Replace believer with a shallow raider if it's the old shallow raider, not the new garbage version.
Angling Oracle
Posted 7/17/2023 1:13 PM (#1022344 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 351


Location: Selkirk, Manitoba
Surprised by all the topraider picks.

Are we allowed glue?
BillM
Posted 7/17/2023 1:24 PM (#1022345 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 184


1. Phantom Softail 7.5in - Canadian Crush
2. Spanky 89 firebomb - Double Chartreuse
3. 13in Grandma - Prizm firetiger
4. Lubowski Big Lou XL - Orange over black
5. Storm Kickin Stick - Gold over black.
welfaretrain
Posted 7/17/2023 3:08 PM (#1022347 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 10


Lake X Fat Bastard Black/Chart

Some Spanky 89 firebomb probably a copper/white tinsel w/ one copper and one painted blade

Another Spanky, double 9's with black tinsel and silver blades
horsehunter
Posted 7/17/2023 3:55 PM (#1022348 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Location: Eastern Ontario
Firetiger Suick
Rob Dey Spinner bait black orange blades
6 inch Reef Hawg Walleye ( I know it has the action of a dog turd but the #*^@d thing catches fish)
Rob Dey Spinner bait black silver blades
8 inch firetiger believer unjointed
If it's big water and I can troll scrub the last 3 and give me
Hose Fatty brown perch
Hose Flat Shad jailbird
Extra Heavy Rob Dey Spinnerbait white silver blades ( dont know what Rob calls it I call it the doorknob)
IAJustin
Posted 7/17/2023 5:01 PM (#1022350 - in reply to #1022348)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 2008


black mag dawg
black medussa
black jr. cowgirl
black original bondy
black 2oz Spinnerbait - willow blade
esoxaddict
Posted 7/17/2023 5:28 PM (#1022351 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 8772


#1 Double 10 Spanky Bait: Nickel blades/Black Skirt
#2 Double 8 Shumway Flasher: Orange blades/Black Skirt
#3 Lee Lures Chopper: Any color as long as it's black
#4 Mag Dawg: Black/Any color tail
#5 DDD: Perch


7.62xJay
Posted 7/17/2023 10:42 PM (#1022353 - in reply to #1022350)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 523


Location: NW WI
IAJustin - 7/17/2023 5:01 PM

black mag dawg
black medussa
black jr. cowgirl
black original bondy
black 2oz Spinnerbait - willow blade


I've never been there and don't know much about it. Are u truly vertical jigging under power or are u casting ur Bondy out there?
Angling Oracle
Posted 7/18/2023 11:10 AM (#1022355 - in reply to #1022353)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 351


Location: Selkirk, Manitoba
7.62xJay - 7/17/2023 10:42 PM

IAJustin - 7/17/2023 5:01 PM

black mag dawg
black medussa
black jr. cowgirl
black original bondy
black 2oz Spinnerbait - willow blade


I've never been there and don't know much about it. Are u truly vertical jigging under power or are u casting ur Bondy out there?


Once you jig bondys and get pinned to the gunnel, you will have found your next addiction...

Edited by Angling Oracle 7/18/2023 11:14 AM
zekeekez
Posted 7/18/2023 8:15 PM (#1022363 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 21


Fat bastard - loon
Ice 89 - black/silver
Shallow invader - clown/orange
Double dog - walleye
Cowgirl - green
Ciscokid82
Posted 7/19/2023 6:15 PM (#1022371 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 333


Location: SE Wisc
Marvin Flash single mag 8 (black/nickel)
Regular Dawg (mud minnow) w/ blade attachment (orange blades)
Ninja tube shallow rig w/ custom weight (baby Muskie)
7” shallow raider (white perch) or 7.5” classic Grandma
10” Chaos Navin (walleye)
Rod would be 8’6” H w/ Tranx 400 hs

North of 8
Posted 7/20/2023 9:03 AM (#1022380 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Really interesting thread.
Ranger
Posted 7/20/2023 9:16 AM (#1022381 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 3861


1) Original Unweighted Perch Suick
2) 10" Black/Orange Timberwolf Glider
3) 7.5" Crappie Grandma Crankbait (modified to suspend)
4) Black/Orange Topraider
5) Black/Silver Buchertail 700

Edited by Ranger 7/20/2023 9:17 AM
OH Muskyman
Posted 7/20/2023 8:52 PM (#1022414 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 56


Ninja tube mid rig- shad
Reg Medusa- shad
Large ell tail - white
Bondi - black
Big Joe - crappie

9,6 Shock & Awe Tranx 400

Edited by OH Muskyman 7/20/2023 8:56 PM
southern comfort
Posted 7/22/2023 12:02 PM (#1022452 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 390


1. Black 9' suick ( new hi - impact suick with optional weights)
2. Musky Mayhem Trigger 7/9 buck tail - black/nickel
3. Loon Topraider (old one with rattles)
4. Regular Medussa white
5. Droptine Spinner bait - green/black
Brian Hoffies
Posted 7/22/2023 9:07 PM (#1022460 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge





Posts: 1719


I'm far from a Muskie maven but wouldn't the season make a difference? Wouldn't Sept. baits on Eagle be different than late June July baits on Eagle?

I'll follow along and see what everybody thinks.
bturg
Posted 7/22/2023 10:26 PM (#1022462 - in reply to #1022460)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 716


The premise is that you don't know...the event is a total unknown prior to going. Actually it isn't an event at all, it's the concept we are using for discussion. I was going to play this out a bit then start another with the time of year being a factor.
I suspect it will change things knowing the season but I think less than one may think. For example many people will have a glider or minnow bait ( fairly interchangeable imo) in the mix, spring thru fall. In my world the bucktails just get bigger as the water cools...but I still need a blade bait spring thru fall. etc etc.
Guzzler
Posted 7/23/2023 10:04 AM (#1022464 - in reply to #1022313)
Subject: Re: Five lure challenge




Posts: 41


Lots of variables but...

Shallow Mag Dog - Walleye gold color,
Dbl Cowgirl - Black tail and orange/brass blades
Jr Cowgirl - Black tail and brass and copper blades
11" Safari Tackle Water Mocassin
Large Grandma (old style with old lip) - flashy gold color
Jump to page : 1 2
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete all cookies set by this site)