Muskie Discussion Forums

Forums | Calendars | Albums | Quotes | Language | Blogs Search | Statistics | User Listing
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )
Moderators: Slamr

View previous thread :: View next thread
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]

Muskie Fishing -> Lures,Tackle, and Equipment -> Opinions needed-rod/reel
 
Message Subject: Opinions needed-rod/reel
Cover Dog
Posted 2/16/2022 10:12 PM (#1002582)
Subject: Opinions needed-rod/reel




Posts: 15


Location: Chardon, Ohio
After following the site for the better part of the year, I have joined and would like some advice. I have the rods and reels listed below and would like opinions on which rod with which reel.

Rods:
St Croix Top-n-Tail 8’ MH-F 3/4-3oz.
St Croix Big Nasty 9’ HF 3-8oz.
Okuma EVX HF 9’3” 2-10oz.
Okuma SCT XH-F 8’6” 4-12oz.
Okuma SCT XH-F 9’3” 4-16oz.

Reels:
Tranx 400A 5.8
Daiwa Lexa TW 6.3
Daiwa Lexa HD 300HS-P 7.4
Tranx 400HG 7.6
Daiwa Lexa TW 8.1

Thanks to all in advance for your knowledgeable opinions.
Pa Tigers n trout
Posted 2/17/2022 7:03 AM (#1002587 - in reply to #1002582)
Subject: RE: Opinions needed-rod/reel




Posts: 267


Location: Central Pennsylvania
What sorts of baits are you going to be throwing with said setup? different combos are better suited to different sorts of lures, obviously not gonna do well throwing double 10s on a 8.1:1 haha
Masqui-ninja
Posted 2/17/2022 7:09 AM (#1002588 - in reply to #1002582)
Subject: Re: Opinions needed-rod/reel





Posts: 1203


Location: Walker, MN
Tranx 400 HG and a Big Nasty will cover you.
7ovr50
Posted 2/18/2022 5:34 AM (#1002621 - in reply to #1002582)
Subject: Re: Opinions needed-rod/reel




Posts: 426


I have a top and tails. IMO it's a little light for any thing more than double 8s,
Ogandrews
Posted 2/18/2022 6:01 AM (#1002622 - in reply to #1002582)
Subject: Re: Opinions needed-rod/reel




Posts: 206


Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota
I would say tranx 400hg and the big nasty, and then lexa tw with the 9’3” xh maybe for bigger stuff. I will say I owned one of those okuma rods before and it was pretty solid for the money, although it seemed way overrated power wise. If I was in your position I’d sell everything besides the big nasty and get either one nice 9’ MH or XH depending on how big of lures you generally use. 9’ MH legend tourney or elite are incredibly comfortable rods. If you want to stick with st croix, LT 10ft xtra heavy is a great big bait rod. Otherwise chaos, shimano or Thorne all have good options
RobertK
Posted 2/18/2022 7:40 AM (#1002624 - in reply to #1002582)
Subject: Re: Opinions needed-rod/reel




Posts: 120


Location: Twin Cities Metro
8’ MH + Lexa 300 7.4: small bucktails and topwater
9’ H + Tranx 400 5.8: crank baits, maybe twitching
9’3” H + Lexa 6.3: Bucktail rod, bigger top water
8’6” XH + Lexa 8.1: jerk baits, large twitch baits
9’3” XH + Tranx 400HG 7.6: big rubber

My method was to look at what each rod will be good at throwing and working (ie figure out the rod’s purpose), then choose the reel that matches that purpose. High speed where you want quick pick up of slack, slow speed where you will have the line under tension with hard-pulling baits.

Alternatively, if you really like one or two of those rods (ie the way they load, cast, and figure 8) then you could pair it/them with the most versatile reels and throw almost everything with it/them. The other rods would then be specialist rods for specific things that generalist set-ups wouldn’t handle well. Up to you of course.

Hope it helps.
Cover Dog
Posted 2/18/2022 12:10 PM (#1002627 - in reply to #1002582)
Subject: Re: Opinions needed-rod/reel




Posts: 15


Location: Chardon, Ohio
Thanks to all that have given me very informative opinions.
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete all cookies set by this site)