Muskie Discussion Forums
| ||
| Moderators: Slamr | View previous thread :: View next thread |
| Jump to page : 1 Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page] Muskie Fishing -> General Discussion -> Best Bucktails? |
| Message Subject: Best Bucktails? | |||
| DaveG |
| ||
Posts: 141 | From what we read on here Bucktails are probably THE most productive Musky lures available, which make of Bucktail would you guys say have been the best for you? | ||
| Billy B |
| ||
Posts: 267 Location: Ft. Wayne, Indiana | The most productive bucktail I've ever used would have to be a a double bladed bucktail of any color. But my favorite color would be white with silver blades. | ||
| Rainman JD |
| ||
Posts: 260 Location: Lockport, IL | I have always been fortunate using a Rizzotail with yellow hair. | ||
| IAJustin |
| ||
Posts: 2082 | which bucktail is the best? Thats like picking your favorite Playboy centerfold!!!.....Lots of good ones! | ||
| muskymeyer |
| ||
Posts: 691 Location: nationwide | I mainly use Ghosttails, Rabid Squirrels, Bootails and Joe's. Depending on what color pattern I am looking for usually steers me towards a brand. Bootails because of the flame blade. Joe's because of the squirell tail. Ghosttails because of the green perch pattern and the Rabid's for the coil over wire lighter weight for over weeds in the summer. Corey Meyer | ||
| The Yeti |
| ||
| llungens...keiths or chads. another dude on ebay custom makes some too.... mzogmusky awesome normal sized tails. | |||
| Pete Stoltman |
| ||
Posts: 663 | It's still tough to beat a Mepps Musky Killer or Bucher 700 for all around good tails. A lot of the others already mentioned get fish too. | ||
| fish4musky1 |
| ||
Location: Northern Wisconsin | mepps musky marabou, ghost tails, cats tails, bucher tails. | ||
| kdawg |
| ||
Posts: 784 | Depending on water clarity, colors will vary but in the spring, Mepps Musky Killers, then Giant Killers throughout the rest of the season. Kdawg | ||
| C_Nelson |
| ||
Posts: 578 Location: Sheboygan Falls, WI | . Edited by C_Nelson 6/7/2008 12:36 PM | ||
| Scott Webster |
| ||
| Hey Corey, I will change your mind when I get yours made!!! At least I hope to. Scott | |||
| The Yeti |
| ||
| i got some Bayboos from Jim today..man they look nice. if i get out this weekend, i'll put them thru the wringer and put a thought or 2 up. thanx jim, they look spectacular!! G | |||
| Kingfisher |
| ||
Posts: 1106 Location: Muskegon Michigan | Spinline single tails because they are the right weight to bulge easily. The Indiana Blades have that certain thump. A black one gave me a 9 fish day this year. The double tail has so much hair you would think you were back in the 80's. Kingfisher | ||
| Reelwise |
| ||
Posts: 1636 | Mepps Maribou! To be honest, I dont think I have caught a muskie on any other bucktail. If there is a hot bucktail bite I always have one on while the other person usually throws a flasher, buchertail, land o lakes, etc. | ||
| ESOXER |
| ||
Posts: 232 Location: Sun Prairie, WI | I prefer a Sugartale by Berg Lures. Color depending on conditions and which lake. | ||
| firstsixfeet |
| ||
Posts: 2361 | I am happy with a mepps #5, a tandem mepps, a funky chicken?(not sure what Shumway calls his straight bucktail), and a magnum bootail. I am sure there are other good tails, but those give a nice range of size and speed, and provide a nice rotation of bucktails. I am pretty sure that there is usually a best bucktail on any given lake, and any given day, and that you won't always hit it on the nose, but your should have at least a small rotation to offer a choice. | ||
| CowgirlAddict |
| ||
Location: Minnesota | Double Cowgirl Blk/Silver | ||
| Hammskie |
| ||
Posts: 697 Location: Minnetonka | Yeah... YOU'RE addicted... the FISH are addicted... cuz Cowgirls are like a drug... best legal buzz around if you gotz the cash. | ||
| turgeon |
| ||
| Cowgirls..... if you aren't throwin them, your NOT fishin. Absolutly the most productive bait I have ever thrown. | |||
| 2Rodknocker |
| ||
Posts: 459 Location: New Baden IL | My favorites are the LLungen Tails hands down. There is something about those skirts that make them crack for fish. They are built like a tank and that shrink wrapped hook seals the deal for me! There are some new Llungen Tails in the works...keep your eyes out for them too! My second favorite are any of Shumway's Flashers or Hot Tails. When the fish are on a bucktail bite, Man is that the best! Rodney LaCaze | ||
| 2Rodknocker |
| ||
Posts: 459 Location: New Baden IL | My favorites are the LLungen Tails hands down. There is something about those skirts that make them crack for fish. They are built like a tank and that shrink wrapped hook seals the deal for me! There are some new Llungen Tails in the works...keep your eyes out for them too! My second favorite are any of Shumway's Flashers or Hot Tails. When the fish are on a bucktail bite, Man is that the best! Rodney LaCaze | ||
| harley |
| ||
Posts: 19 | Double Cowgirl is the ticket. Great bucktail to throw at night and just about anytime. BN got me hooked on those things. Thanks Brad, now my pocket book is lighter...haha Going to be making plenty of those double bladed bucktails this winter. Boy, it is going to be a long....winter. | ||
| MuskyJay |
| ||
Posts: 734 | By far the Cowgirl, 52 out of 61, for me this year. | ||
| Schuler |
| ||
Posts: 1462 Location: Davenport, IA | If it wasn't made by me, I don't own it. Not a big differance between brands. Find what kind of hair you want and what kind of blade. | ||
| Hunter4 |
| ||
Posts: 720 | Hi all, Any tail made by Ron Douglas at Crazy "D" Tackle. Always were for me and I can get them made to order specs and colors. Ron also stands behind them 100%. You just can't beat them. Dave | ||
| dannyboy |
| ||
Posts: 54 | ducktails www.ducktaillures.com bootails www.bootail.com trappertails good luck to all dannyboy www.dannyboysguideservice.com | ||
| Jump to page : 1 Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page] |
| Search this forum Printer friendly version E-mail a link to this thread |


Copyright © 2026 OutdoorsFIRST Media |