Muskie Discussion Forums

Forums | Calendars | Albums | Quotes | Language | Blogs Search | Statistics | User Listing
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )
Moderators: Slamr

View previous thread :: View next thread
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]

Muskie Fishing -> General Discussion -> If the muskie god let you choose
 
Message Subject: If the muskie god let you choose

Posted 1/5/2002 11:44 AM (#1075)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


You get a week on LOTW and you can choose what you get to catch...

What would you choose? and Why?

A. 9 fish week, 35,35,36,37,37,38,38.5,39,41
B. 7 fish week, 35,35,37,39,39.5,42,48
c. 5 fish week, 38,39,40,44,48
d. 3 fish week, 45,46,48
e. 1 fish week, 50
f. ? fish week, A boatside hit and a 50% chance at at 54"

Posted 1/5/2002 12:04 PM (#18253)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


Mmmm..how about (F) all of the above,sometimes you just have to catch all of them.

Posted 1/5/2002 12:58 PM (#18254)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


I would take "A",can they all be on Topwater as well?

Posted 1/5/2002 1:01 PM (#18255)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


DUDE,Thats an easy one!!!!!!!!( B )cause 7 fish with a 4footer would be AWESOME! Jeff

Posted 1/5/2002 1:44 PM (#18256)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


I would have to say E, because thats always been a goal of mine and if I go to LOTW I feel I have one of the best chances to put a 50 in the boat.

Good topic,

BrettC

Posted 1/5/2002 3:16 PM (#18257)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


I think I would have to go with B, that would give me my biggest ever and a whole lot of fun for the week.

Dave

Posted 1/5/2002 4:08 PM (#18258)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


Let's see. I did the "A" thing to years ago. What a blast. Then last fall, I did the "E" thing, 'cept the fish was only 35".[:praise:]

I guess for my next trip, I'd go with "B". Good numbers, lot's of fun, and the 48 would be a personal best also. Plus, it would do wonders for my confidence, after my 1 less-than-50" fish trip there last fall.[:((]

Yup, I'd take "B" this next time. A real "E" will come when it's my turn........maybe.

Tight lines,

Shep[:bigsmile:]

Posted 1/5/2002 4:15 PM (#18259)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


OK....I just ADDED one more...to really make you guys think...

Anyone want to change there minds?

Posted 1/5/2002 5:24 PM (#18260)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


Ill also go with B .1 good fish and enough average fish for a very successful week.

Posted 1/5/2002 5:41 PM (#18261)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


I wouldn't drive to lake of the woods for any of those as I can look forward to a week with an b-d-e here anytime at worse.

But if I was to fish anywhere for an entire week I would have to go the numbers way man 9 fish is barely more then 1 a day, I would go nut to just get 3 fish or less in a week.

I must be spoiled.[:sun:]

Posted 1/5/2002 6:38 PM (#18262)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


Got to be "B".7 fish with 2 over 40 and nothing under 35" is a pretty good average to me and I'm sure if I caught that many then I've seen several others and that ,to me, is the rush that I live for . If I caught a 48" in that week then I have probably seen others in that class. I'm shaking just thinking about...............[8)]

Posted 1/5/2002 6:47 PM (#18263)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


My choice is either E or F. The realistic chance at a big fish is why I go to LOTW in the fall.Good Luck to all,Paul

Posted 1/5/2002 7:57 PM (#18264)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


Smitherious strikes again.

If these were numbers for the boat I do not think I would want to make the drive all the way to Canada, although D might give me itchy feet. If these were only my numbers I would be happy with A through D if my partner also got A through D. Any combination would suite.

Posted 1/5/2002 9:54 PM (#18265)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


I would go for all of them but since you make me choose just one, B sounds like a good week.

Posted 1/6/2002 9:04 AM (#18266)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


If I were able to choose one I would choose....C.... a fish a day and of decent size. I could fish for other more edible species for shorelunch in between, and take in the sites.[:halo:]

Posted 1/7/2002 11:53 AM (#18267)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


I guess my wife does not want a fifty. Hmmmm[:)]

Posted 1/7/2002 12:36 PM (#18268)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


I'd take 'C'. ! fish a day, getting progressively bigger, finishing off with a 4-footer. That would be a great week. I'd even let my wife catch the 3 smaller ones. Besides, if I catch 5 in a week, that means that I'll probably have at least 10 follows and 5 other strikes.....I'll take it. Where do I apply?
One more thing, can I catch the 48 on a Creature? That would be icing on the cake.
Beav

Posted 1/7/2002 1:09 PM (#18269)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


b, definately

Posted 1/7/2002 1:23 PM (#18270)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


I'd still stick with E. I'd rather catch a 50" fish then have a 50% chance at a 54+" fish.

BrettC

Posted 1/7/2002 2:16 PM (#18271)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


B sounds good to me, but a chance at a 54"...... uh...cold shower time.[:0]
Rob

www.showseasonrocks.com

Posted 1/8/2002 5:50 AM (#18272)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


If I'm with my son than I would like "A" (along with about 5 dozen walleye's and a few dozen pike)
If it was for me than "D" "E" or "F" would work.

Posted 1/8/2002 7:07 AM (#18273)
Subject: If the muskie god let you choose


Quality not quantity, I would go for the 54 or better

Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete all cookies set by this site)