Muskie Discussion Forums

Forums | Calendars | Albums | Quotes | Language | Blogs Search | Statistics | User Listing
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )
Moderators: Slamr

View previous thread :: View next thread
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]

Muskie Fishing -> General Discussion -> What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie
 
What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie
OptionAdded byResults
Speed TrollingCory Toker7 Votes - [5.47%]
Planner board trollingCory Toker4 Votes - [3.12%]
Bucktail castingCory Toker20 Votes - [15.62%]
Slow trollingCory Toker3 Votes - [2.34%]
creature jiggingCory Toker4 Votes - [3.12%]
Casting bulldawgsCory Toker4 Votes - [3.12%]
Jerk bait CastingCory Toker10 Votes - [7.81%]
Casting CrankbaitsCory Toker7 Votes - [5.47%]
Glide bait castingCory Toker10 Votes - [7.81%]
Sucker riggingCory Toker1 Votes - [0.78%]
TopwaterCory Toker15 Votes - [11.72%]
Medium Speed Trolling (3 to 5 MPH)AFChief9 Votes - [7.03%]
Casting, Casting, Castingkevin12 Votes - [9.38%]
Spinner Bait Casting7 Votes - [5.47%]
By Sharp HooksSteve Van Lieshout2 Votes - [1.56%]
TwitchingESOX Maniac7 Votes - [5.47%]
spearingTECK6 Votes - [4.69%]
Add your own option:
This is a multiple choice poll.

Message Subject: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie
Cory Toker
Posted 12/21/2003 8:40 PM (#91361)
Subject: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 240


What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie. Another words, what do you find produces the best for you. Please also tell me when your method works the best and structure you use it on.

Thanks
Cory Toker
Cory Toker
Posted 12/21/2003 8:46 PM (#91362 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 240


So far Speed trolling has been the biggest producer for me. Where talking 4.5 to 7 mph. I troll breaklines, reefs, points and shore lines with stucture protruding from them. I use this from depths of 10 feet to 25 feet. Works great from August to November. I am learning other methods, but this one produces the best so far.

Cory Toker
ToddM
Posted 12/21/2003 9:05 PM (#91368 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie





Posts: 20218


Location: oswego, il
Trolling definitely puts the most fish in our boat. We planer board troll up to about 6mph. In late fall we just put the motor in gear which ends up being almost 3mph.
RAZE1
Posted 12/21/2003 9:51 PM (#91372 - in reply to #91368)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie





Posts: 938


Location: NeverNever Lake
Speed casting Bulldawgs. Rippin as fast as the rotor cuff's allow.
kevin
Posted 12/21/2003 10:26 PM (#91376 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie





Posts: 1335


Location: Chicago, Beverly
Just casting.. I really don't have just one lure or technique, I switch baits around a lot. I think my key to success is just keeping the baits in the water.
husky_jerk
Posted 12/22/2003 7:41 AM (#91388 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 305


Location: Illinois
Definitely trolling has put more and bigger fish in my boat the last few years. One technique that has helped is the third man in the boat. By that I mean when I am casting I like to put the trolling motor on 3 or 4 and trail a creeper behind the boat about twenty five feet. I use a rod holder and the creeper gets eaten occassionally by fish we have just brought to the boat. Of course, I don't do this in trolling restricted waters or waters that limit lines per angler to one.Give it a try.
ESOX Maniac
Posted 12/22/2003 8:23 AM (#91396 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie





Posts: 2753


Location: Mauston, Wisconsin

Maybe instead of twitching, I should have said very spastic retrieve, i.e., erratic w/ speed changes, jerks, twitches, pulls, rips, etc. I want to get their attention! It seems to work for me. When others are watching me fishing they probably think I'm a real spastic. I have a new tactic for this year to try and convert those lookers/followers.

"All Water is Zalt Water"

Al Warner

hhtp://www.zaltnad.com

Mr.Pike
Posted 12/22/2003 11:00 AM (#91415 - in reply to #91396)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 466


Location: Pittsburgh, PA
casting, casting, casting. in my magical bay of muskies, open water, into and around timber. bucktails and undertakers have accounted for 92% of my fish.

Posted 12/22/2003 12:04 PM (#91420 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie


crazycanuck
Posted 12/22/2003 1:03 PM (#91427 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie





Posts: 105


Location: Kawartha Lakes, Ontario
On a good day I can get 6 fish by casting, and a bad day can produce a big donut. Trolling, on the other hand, will consistently produce fish for me, and they are bigger on average than those caught casting. 3 to 3.5mph is my standard speed and primary dropoffs and breaklines are my most productive areas. As with any type of fishing, different conditions will require different approaches, and adapting to these dynamic variables will always be the key to success.
Cory Toker
Posted 12/22/2003 3:24 PM (#91434 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 240


Okay, who is the wise guy that added spearing?
That is not an acceptable form of muskie fishing.

Cory
kevin
Posted 12/22/2003 4:03 PM (#91439 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie





Posts: 1335


Location: Chicago, Beverly
Hey Cory, the scarey part is that it has 4 votes....
Snowcrest 6
Posted 12/22/2003 5:00 PM (#91444 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 303


Location: Valentine, NE USA
Spinnerbaits are my go to lure. Weedlines, drop-offs, points, and bangin' them through the stumps...trolled at 4-6 mph usually productive, too.


Brian
pbrostuen
Posted 12/22/2003 9:53 PM (#91485 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 158


Location: Eagan, MN
Casting bucktails to weeds and shallow structure --- hands down. Classics become classics for a reason. Night fishing is my runner-up.
CiscoKid
Posted 12/23/2003 7:12 AM (#91494 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie





Posts: 1906


Location: Oconto Falls, WI
Definitely casting a crankbait. Or perhaps I should say ripping/twitching crankbaits.
Cory Toker
Posted 12/24/2003 9:40 AM (#91567 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 240


This is going great so far. Lets get a few more in here with some more comments. Thanks Everyone and have a great Christmas!

Cory
muskyboy
Posted 12/24/2003 12:11 PM (#91580 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie


Let's see some more votes! Great poll.
RiverMusky
Posted 12/24/2003 2:52 PM (#91593 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie





Posts: 143


Location: Kentucky

My goto would have to be the bulldawg's. I have had good success with a really crazy erratic retrieve. When the water cool's, I would have to say that a big 2 oz spinnerbait slow rolled thru the timber has also been very good to me.

cpr

Chris

crippler
Posted 12/24/2003 7:17 PM (#91606 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 116


Location: winnipeg manitoba
with my hook in the water. have a good christmas,thanks for the card. craig
Cory Toker
Posted 12/24/2003 7:29 PM (#91608 - in reply to #91606)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie




Posts: 240


Originally written by crippler on 2003-12-24 7:17 PM

with my hook in the water. have a good christmas,thanks for the card. craig


Your a putz! Have a good Christmas!!!

Cory

Posted 12/25/2003 11:07 AM (#91634 - in reply to #91361)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie


TWITCHN' TWITCHN' TWITCHN'
sworrall
Posted 12/27/2003 8:55 AM (#91715 - in reply to #91634)
Subject: RE: What is your most Consistent way of catching a muskie





Posts: 32886


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
SO much depends on the water I am fishing. If I am on the Goon, topwater and Spinnerbaits rule. Sabaskong, the crankbaits and topwater rule. Locally, jigs, topwater, and Suicks/Gliders rule, and conditions are everything. Hard question for me to answer!
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [30 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete all cookies set by this site)