Poll How did you catch your first muskie?
How did you catch your first muskie?
OptionResults
Fishing for muskies49 Votes - [76.56%]
Fishing for northerns2 Votes - [3.12%]
Fishing for walleyes6 Votes - [9.38%]
Fishing for lgmouth bass5 Votes - [7.81%]
Fishing for smmouth bass0 Votes - [0%]
Fishing for panfish0 Votes - [0%]
Fishing for trout1 Votes - [1.56%]
Dangling my toes in water1 Votes - [1.56%]

Otter
Posted 2/23/2003 1:43 PM (#61145)
Subject: How did you catch your first muskie?





Posts: 129


Location: Bemidji, MN-
How did you catch your first muskie?
Tone
Posted 2/23/2003 2:07 PM (#61148 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?




Posts: 215


Location: Wisconsin
Casting off of my Uncle's dock when I was a kid. Caught it on a figure 8! (undersized though.. but still a muskie!!)
ToddM
Posted 2/23/2003 6:06 PM (#61170 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?





Posts: 20279


Location: oswego, il
Caught mine, actually two that day on shabbazoo(known as shabbona back then). I was using a cardianl 3 with a light action rod, 4lb test, casting a floating rapala. They were hybrids and not big but were certainly fun.
muskiejerk
Posted 2/23/2003 7:22 PM (#61184 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?




Posts: 12


Mine was on Pewaukee while fishing for largemouth. I was pitching a plastic worm to some lilly pads and ended up with a 40". Two weeks later I caught another fish on a bass size spinnerbait so I decided maybe I should fish for these things. Haven't fished for anything else since.

Edited by muskiejerk 2/23/2003 7:24 PM
Mark H.
Posted 2/24/2003 7:11 AM (#61229 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?




Posts: 1936


Location: Eau Claire, WI
I got my first one when I was 14 in Oneil Creek right below the Leinie's brewery in Chippewa Falls.

I was standing on some rocks in the middle of the creek casting a beetle spin into a slack water area and got a undersized fish. My first legal was caught actually while hoping to catch a muskie but I was just out fishing.
sworrall
Posted 4/8/2003 11:19 AM (#66256 - in reply to #61229)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?





Posts: 32957


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
I got mine with my Dad when I was a teenager. We were fishing Bone Lake for Bass, and Muskies if one took my jig. One did!
Fish-n-Freak
Posted 4/8/2003 12:00 PM (#66260 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?




Posts: 259


Location: Alexandria, MN
My first came casting a crankbait at night, I have always liked night fishing.

Most of my multiple fish days have come on the Jackpot!

Good Fishing!
Freak
Musky Fever
Posted 4/8/2003 2:11 PM (#66275 - in reply to #66260)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?





Location: Illinois-Indiana
Steve, why did I know you were going to say that you caught your first one on a jig.:)

I caught mine while walleye fishing with my dad on Lac View Desert.
Lightning
Posted 4/8/2003 3:15 PM (#66291 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?





Posts: 485


Location: On my favorite lake!
I caught mine throwing a 5 inch rattle spot that they don't make anymore. I was 12 and it was the first time I fished for them. I still have the lure and have retired it. It was a 38 in.
Steve Jonesi
Posted 4/8/2003 6:50 PM (#66316 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?




Posts: 2089


1975 on a Beetle Spin off the dock on Upper Post Lake 25".1ST legal was Sept.25,1977 31" on a 7" yellow Suick,5'3" Fenwick Lunkerstik and a Cardinal 4, 12lb Stren and no leader.I actually still have the combo. I'm thinking of letting my daughter or son use it this year to see if it'll work for 2 generations. If they're anything like mom, they'll be reachin' for the good stuff in no time.Great thread, brought back a lot of memories of a much simpler time.Good Luck this season. Steve

Posted 4/8/2003 7:03 PM (#66317 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?


I caught my first Muskie on Indian Lake, Ontario on a jointed Red & White River Runt, it was a 36 inch fish and the guide was none other than Andre Fluffe'. I've caught quite a few since then but I'll never forget that very first one.
Bill Schwartz - Slam
Posted 4/9/2003 5:38 AM (#66350 - in reply to #66275)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?




Posts: 956


Was Spoonplugging out on Pewaukee.

Posted 4/9/2003 9:20 AM (#66371 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?



Posted 4/9/2003 9:26 AM (#66373 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?


I caught my fist muskie last Oct i was out bass fishing. I was throwing a baby torpedo on 4lb test with a 4 1/2' ultralight and a 24" muskie hit it 4 times before it hooked up . Sense then I've caught a few more and I don't fish for anyting else.
Cory Toker
Posted 4/9/2003 10:46 AM (#66390 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?




Posts: 240


Fishing for muskies speed trolling a 8" Swimwize in a pearch color. Speed trolling has worked great for me with most of my muskies coming that way.
Schuler
Posted 4/9/2003 4:33 PM (#66428 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?





Posts: 1462


Location: Davenport, IA
I caught my first trolling a 10" jointed believer. That was before I knew how deep any of the water was. I didn't even have a fishfinder.
Goltz1
Posted 4/10/2003 6:18 AM (#66447 - in reply to #61145)
Subject: RE: How did you catch your first muskie?




Posts: 20


There was a local police officer down here a couple years ago draging his big toe in the water and he did land his first musky. I believe the fish was around the 30" range. This guy kept the undersized fish and initially received a fine from the DNR for keeping and undersized fish and catching a fish illegally. The charges were dropped. The gentleman did receive approximately 70 stiches.