Should I stay or should I go??
bigfish44
Posted 10/12/2013 10:36 AM (#668165)
Subject: Should I stay or should I go??




Posts: 41


I just found out I have a chance to go to Minneapolis the week of Nov 11 for vacation and will be able to fish all I want. Which is a dream for me, but I was planning on fishing St. Clair that week which is usually prime time.
So my dilema is, I can go to Minneapolis or stay home and save the vacation until St. Clair is prime.
I've always wanted to muskie fish in Minnesota but I've yet to have the chance, so that would be great! I know there are great lakes I'd love to fish, but I'd have to find someone to fish with or fish new waters by myself. Or I can save the vacation, stay home and go to St.Clair whenever it's prime (I live 3hrs away and have confidence fishing there).
Should I go to Minneapolis or stay home and go to St. Clair?
muskie_man
Posted 10/12/2013 10:52 AM (#668166 - in reply to #668165)
Subject: Re: Should I stay or should I go??





Posts: 1237


Location: South Portsmouth, KY		Clair
muskieman6
Posted 10/12/2013 10:53 AM (#668168 - in reply to #668165)
Subject: RE: Should I stay or should I go??




Posts: 91


Location: Metro , Mille Lacs, and G. Rapids		Id say go for it! Lots of great lakes here in MN ! Lakes with both numbers and size!
Reggie54
Posted 10/12/2013 11:03 AM (#668171 - in reply to #668165)
Subject: Re: Should I stay or should I go??




Posts: 98


I'd say you're crazy to pass up prime time on arguably the best musky water in the world to go to MPLS. But what do I know, good luck either way.
psv
Posted 10/12/2013 11:18 AM (#668172 - in reply to #668165)
Subject: Re: Should I stay or should I go??




Posts: 469


Location: MN		I'd rather stay and fish St Clair.
0723
Posted 10/12/2013 12:55 PM (#668180 - in reply to #668172)
Subject: Re: Should I stay or should I go??




Posts: 5193


U should stay and invite me!
Kirby Budrow
Posted 10/12/2013 1:57 PM (#668189 - in reply to #668165)
Subject: Re: Should I stay or should I go??





Posts: 2381


Location: Chisholm, MN		Moet people from MN would like to have a shot at st Clair over metro muskies
ErockEsox
Posted 10/12/2013 2:06 PM (#668192 - in reply to #668165)
Subject: Re: Should I stay or should I go??




Posts: 118


I'd leave the metro in a minute for St Claire.
muskyhunter47
Posted 10/12/2013 3:37 PM (#668203 - in reply to #668192)
Subject: Re: Should I stay or should I go??




Posts: 1638


Location: Minnesota		why leave great water for ok water ? I live in the north metro I fished st.clair once I would stay where your at before coming here. know if you could get a trip with Jason hamernic and fish mille lac lake that's another story.
woodieb8
Posted 10/12/2013 5:40 PM (#668218 - in reply to #668165)
Subject: Re: Should I stay or should I go??




Posts: 1530


st clair my buddy went 15for 21 t-day.. as it cools the big girls head for the buffet table
muskymagnet
Posted 10/14/2013 7:17 AM (#668407 - in reply to #668165)
Subject: Re: Should I stay or should I go??




Posts: 93


I've been to both, and keep going back to st. clair because it NEVER disappoints. Last year in Minneapolis, I basically got skunked after 3 days. If I go 3 hours on Clair, something's wrong. Call Spencer Berman, Matt Quintano, or Kevin Long.