What makes muskies so fragile?
dami0101
Posted 7/26/2013 10:43 AM (#653719)
Subject: What makes muskies so fragile?





Posts: 750


Location: Minneapolis, MN
I caught my first muskie last night and spent a few minutes working on her in the water before she swam off. On the way home my dad and I were talking about how fragile muskies seem to be for such a big fish. I mean you keep a bass out of water for longer than a muskie and it just swims away when you toss it back. So what's the deal?
FAT-SKI
Posted 7/26/2013 10:50 AM (#653722 - in reply to #653719)
Subject: RE: What makes muskies so fragile?




Posts: 1360


Location: Lake "y" cause lake"x" got over fished
I know you have a different question, but...

CONGRATS MAN!!!!!!!!!! What did you get her on? how big was she? The first one is the one you will never forget. Welcom to the dark side.

dami0101
Posted 7/26/2013 11:05 AM (#653724 - in reply to #653722)
Subject: RE: What makes muskies so fragile?





Posts: 750


Location: Minneapolis, MN
Got her on a Black Bullhead (TB custom color) Double Cowgirl. She was 40 inches and I still can't believe I caught her because because she missed the first strike, so I figured she would be gone, but she quickly followed up with a second strike and the fight was on.

Edited by dami0101 7/26/2013 11:41 AM
Adam42
Posted 7/26/2013 11:46 AM (#653736 - in reply to #653719)
Subject: Re: What makes muskies so fragile?




Posts: 46


Location: Plymouth, MN
Yeah man congrats, you never forget that first one.

I've never understood why they are so fragile either. Especially since they are part of the pike family. Pike can take a beating and still swim off right away at full speed. Put a muskie in the same situation and you are trying to revive it for 20 min.

I think size of the fish has a lot to do with it. Most pike caught aren't 40"+. The more mass a fish has the longer it will take to recover. Just an educated guess maybe someone knows a more specific reason why muskies aren't so resilient.
WaubyTackle
Posted 7/26/2013 12:30 PM (#653747 - in reply to #653719)
Subject: Re: What makes muskies so fragile?




Posts: 24


Alot has to do with the temp of the water. When the water is warm it takes more time to revive them. In the fall when the water is cool/cold alot of times they will take off right away, they are alot more spunky with lower water temps.
tjeep
Posted 7/26/2013 1:33 PM (#653758 - in reply to #653719)
Subject: Re: What makes muskies so fragile?




Posts: 26


One of the Lakes I fish, seem to have 2 different strains of fish stocked. Some are very green with bars, even with warm water these fish recover very quickly after a catch even 45"+. The other strain is almost a solid gold with very little markings, these fish no matter what the size seem to take much more care handling. Any one else have opinions about the different strains?