Manufacturers oil or off brand????
Get The Net
Posted 4/29/2013 8:34 PM (#638285)
Subject: Manufacturers oil or off brand????




Posts: 19


Can I get some advice on oil for Optimax? Does a guy buy the Mercury oil that runs about $36-$40 a gallon or buy an off brand like Shell, Valvoline or even Cabelas at $13- $15 a gallon? All are TCW3 as per Mercury manual. If I buy the "cheap" oil I can buy a muskie lure everytime I add a gallon?
VMS
Posted 4/29/2013 8:37 PM (#638287 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 3508


Location: Elk River, Minnesota
Hiya,

If you can do it, I'd split the cost a bit and go for Amsoil... Synthetic so it doesn't smoke a bunch, runs clean in the engine, and you usually can find it under $30 a gallon if you go with a local independent seller.

Steve
Cowboyhannah
Posted 4/29/2013 9:01 PM (#638295 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 1460


Location: Kronenwetter, WI
So....okay...I keep hearing about everyone running amsoil.....I'm running xd-30 in my evinrude ficht and paying about the same as a gallon of amsoil (35$). Since amsoil is 100% synthetic, am I better off running that at the same price?
bdog
Posted 4/30/2013 5:22 AM (#638333 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????




Posts: 357


Location: Duluth, MN
AMSOIL all the way bud. Ive ran it in 4 different outboards without a hitch! Burns clean, no smoke....great stuff.
Just happens to manufactured locally for me as well.
anzomcik
Posted 4/30/2013 10:58 AM (#638409 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 532


Ok lets take this one set further. I am also running XD30 in my johnson and merc kicker, if I make the switch to Amsoil can it be mixed in with the remaining XD30 with my next fill up? Say 5-8 gallons of old premix XD30 (left in the tank) and 15 new gallons of premix Amsoil.
bdog
Posted 4/30/2013 11:41 AM (#638417 - in reply to #638409)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????




Posts: 357


Location: Duluth, MN
I ran out of oil up in Canada one musky opener (dumb me forgot the extra gallon)
and had to mix a jug of quicksilver oil in with a few quarts of amsoil. No issues other than I could notice the smoke and smell of the quicksilver oil. Filled her back up with AMSOIL after I got home, and no issues.

For all practical purposes oil is oil, it all should burn. How efficiently and cleanly, thats another matter altogether.
Top H2O
Posted 4/30/2013 10:29 PM (#638558 - in reply to #638287)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????




Posts: 4080


Location: Elko - Lake Vermilion
VMS - 4/29/2013 8:37 PM

Hiya,

If you can do it, I'd split the cost a bit and go for Amsoil... Synthetic so it doesn't smoke a bunch, runs clean in the engine, and you usually can find it under $30 a gallon if you go with a local independent seller.

Steve

Bingo!
Steve knows his stuff.
VMS
Posted 5/1/2013 12:33 PM (#638625 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 3508


Location: Elk River, Minnesota
Hiya,

What I would suggest is to run the tank down as far as you are comfortable doing, then fill up with amsoil on your next fuel fill. The oils are compatible, so it will not be any sort of issue at all whatsoever.

And most definitely run it in your kickers!! If you do any sort of trolling with a 2 stroke carbed kicker, you will truly enjoy the lack of smoke and smell..especially if you are backtrolling into the wind.

The HP injector is perfect for premix, and those oil injected systems. To be honest, I am unsure of the high pressure direct injected systems for HP injector (they might be calling it just HP) now, but a little research through amsoil will get you to the right product.

Steve
waterwolfhunter
Posted 5/1/2013 1:12 PM (#638633 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 131


Location: Lake St. Clair
I run quicksilver in my optimax. Much cheaper than mercury oil and runs just as good.
MuskyManiac09
Posted 5/1/2013 3:28 PM (#638661 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 183


Location: Grand Forks ND
Even at $40 a gallon for Optimax oil I feel it is a small price to pay for my piece of mind.
hunter991
Posted 5/2/2013 8:42 AM (#638767 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????




Posts: 139


i run quicksilver premium plus ($28 a gallon at walmart) in all my 2S outboards. Never had an issue. Its made by mercury.
erico
Posted 5/2/2013 12:29 PM (#638813 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Location: Hayward WI
I've heard of other guys buying from Domo Oil online, looks like I can get Mercury DFI oil for $29/gallon, might be placing an order. http://www.domo-online.com/Outboard-Motor-Oil/discount-outboard-mot...
Jason Bomber
Posted 5/2/2013 12:55 PM (#638816 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 574


I'm glad VMS brought up the independent dealer for the AMSoil.. That's all I've used in any of the 2 strokes I've had.. Never had an issue and I think it smells and smokes less than the Manufacturers brand stuff.

Just paid $42 a gallon for the AMS 2 weeks ago.. Called one of the independent dealers yesterday, and was told $30-$32..
bdog
Posted 5/2/2013 1:26 PM (#638820 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????




Posts: 357


Location: Duluth, MN
Yep way cheaper from the independant dealers. My brother is one and I can get a 4 gallon case of HP injector from him for about a $120. Pretty reasonable for a seasons worth the oil!
Cowboyhannah
Posted 5/2/2013 8:24 PM (#638888 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 1460


Location: Kronenwetter, WI
Found a local independent dealer will call for pricing

Edited by Cowboyhannah 5/2/2013 8:34 PM
SteveHulbert
Posted 5/7/2013 9:10 PM (#639871 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 202


Location: Angola, IN
There are a lot of really good 2-stroke oils out there. Red Line, Motul, and Maxima to name a few...all of which are rated much higher than Amsoil. I know Amsoil has a huge following in North Woods....but I wanted to chime in here with 2-stroke oils that people trust in their ultra-high performance 2-stroke engines. People with $20k-$50k in a 2-stroke engine either run Red Line or Maxima oils. These are mechanics who tear these engines apart after every race and can see week-to-week how much better these oils protect versus other products.
http://www.redlineoil.com/product.aspx?pid=22&pcid=16

Torco makes some of the best oils out there as well. I've never used their 2-stroke oil, but here is a link to their PWC offering:
http://www.torcousa.com/torco_product/pwc.html

Edited by SteveHulbert 5/7/2013 9:43 PM
VMS
Posted 5/9/2013 12:06 PM (#640229 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 3508


Location: Elk River, Minnesota
Steve,

What kind of prices do those product carry per gallon?

Steve
jasond
Posted 5/10/2013 2:34 PM (#640442 - in reply to #638813)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????




Posts: 187


Location: West Metro, MN
Has anybody had any issues with using Quicksilver Premium Plus in a Yamaha 2 Stroke? Like other have stated it was about $16 a gallon cheaper than Yamalube so i figued i would give it a try as long as it won't cause issues. Thanks.
deweymedlin
Posted 5/11/2013 6:24 AM (#640524 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????




Posts: 1


Location: Yonkers
I always go with the quality not a price. So I always buy the quality oil.

Edited by deweymedlin 5/11/2013 6:26 AM
horsehunter
Posted 5/11/2013 7:07 AM (#640527 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????




Location: Eastern Ontario
None of the outboard manufactures make their own oil it's packaged for them by an OIL company. Before retiring I worked for a large cheese manufacturer / processor and did a lot of private label business for Restaurant and Food chains and when switching from one to the next the only thing that changed was the packaging
kjgmh
Posted 5/11/2013 9:21 AM (#640538 - in reply to #638285)
Subject: Re: Manufacturers oil or off brand????





Posts: 1096


Location: Hayward, WI
You can tell just by looking at the inside of the prop on an Optimax if they are running a cheap oil. The only oils that I have seen that will not have the prop sooted up, that I have seen, are Optimax oil and Amsoil. There may be more but those are the 2 that I have seen. These also seem to help with a longer spark plug life, which can get expensive at $16-19 each for spark plugs.