5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!
wkeegobbler
Posted 10/22/2012 9:33 PM (#592616)
Subject: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!





Posts: 323


Location: Waukee, IA
Ok.....I am horribly weak in my bucktail selection currently. In fact, I honestly don't even own ONE DCG. I have a couple buchertails but that is it. If you could have only 5 colors to throw in your arsenal...what blade/skirt combos could you NOT live without? Irregardless of water clarity, time of year, etc. I want your go-to color combos.

Thanks for considering!!

Feel free to PM me if you don't want to share your colors with the entire musky world!
Nolan
Posted 10/22/2012 9:51 PM (#592629 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Black/Nickle Red/Brass Walleye/Gold Purple/Gold White/Silver
muskellunged
Posted 10/22/2012 10:06 PM (#592637 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!





Location: Illinois
Black/Black
Nickel/Black
Orange/Black
Gold/Purple
Copper/Red
milje
Posted 10/22/2012 10:24 PM (#592645 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 410


Location: Wakefield, MI
Black/Orange blade
White/Nickel blade
Brown/Brown Trout blade (or Red and white blade) from Mepps
Plunker
Posted 10/22/2012 11:56 PM (#592665 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 307


Black/black
black_dawg
Posted 10/23/2012 4:55 AM (#592676 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!





Posts: 173


Location: Green Bay, Titletown, WI
Chatreuse/black
copper/copper
nickel/black

Zib
Posted 10/23/2012 7:59 AM (#592691 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: RE: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!





Posts: 1405


Location: Detroit River
Black/Nickle
White/Nickle
Red/Copper
Fluorecent Yellow/Brass (Hulk Hogan)
Pink/Nickle
FAT-SKI
Posted 10/23/2012 8:23 AM (#592701 - in reply to #592691)
Subject: RE: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 1360


Location: Lake "y" cause lake"x" got over fished
Black/Nickle
Black/Orange
Black-Chartreuse/chartreuse flame
Purple/Gold
Blue-Pearl/Black Nickle
The Swan
Posted 10/23/2012 11:07 AM (#592743 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: RE: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!


Silver blade, black tail.
Gold blade, brown tail.
Gold blade, yellow tail.
Firetiger blade, black tail.
Silver blade, white tail with red feather.
Brad P
Posted 10/23/2012 11:14 AM (#592745 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 833


I can't narrow it down that far...
BNelson
Posted 10/23/2012 11:14 AM (#592746 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!





Location: Contrarian Island
blade/flash
black nickel/black holo
chart/black
gold/purple
black nickel/purple
one gold blade, one chart/ salt n pepper
Skyblaster
Posted 10/23/2012 3:46 PM (#592836 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 190


Location: Savage, MN
Nickel blade/ black skirt.
Gun metal blade/ red with little black skirt.
Gun metal blade/ white & silver skirt.
Gold blade/ gold skirt
Durado DCG. (Can't accurately describe colors)
Musky Face
Posted 10/23/2012 9:38 PM (#592962 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 558


Brown with gold blades
Black with black blades
Black with silver blades
Black with orange blades and
Blue/nickle with silver blades oh ya and copper with copper blades.
esoxaddict
Posted 10/23/2012 9:50 PM (#592970 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!





Posts: 8781


Black/Silver blades
Black/Gold blades
Black/Orange blades
Black/Smoke blades
Brown/Copper or Gold blades

All the rest is fluff. Fluff is fun, don't get me wrong. I caught 3 fish in one day on the ugliest color combination I have ever seen, but if I had to pick, those would be my five.
schleprock82
Posted 10/24/2012 6:10 AM (#593015 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: RE: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 99


Green blades black skirt has been my most productive.
fishhawk50
Posted 10/24/2012 4:50 PM (#593219 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 1416


Location: oconomowoc, wi
any pattern..as long as its black
Pal
Posted 10/25/2012 8:08 AM (#593389 - in reply to #593219)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 665


Location: Twin Cities, MN
5, I am not sure I an live with just 5..... for any variety of bucktails.

That being said, the below are the ones that got the most use last year

Double 8 Gerry's Girl Blue with flame blades
Double 10 Black Perch Cowgirl with firetiger / black blades
Double 10 Bluegill Spanky with smoke blades
Double 8 black with black blades - homemade
Double 10 Gerry's girl candy corn with flame blades
wkeegobbler
Posted 10/26/2012 9:37 PM (#593829 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: RE: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!





Posts: 323


Location: Waukee, IA
Well, I tried to summarize as best I could with all your suggestions.....I didn't get every single one but I think it shows some trends......BLACK is awfully popular!
If anybody else has suggestions feel free to post and I will update totals.

Skirt Blade Total
Black Nickel 12
Black Orange 9
Black Black 7
Black Chartreuse 6
Red Copper/Brass/Gold 4
White Nickel 6
Purple Gold 3
Brown Gold 3
Blue Black 3
Black Gold 2
Blue Nickel 3
Blue Black 2
Black Green 1
Blue Flame 1
Copper Copper 1
Red Nickel 1
Green Copper 1
Yellow Gold 1
Pink Pink 1
Purple Black Nickel 1
rich
Posted 10/28/2012 6:49 PM (#594081 - in reply to #593829)
Subject: RE: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 133


Gold/gold has done well for me, as well as black/black and my goto nickle/black, nickle/red as well as orange/black.
tincan
Posted 10/30/2012 1:16 PM (#594692 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!





Posts: 63


black/ nickel
yellow/ gold
white/ nickel
blue/ nickel
black/ orange
muddymusky
Posted 10/30/2012 1:27 PM (#594701 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: RE: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 569


Nickle/Black
Nickle/White
Orange/Black
Copper/Green
Pink/Pink
Matt DeVos
Posted 10/30/2012 2:59 PM (#594718 - in reply to #592616)
Subject: Re: 5 bucktail colors you CANNOT live without!




Posts: 580


There are really only two color combo's that I wouldn't be without:

-Black Nickel blades over black body (for any sky conditions, sunny or cloudy, dusk, midday, etc.)
-Chartreuse blades over black body (I like the bright blades in overcast conditions)

I have dozens and dozens of other colors, but the two above are all that I really need.