Poll $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.
$200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.
OptionResults
Used Calcutta 400 TE8 Votes - [12.31%]
New Calcutta 400 B20 Votes - [30.77%]
New Daiwa Luna/Croix Avid12 Votes - [18.46%]
New 5.4:1 Revo Toro - They can still be found : )20 Votes - [30.77%]
Abu Record 601 Votes - [1.54%]
Zebco 334 Votes - [6.15%]
Add your own option:

RushFan2112
Posted 2/25/2012 8:52 AM (#541483)
Subject: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.


Hey All, I'm about to upgrade my musky rig for the first time in many years and am looking for some advice. If you had around $200 (give or take $40) to spend on a new "all-purpose" reel, which would you choose and why? I would love a 400 TE, but the $360 price tag is just too steep for a reel that I'll only use 10 days a season. I've used Abu C3's for the past 10 years and am ready to treat myself a little bit after the tax return. Feel free to add any options that I may have missed.
joemsanderson
Posted 2/25/2012 9:53 AM (#541497 - in reply to #541483)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.




Posts: 150


Location: Central Minnesota
Spend the extra 100$ and get the 400 TE. You wont be sorry.
Ronix
Posted 2/25/2012 10:31 AM (#541505 - in reply to #541497)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.




Posts: 981


joemsanderson - 2/25/2012 10:53 AM

Spend the extra 100$ and get the 400 TE. You wont be sorry.


agreed. or the toro 61 5:4:1 would be a nice choice but good luck finding that
5th lake Brad
Posted 2/25/2012 11:39 AM (#541521 - in reply to #541497)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.





Posts: 537


Location: Gilberts IL/Rhinelander WI
joemsanderson - 2/25/2012 9:53 AM

Spend the extra 100$ and get the 400 TE. You wont be sorry.




Where are you finding the 400Te for $300? I'll take two!
jlammusky
Posted 2/25/2012 11:45 AM (#541522 - in reply to #541483)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.





Posts: 360


Location: montreal, canada
Poeple that answer a revo toro it's only because they don't have it since 3 4 years ... They don't last long because of there chinesse bearing ... Believe me i did a lot of benchmark test on them . Better go with a calcutta or calcutta te or daiwa japanesse last for year and year .
Ronix
Posted 2/25/2012 11:50 AM (#541524 - in reply to #541521)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.




Posts: 981


5th lake Brad - 2/25/2012 12:39 PM

joemsanderson - 2/25/2012 9:53 AM

Spend the extra 100$ and get the 400 TE. You wont be sorry.




Where are you finding the 400Te for $300? I'll take two!


you can find a lot of used ones for that...i picked a 401te from vince weirick for 285 shipped. put a message up saying youre looking for one
TheMuskyMan
Posted 2/25/2012 12:06 PM (#541526 - in reply to #541524)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.




Posts: 339


Location: Maryland
Look at the Okuma Isis IS-400. Good reel for $200 but can be purchased on ebay for $144.44 shipped.
5th lake Brad
Posted 2/25/2012 12:42 PM (#541531 - in reply to #541524)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.





Posts: 537


Location: Gilberts IL/Rhinelander WI
Ronix - 2/25/2012 11:50 AM

5th lake Brad - 2/25/2012 12:39 PM

joemsanderson - 2/25/2012 9:53 AM

Spend the extra 100$ and get the 400 TE. You wont be sorry.




Where are you finding the 400Te for $300? I'll take two!


you can find a lot of used ones for that...i picked a 401te from vince weirick for 285 shipped. put a message up saying youre looking for one




I was thinking new ones for $300, that would be a deal. GAT GUNS in Dundee IL has 401TE's for $335, I would have spent the extra $50 for a new one , especially before buying one from a guide.
pike2772
Posted 2/25/2012 4:57 PM (#541560 - in reply to #541483)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.




Posts: 147


Location: Chesterton, Indiana
The Shimano Calcutta 400B is a very nice dependable reel for $ 229.00
shadowkiller
Posted 2/25/2012 6:01 PM (#541579 - in reply to #541560)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.




Posts: 13


if your looking for a good real try the shimano curado 300e. i recommend this real for 2-5 ounce baits. dont use this reel for dcgs10-13s. it will work for smaller bucktails. or get the calcutta 400b or 400te. all these are good choices but you should choose them based on prefrence and baits. good luck.
makins117
Posted 2/25/2012 6:06 PM (#541580 - in reply to #541483)
Subject: Re: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.




Posts: 84


Location: Buffalo Grove, IL
A website out east recently had a 20% off sale on everything in the store. I think they do this a few times a year. I got a brand new 400 TE for $295.99 shipped. They had the Calcutta 400B for $183.99. That's beside the point of the original post though. Aside from sale prices, I would say a good reel in the $200-240 range would be a 400B or the Luna. I have both and they perform very well.
RushFan2112
Posted 2/25/2012 7:24 PM (#541591 - in reply to #541483)
Subject: RE: $200 Range Reel Choice - If You Could Have Only One.


Wow, thanks for all of the replies and feedback! I should've mentioned that I have a $100 BassPro gift card from wifey, which is a tough call for me because they don't carry the Luna or the old Toro(obviously). With their trade in deal right now, I can also get an additional discount with a trade-in. So, I can essentially get a new Calcutta B for about $100 total out-of-pocket. Even with all of the discounts, a new TE would still cost me $250 out of pocket, which is a bit rich for me. But, I'm paying near retail price and sales tax for both of those reels. My other option is just to use the gift card for a new rod and get a Luna or used TE on E*ay. Dang, I'm torn...

Thanks.