top 5 surface lures
wcmc
Posted 2/11/2012 6:39 PM (#538122)
Subject: top 5 surface lures


hey guys. With so many surface baits on the market today (that cost alot), i dont want to spend too much on surface baits. What is your top 5 surface lures? if you know the color off hand please mention tht as well. thanks
Zib
Posted 2/11/2012 7:05 PM (#538124 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 1405


Location: Detroit River
Not in any particular order because I like them all.

Poe's Havana Jack Jackpot - sucker
Poe's Giant Jackpot - blue/silver
Whopper Plopper - Red Horse
Top Raider - firetiger
Lee's Water Chopper -black/firetail




esox1980
Posted 2/11/2012 7:06 PM (#538125 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 265


Location: Manitowish Waters WI
Jackpot, jackpot, jackpot, jackpot, top raider. Loon pattern and black jackpot
thrax_johnson
Posted 2/11/2012 7:28 PM (#538127 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 313


Location: Bemidji, Lake Vermilion
Hawg Wobbler, Pacemaker, Locomotive, Low Rider, Stillwater. All black all the time.
Bondy
Posted 2/11/2012 7:35 PM (#538129 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 719


Musky Buster Top Walker.
MD75
Posted 2/11/2012 8:03 PM (#538134 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 682


Location: Sycamore, IL
Jackpot/black and orange
Weagle/black
nimmer swimmer/ bull frog
Whopper plopper/red horse
Hi fin creeper/ black

These are the lures that I bring along...i have also had success on the large spro bass frog when the muskies are deep in the slop!
Mak51
Posted 2/11/2012 8:04 PM (#538135 - in reply to #538129)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Location: MN
Lots of good ones out there but here are my five, no particular order:

Weagle - Black
Hawg Wobbler - Black
Lowrider - Orange Tiger?
Pacemaker - Purple, Black
Topraider - Orange Tail/Black Body

Rudedog
Posted 2/11/2012 8:16 PM (#538138 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 625


Location: S.W. WI
TopRaider........Blackbird
9" Doc.............Black
LOW Rider........Black/Chartruess
TopWalker.......blk/chart
Big Game Surface twitch.......any color

-Jon
JKahler
Posted 2/11/2012 8:25 PM (#538139 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 1290


Location: WI
Pacemaker, Creeptonite, Headbanger, Lee's Chopper, Weagle. Most of my topwaters are black or orange.
TC24
Posted 2/12/2012 12:09 AM (#538169 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 175


Location: Tonka, MN
Raider, raider, raider, raider, raided
IAJustin
Posted 2/12/2012 12:25 AM (#538170 - in reply to #538169)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 2019


Love Topwater!, was just sorting them earlier this week - i own 87 topwater baits, good lord...anyway my 5 best producers recently:

1) Weagle
2) Lee's Chopper
3) Top Raider
4) Lee's Fish Stick HD
5) Wood Pacemaker (large)



Pal
Posted 2/12/2012 5:33 AM (#538175 - in reply to #538170)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 670


Location: Twin Cities, MN
Original Lelure water thumper - perch
Lee's Chopper - black
Nimmer Prop Dog - black / yellow
Top Walker - blk/white
Marketti Globe - Yellow/Black
mseybert
Posted 2/12/2012 6:55 AM (#538182 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 443


Location: Indiana
Cady weagle in fire crappie
topraider in baby loon
pacemaker, custom painted in white crappie
muSKI
Posted 2/12/2012 7:13 AM (#538184 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures


topper stopper
muskie Freak
topraider
jackpot
whopper plopper

all black
The Swan
Posted 2/12/2012 8:24 AM (#538197 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures


Ain't no expert, but these are the ones in the box:
Topraider, blackbird and bullfrog
Baby Doc, loon and perch
Poe's Awaker, black with a touch of orange
kodiak
Posted 2/12/2012 9:13 AM (#538200 - in reply to #538197)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 1224


Location: Okoboji
DirdyB. Custom iridecsent green/black
Esoxonthefly421
Posted 2/12/2012 10:00 AM (#538203 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 292


Location: SW MI
Topraider- Baby Loon
Top H2O- Black
Weagle- Cisco or black
Creepenstein- Black
Doc- Loon
WI Skis
Posted 2/12/2012 11:45 AM (#538214 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 547


Location: Oshkosh
Lee Lures Chopper- Black
10 in Weagle- Black
Lee Lures Top H2O HD- Loon
BS Willy Globe- Frog
Lee Lures Creepshow- Frog

Peter
Mullhead
Posted 2/12/2012 1:53 PM (#538227 - in reply to #538214)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 286


Location: VA
Nimmer Prop Dog Plus Frog
Low Rider Black
Musky Town Tackle Hog Head Gold fish
Rylure Chattertail Frog
Lee Lures Chopper HD Fire Tiger

Works for me.
TLmusky
Posted 2/12/2012 1:55 PM (#538228 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures


5.) hawg wobbler- loon
4.) topraider- baby mallard
3.) bucher buzzbait- black
2.) hi fin creeper- black
1.) Gopher Musky Duckling- Cinnamon Green Head (Its expensive and uncommon but its great)... Anybody else use that?

TLmusky
Posted 2/12/2012 1:57 PM (#538229 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures


5.) hawg wobbler- loon
4.) topraider- baby mallard
3.) bucher buzzbait- black
2.) hi fin creeper- black
1.) Gopher Musky Duckling- Cinnamon Green Head (Its expensive and uncommon but its great)... Anybody else use that?

ONMuskie
Posted 2/12/2012 7:02 PM (#538267 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures


Top Raider
Weagle or One-Eyed Willy

I own others, but give me those and I'm set.

Others: Top Walker (if you can keep the line twist down), wooden Pacemaker, Hawg Wobbler.
Mojo1269
Posted 2/12/2012 8:47 PM (#538307 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 753


Pace Maker
Psycho Sister
Whopper Plopper
Weagle
Dirdy B (Only had it for 8 weeks last year it was Money!!)
Jeff Hanson
Posted 2/13/2012 10:36 AM (#538428 - in reply to #538307)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 947


Hawg wobbler
One Eyed Willy JR
Top raider
B.S. Willy Creeper
B.S Willy Globe

Jeff Hanson
madisonmuskyguide.com
MuskieMike
Posted 2/13/2012 10:41 AM (#538429 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures





Location: Des Moines IA
10 in Weagle
Weagle
Top Raider
Small wood Pacemaker with the "Big Hook" modification
Chopper
msky3
Posted 2/13/2012 10:44 AM (#538430 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 309


Location: Elgin IL
This should do it...maybe add a globe


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(5 favorite_1.JPG)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments 5 favorite_1.JPG (62KB - 500 downloads)
Brad P
Posted 2/14/2012 11:29 AM (#538680 - in reply to #538200)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 833


kodiak - 2/12/2012 9:13 AM

DirdyB. Custom iridecsent green/black


I will second this. The Big Mama Topwaters are just awesome.

Also like my cheeto pacemaker.
Guest
Posted 2/14/2012 5:33 PM (#538764 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures


for me, used to be:
topraider, whopper plopper, weagle, homewrecker, lac suel twin turbo

but now, only use thru wire on the prop's (don't ask!), so...
crusader swapped out with topraider tail, koolkat whackker, xps wheel n deal, homewrecker, weagle
muskihntr
Posted 2/14/2012 7:07 PM (#538790 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 2037


Location: lansing, il
One Eyed Willy
Pacemaker
H20
Whopper Plopper
FB Outdoors Snub Nose.


SouperFish
Posted 2/14/2012 9:41 PM (#538834 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Location: Green Bay
Jackpot black and orange
Low Rider black
Homewrecker black
Topraider frog
Creeper black
sworrall
Posted 2/14/2012 9:48 PM (#538836 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 32892


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
Weagle any color
Top Raider and color
Topper Stopper any color
Snodlo any color
Violent Strike Magnum Buzzer Color depends on the sky. More of this lure is under the surface.
whynot
Posted 2/15/2012 7:27 AM (#538869 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 897


Top Raider, Super Top Raider, Pacemaker, 10" Weagle, Hawg Wobbler, maybe throw in a creeper but usually the Hawg wobbler will catch those fish

All black or mostly black
BNelson
Posted 2/15/2012 2:36 PM (#538964 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Location: Contrarian Island
Lee's Chopper
Wolly Pog
Rylure Creepers
Fish Stick
One Eye Willy
80% of my topwaters are Loon pattern...luv it.
nazercl
Posted 2/15/2012 6:59 PM (#539005 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures





Black Tin Head
little one
Posted 2/15/2012 8:06 PM (#539017 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 501


Location: S.Wisconsin
Wick creeper
Chopper
Wick flaptail
One eye willie
My own
Brewski
Posted 2/15/2012 10:06 PM (#539052 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures


Wood magnum "pacemaker"
Trueglide "Heckler"old version is my go to bait . Don't know about the new one yet.
Snodlo

dtaijo174
Posted 2/16/2012 9:00 AM (#539114 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 1169


Location: New Hope MN
Musky Buster Super humper
Guest
Posted 2/16/2012 6:45 PM (#539220 - in reply to #538764)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures


Guest - 2/14/2012 5:33 PM

for me, used to be:
topraider, whopper plopper, weagle, homewrecker, lac suel twin turbo

but now, only use thru wire on the prop's (don't ask!), so...
crusader swapped out with topraider tail, koolkat whackker, xps wheel n deal, homewrecker, weagle


ditto...and you're right, don't ask why they have to be thru wire!!
jganga
Posted 2/16/2012 11:05 PM (#539265 - in reply to #538834)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 15


Location: East Central WI
Anything black
Topraider
Weagle
Hawg Wobbler
Tallywacker, with the rear hook upsized and shrink tubing.
Grass
Posted 2/17/2012 11:56 AM (#539342 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 620


Location: Seymour, WI
Hawg Wobbler
Pace Maker
Top Walker
Weagle
Top Raider
dh buc
Posted 2/17/2012 4:48 PM (#539420 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 134


Hawg Wobbler - especially second day of a cold front -Black
Weagle -Black
Whopper Plopper - Loon
HiFinn Creeper - Black
Top Raider - Black
dh buc
Posted 2/17/2012 4:51 PM (#539421 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 134


Hawg Wobbler - especially second day of a cold front -Black
Weagle -Black
Whopper Plopper - Loon
HiFinn Creeper - Black
Top Raider - Black
jdsplasher
Posted 2/17/2012 8:51 PM (#539472 - in reply to #539421)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 2277


Location: SE, WI.

J. Wick Creeper...drop spreaders

Headbanger

JDsplasher...flaptail

Old Lelure globe

Mag Hog Wobbler

Colors ;  Black,  Black/Orange,  Black/Chartreuse!

dh buc
Posted 2/18/2012 4:29 AM (#539503 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: RE: top 5 surface lures




Posts: 134


Hawg Wobbler - especially second day of a cold front -Black
Weagle -Black
Whopper Plopper - Loon
HiFinn Creeper - Black
Top Raider - Black
Jason Bomber
Posted 2/18/2012 9:05 AM (#539519 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 574


Chopper
One Eyed Willy (mostly Jr)
Fish Stick HD
H2o or Hawg wobbler
LOWrider

Loon, black & firetiger
jaycbs74
Posted 2/18/2012 7:50 PM (#539630 - in reply to #538122)
Subject: Re: top 5 surface lures





Posts: 136


Location: Chicago
bulged bucktail, globe, tailprop,creeper,WTD and black seems to reign supreme