How long did it take you for your first?
TrentM.
Posted 1/8/2012 5:50 PM (#531904)
Subject: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 133


Location: South Bend, Indiana
Just curious to see how long it took everyone to catch their first musky. For me, it has been two years, and running. Still looking for my first. Through 17 attempts, my boat has seen three follows, and one fish that my friend has caught. Surely being optimistic helps, but that can only take you so far. But, how long did it take you?
Kodiak_HL
Posted 1/8/2012 5:59 PM (#531906 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 18


Zip for the first year, ended up with 2 after the second year........ with considerable more then 17 outings..... over those 2 years.
Marshall
Posted 1/8/2012 6:17 PM (#531912 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 406


Location: Stones throw away...finally!!
I was pretty lucky as I look back. The first time I actually went fishing for them I had an arsenal consisting of a medium heavy bass rod paired with an Abu Garcia baitcaster (can't remember the model but do know that it had 20 lb. mono), jointed shallow raider, slammer thunderhead, and a small (by today's standards) Mepps bucktail. I went over to a small lake in Illinois that I had visited (and not fished)with a girlfriend at the time, and saw the DNR legal length pictures of muskies at the ramp (which I was unfamiliar with, but intrigued). About a month later, I borrowed my old man's John boat and went over for the day...no graph, no net, no map...very unprepared. Anyhow, I was by myself, so just went out and started casting shorelines - nothing. After circling better than half the lake (77acres), I decided to take a break and do a little trolling with the Shallow Raider and...wham! About 20 minutes in I had the biggest fish I had ever caught in the boat. 44.5 inches and needless to say I was hooked. Great to look back at how it all started...thank you for starting this thread.
Mike K
Posted 1/8/2012 6:29 PM (#531915 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


first time out was with my buddy and we boated 7 fish between us. ranging from 39" to 45". we had every kind of strike you can imagine. hits on the eight, wake come behind a top waters, train wreck t bone hits it was awesome. and i was forever hooked on these #*^@ fish. it aslo established some unrealistic expectations of what muskie fishing is, obviously. i was asking my friend whats so hard about muskie fishing? fish of 10000 cast my butt. if only i knew...
kid coulson
Posted 1/8/2012 6:31 PM (#531917 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 68


5 months+1 week. Dont know how many outings it was. Caught a few nice pike and had a few follows to keep us going, then it finally happened. 40 incher!
MuskyFix
Posted 1/8/2012 6:59 PM (#531924 - in reply to #531917)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?





6 hours of musky fishing, hit a suick - spin cast rod with 12lb test 1989.
Pedro
Posted 1/8/2012 8:40 PM (#531937 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 670


Location: Otsego, MN
2 hours, my buddy and I both got one each on jackpots. That one fishing trip has now cost me tens of thousands of dollars chasing these stupid fish.
MuskieMike
Posted 1/8/2012 9:31 PM (#531945 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?





Location: Des Moines IA
First day I caught two. A 40 and a 44. But I cheated, had a guide on the Indian Chain in Ontario.


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(Muskie Head upright.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments Muskie Head upright.jpg (59KB - 136 downloads)
Udee2159
Posted 1/8/2012 9:37 PM (#531947 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 87


1 year.

Went fishing with my Dad to Canada, on the last day of the trip I hooked a MONSTER of a musky (probably 36"). It jumped/thrashed/ran and eventually wrapped around a log and was gone. For an entire year I thought about that fish, everday. I read books about muskies, read articles where I could find them, and listened to my Dad about family members who hooked them.

After that tough long year, we made it back to that same lake. It was pretty much out of a book, because we went back to the same spot, with the same lure, and I made the same cast to that same rock. You guessed it. WHAM! I caught my first muskie, a healthy 30".

I'll never forget that fish, even if it's been 15 years since that day. I've caught a few since that one, including a 51" on Lake of the Woods, but that one fish will never be forgotten.
Guest
Posted 1/8/2012 9:47 PM (#531949 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


About a month after we started dating, but to be fair I spent two years trying to convince her to date me.

If you're referring to catching a muskie I was one of the guys that caught on accidentally. To be fair it wasn't a complete accident, as I was attempting to target them, but I was doing so with bass equipment and no musky lures. I got a bunch of real musky stuff and started fishing for them locally, but I didn't catch the next one until my next trip to Canada a year later.
Plunker
Posted 1/8/2012 9:51 PM (#531951 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 307


4 years of hard fishing. Then the tables turned and I went on a bit of a winning streak. Hang in there it will come eventually.
long road
Posted 1/8/2012 9:57 PM (#531953 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


My experience was somewhat like yours in terms of time. I did not have the benefit of knowing an experienced musky angler that I could fish with so I had to learn on my own. The first year I gave it a pretty good attempt and came up empty. I had bad equipment, poor skills and limited experience to draw from. The learning curve for me was pretty harsh but I always felt with every cast that this might be the one and I still feel that all these years later. I caught a few fish the next year and finished the season with my first big one. What a feeling of appreciation and satisfaction to see that first one that you worked so hard for paddle away from a successful release. I still read everything I can get my hands on, I go to Muskies Inc meetings and seminars, I watch the tv shows and all of that stuff is a big part of it but nothing tops productive time spent on the water. Stick with it and it will happen....and if you persist it will slowly start to happen more often. Most importantly remember to enjoy yourself and have fun.
guest
Posted 1/8/2012 10:06 PM (#531954 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


Read the book "time on the water". Keep at it and good luck in 2012!
ghitierman
Posted 1/8/2012 10:39 PM (#531959 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 284


Got my first on my third trip. My second on my fifth trip and it's been 10 years since I put one in the boat. Only get out three times a year but I am loosing the itch.
Guest
Posted 1/8/2012 11:33 PM (#531962 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


If you're seeing fish you're doing alright. I fished from May to October my first year and the only fish I saw locally came in September. Try looking for info of what you should be doing at given times of the year. I attribute a lot of the mistakes I made my first year to just being dumb. I didn't know what I was doing or why I was doing it.

Learn the fish. Learn your lake. Talk to guys on here and other forums. Go to sport shows/clinics. Watch TV shows and read articles. Try to learn as much as you possibly can, but remember that even the guys that are making shows and writing articles are still learning too, and at one point they were in your shoes.
Junkman
Posted 1/9/2012 7:48 AM (#531978 - in reply to #531962)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 1220


It was 1976, I was among the walleye-only guys at the time, fishing with a buddy in the Minouqua area. He talked me into hiring a guide (Crazy Jim) to try musky fishing. I caught a 42 1/2 inch fatty about an hour into the day, the fish went into the box at Bennett's Sport Shop, my picture was taken and posted in the Lakeland Times, fish was mounted and I have been severyly gut-hooked ever since. And, OBTW, that's the last fish that did not swim away. That's almost 35 years now without keeping a second one. Marty Forman
Almost-B-Good
Posted 1/9/2012 8:04 AM (#531980 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 433


Location: Cedarburg, Wisconsin
For my first legal fish it was about 6 years. Caught a few sub 30"ers before that but had a hard time cracking that 30" length. Talking apples and oranges between fishing back in the 60's and now though. Information that people have access to now in less than an hour took me 20 years of trial and error to learn. First legal was 43" and caught my second, a 39"er the next day. So, even then it seems like the first one is the hardest to catch.
HomeTime
Posted 1/9/2012 8:58 AM (#531987 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 247


Location: Uxbridge Ontario
My first muskie was caught about 45 minutes in and was 49" long. Caught 3 that day.

First season muskie fishing I had 36 fish in total. One thing to note, you chances greatly increase when fishing with a seasons muskie angler. Coaching was utilized.
missourimuskyhunter
Posted 1/9/2012 9:45 AM (#531994 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 1316


Location: Lebanon,Mo
Crap...I dont remember. Must of been the year of '95 maybe,with no fish the first year or so and realized I was fishing a lake that averages one fish per 100 hours...
The Swan
Posted 1/9/2012 11:18 AM (#532010 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


Don't despair. It may be that you are fishing waters that are just really tough. Man-made lakes in the southern belt of the musky's range are almost all pressured. There are bass anglers teaching the skis lessons from early spring through late autumn. They learn. Also remember that as top of the line predators, muskys are just a lot rarer that other species.

I got into this mess by hooking an "accidental musky." It escaped with my lure; but I was impressed and started to pursue. It took a long time to get a fish in my hands thereafter--and that was a dink that hit an 8" Depthraider in a federal reservoir. (Still it was a triumph.) In my second year I lost a trophy at boatside. Inadequate knot. I wanted to cry.

Can you get to prime musky water? Lake of the Woods? Lake St. Clair? Hook up with a more experienced angler. ("Please teach me." "I'll cover the gas.")

Ask yourself: What am I doing that is wrong? Are you using lures designed and sized for trophy sized fish? Most fish are not trophy sized. Would down-sizing your lures make a difference? Might. (Have you tried a 5.5" Wiley? Works here.)

Just make sure you are ready when the big hit comes. Is your line sound? Terminal tackle? Will the knots hold? And especially: Do you have an adequate net?

Keep at it; and good luck in 2012.

TrentM.
Posted 1/9/2012 12:17 PM (#532025 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 133


Location: South Bend, Indiana
Love the replies, guys... keep em' coming!!!! Just a little backround info.... I fish the north webster area lakes, mainly the barbee chain or tippy. Would you all consider them pressurred waters, right? I'm not under-equiptted, and have many baits. Also, a great suggestion, I am planning a trip up to lake St. Clair, in the summer. Seems that everyone's most memorable is their first. I'm surely not gonna give up anytime soon!

Hope to see you all in chicago.
BNelson
Posted 1/9/2012 1:22 PM (#532041 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Location: Contrarian Island
1993, first hour casting for muskies my buddy and I both caught ski's of about 37" in northern WI... we had our 5' foot pool cue Gander Mountain rods and Abu 5500s...johnson silver minnow w a yellow twister tail... who knew that hour would cost me so much d*mn $$$ 19 yrs later! ; )
esoxaddict
Posted 1/9/2012 1:24 PM (#532042 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 8782


Caught my first one in 2004 on a sucker, after two days fishing total. I don't really count that one as I was fishing with a guide who set the hook and handed me the rod - all I did was reel in the fish. Second one was caught the next year, after a total of maybe 7 days on the water? But that was trolling, so again, I just reeled in the fish. Didn't even take the rod out of the holder myself. Don't count that one either. First one casting was probably day 10 or so, a whopping 28".

That was after a year and a half of fishing for them. After that I went 17 days, half of them GUIDED, without a fish, most of which were days when I didn't even see one. It wasn't until my fourth season where I actually started seeing fish on a regular basis. It was demeaning as all #*#*, because I had been fishing regularly for 30 years and had almost always caught fish everywhere I went.

So what I am saying is don't despair! Your success depends on a lot of things. Most importantly it's the waters you fish, and the days and times when you fish them. If you're fishing low desnity/high pressure waters, during crappy conditions when nobody is catching or even moving fish? You can't expect miracles, especially when you pick a day a month in advance. Your best barometer starting out is what other people are doing. If you didn't catch or see fish today, and other people did, that means it's probably you. If you're taking to guys at the bar or the landing, or the lodge or whatever, and nobody else saw or caught anything either? It's probably not you.
IM Musky Time
Posted 1/9/2012 2:14 PM (#532054 - in reply to #532010)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 243


The Swan - 1/9/2012 11:18 AM

Can you get to prime musky water? Lake of the Woods? Lake St. Clair? Hook up with a more experienced angler. ("Please teach me." "I'll cover the gas.")

Ask yourself: What am I doing that is wrong? Are you using lures designed and sized for trophy sized fish? Most fish are not trophy sized. Would down-sizing your lures make a difference? Might. (Have you tried a 5.5" Wiley? Works here.)

Just make sure you are ready when the big hit comes. Is your line sound? Terminal tackle? Will the knots hold? And especially: Do you have an adequate net?

Keep at it; and good luck in 2012.



+1!

Being a stubborn Type-A, I convinced myself I would conquer the musky in the summer of '94 when I was in high school. Fished all the time growing up in Northern Lower Michigan and my grandparents had property on a small musky lake. Saw them in the water and sometimes on a stringer as a kid growing up. Was always fascinated by them and actually lost one on a bluegill with a treble through its back off the end of the dock when I was probably 7 or 8. Unfortunately, no one in my family was interested in muskies and I didn't know anyone who really targeted them.

Anyway, I spent weeks on the water that summer and the next and the next before finally catching a 40. Bass sized net, what a mess. Spinning gear with mono and a pike leader and a Mepps #5. Bleeding hands, almost fell out of the boat, shaking like a leaf. Loved it. But wasted SOOOOO much time getting to that first one! Fishing during the heat of the day, hardly ever at prime times (girls and other sports will also negatively impact your fishing, btw). Never did a figure 8, never ran my lure deeper than 2 feet, and kept losing fish or missing chances.

Can't agree more with being prepared, and with the info/equipment available now, it's much easier to get started I think. But wow, do I wish I could go back to those days and started out by fishing with someone who knew what they were doing. Experience is a great teacher in the musky world.

One other thing that's really made me a better musky angler in the last 7 years was joining my local musky club. Small group of people, but some really good fishermen who cut my learning curve so drastically that it literally changed my life in the boat.

Good luck getting to that first one. It will be even sweeter now than if you caught it your first time out because you've earned it.
Chuckin Baits
Posted 1/9/2012 2:25 PM (#532056 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 143


Location: La Crosse, WI
My first year I got skunked while my dad boated 7 muskies, all with me in the boat. I think one of the most overlooked aspects of muskie fishing is lure presentation. We were fishing the same areas with the same baits in the boat, but I had far less patience than my dad. Working a bait every cast and paying attention to structure and cast location can pay off big time.

And another thing, cherish the first couple years of muskie fishing. We all think that if we could go back to when we first started, we would reduce our mistakes and catch a ton more fish. However, learning things and making mistakes is what makes muskie fishing so enjoyable. If muskies were easier to catch, then they wouldn't be nearly as much fun to chase. Try new things, have a lot of persistence, and keep chucking baits!
Ifishtolive
Posted 1/9/2012 8:29 PM (#532130 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 81


Location: Van Buren, Indiana
Trent the picture in the avitar was my first from our lakes 39" my second smallest. I would be glad to hook up this spring and take you out and try to help shorten the curve. The spring water temps and pre-post spawn conditions can be tough fishing and timing is everything. The times I was able to get out (which was not many) we hit a period the fish were really lazy following, lots of lookers not many takers, some guides were experiencing the same things. But if you can get out often following the "lazy follow" days that's when it picks up. P.M. me and I can fill you in a little more!
R Swain
Posted 1/9/2012 9:31 PM (#532143 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


Best way to cut the learning curve in Indy is to book a trip with Chae Dolsen of Webster lake Guide Service. www.websterlakeguideservice.com
Missouri Wayne
Posted 1/9/2012 11:47 PM (#532161 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 31


10 mandays spreadout over two years once I decided I wanted to catch one. Your first is always one you will remember!
Twinkle-Toes
Posted 1/10/2012 10:01 AM (#532198 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 66


2 years with way more than 17 trips, a boat purchase and countless hours and money spent on gas, lures etc...
MuskieFever
Posted 1/10/2012 10:43 AM (#532210 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 572


Location: Maplewood, MN
3.5 years

My first season my buddy and I (both greenhorns) took about 11 trips and moved 1 fish.
Second season we fished about 11 trips and moved about 8 fish.
Third season I got out about 16 times and lost one boat side opening day, extremely frustrated. Moved a bunch of fish that season.
Finally this season I boated my first, second, and third. Went out over 20 times this year and fished new tactics, new spots, new lures and never gave up. I told myself I would not fish with a guide until I boated my first fish off my own knowledge and skill; let me tell you, it was extremely rewarding. 3 fish boated and moved at least one fish almost every trip.
lhprop1
Posted 1/10/2012 3:39 PM (#532241 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 200


Location: Minnesota
0 my first year, but that was just one weekend.
1 my second year and that was over 4 days fishing.
2 my third year in 4 or 5 days.
1 last year with a lot of days on the water, but most of those days were on an unpopular lake, which is probably not popular for a reason.
Tony Spicker
Posted 1/10/2012 4:22 PM (#532243 - in reply to #532025)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?


TrentM. - 1/9/2012 12:17 PM

Love the replies, guys... keep em' coming!!!! Just a little backround info.... I fish the north webster area lakes, mainly the barbee chain or tippy. Would you all consider them pressurred waters, right? I'm not under-equiptted, and have many baits. Also, a great suggestion, I am planning a trip up to lake St. Clair, in the summer. Seems that everyone's most memorable is their first. I'm surely not gonna give up anytime soon!

Hope to see you all in chicago.


Trent,
For me it was my first time out (got lucky i guess) We were on LOTW and the second spot we fished i taged a 40 on a crane 7 incher... I'll never forget it!!!
You said you are fishing Barbee, webby, and james area. Stop by the Innovative Tackle Solutions booth and ask for me, thats my home waters and know it well...
Tony
jtroop
Posted 1/10/2012 4:39 PM (#532245 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 177


Location: Cohasset, MN
My first was an accidental 8 incher while bass fishing. Wish I had a pic of it. My first "on-purpose" was a 32 incher on a bucktail after about 8 hours on the water. That was my biggest fish to that day. I was shakin' like a leaf ! My success rate has declined significantly since then.
rjhyland
Posted 1/10/2012 5:24 PM (#532249 - in reply to #532210)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 456


Location: Kansas City BBQ Capitol of the world

Trolled all day long one day on the Niagara River with my Pops back in 1977 and Caught my first Muskie on a modified Pike Lure. The second one came 30 years later. 

RonMy First Muskie

leech lake strain
Posted 1/10/2012 7:03 PM (#532265 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 536


some time in the mid 90's for me I think was a summer of fishing from shore mostly because I never had a boat, in september I finally landed one on a suick about the same length as the bait
Shoot2Kill
Posted 1/10/2012 8:09 PM (#532272 - in reply to #532265)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 158


Stuck a 45 the first night out, 20 minutes later I was ruined for life when a 51 slid into the net and I have loved every second of it since! I was out with a friend who knew what he was doing and had all the gear so that definetely jump started my learning curve. I've been pretty fortunate in my first few seasons and am closing in on having 30 by next season (hopefully more!) if all goes as planned. Haha. Muskie fishing changed me forever and I've made some great friends chasing these fish!
Top H2O
Posted 1/10/2012 8:30 PM (#532276 - in reply to #532272)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 4080


Location: Elko - Lake Vermilion
One Cast in 1994 while casting for Bass on Tonka,.............. Caught a 32" Tiger and was "HOOKED" for life,....... Stupid Fish!!!

G-Rome
North of 8
Posted 1/10/2012 10:22 PM (#532292 - in reply to #532210)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




I am guessing maybe 20-25 days of fishing over a couple years, back in the 1970s to catch a legal length fish.

Sometimes it takes time and learning, other times a good mentor and some luck. Last year on opening day my wife and I were volunteering at the landing on the chain where we have a cottage. A boat was coming in and I walked down to the dock to see if they wanted a hand. Turned out to be my nephew, an experienced musky guy and his friend. His buddy had never been musky fishing before and my nephew had told him not to be disappointed if they didn't catch anything, that it might take a number of trips. Well,30 minutes in his buddy boated a mid 30's fish and lost another one. Just a lucky day but on the other hand they got out early because my nephew had read the tables and there was supposed to be a major feeding time early in the morning and the three fish they had hit all were in that window. Also, my nephew knew that lake well and took his buddy to where he had caught or moved fish before and had the way points on his electronics.

So it was some luck but also had a good fisherman helping him, on waters he was very familiar with.
esoxaddict
Posted 1/10/2012 10:55 PM (#532298 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 8782


Those first few seasons are what I call "character building" Then there's Samantha... 45 on her second day muskie fishing, 30 on day 4, another 30 on day 7, 44 on day 10... She's lost some others, and a few good ones at that. I keep telling her that dry spells are going to happen, but she always manages to blow that theory right out of the water. I try not to think about the fact that she's got fewer hours on the water than I have weeks!
steve fiorio
Posted 1/10/2012 11:02 PM (#532299 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


I will also be in the Big Game Tackle booth. Hit me up and I should be able to help you out. Check out a few vids of mine on youtube, "muskiesteve"
See you at the show
Steve
TrentM.
Posted 1/11/2012 9:39 PM (#532463 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 133


Location: South Bend, Indiana
Steve, those are some great musky videos! Keep at em'... I personally like the underwater video of the baitfish, gives you a great, new perspective on how to fish bait balls. I surely will stop by and talk in chicago!!!!!!
Doonan
Posted 1/12/2012 12:47 PM (#532526 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 153


Location: Storm Lake, IA
Been chasing pike and muskie since 94 but it took until the fall of 96 twitching a husky jerk on West Okoboji in Iowa. Probably wasn't over 25 inches but sure was exciting.

Edited by Doonan 1/12/2012 12:48 PM
Mike Hulbert
Posted 1/12/2012 9:25 PM (#532607 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


Come see me at the Chicago Show...I'll give a day for free in Indiana...I'll get ya that first musky!!!

MIKE HULBERT
Herb_b
Posted 1/13/2012 12:54 PM (#532673 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 829


Location: Maple Grove, MN
I actually caught a number of Muskies before I ever fished specifically for them. I caught my first Muskies in 1985 fishing for Northerns and then caught about a dozen more before 1994 when I started to actually target Muskies. Funny thing is that I actually catch more large Northerns casting for Muskies. I have caught my largest Northerns, Walleyes, smallmouth and largemouth Bass, and even my largest bullhead while Muskie fishing. My friends still tease me about that big bullhead....


Edited by Herb_b 1/13/2012 12:56 PM
Basschamp167
Posted 1/15/2012 4:08 PM (#533041 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 230


16 years.......OH, we're talking about fish, my bad

Took me one and half seasons, for a total of 36 hours to get my first fish in the boat. A solid 42" on the figure eight.
KentuckyMuskie
Posted 1/15/2012 10:07 PM (#533127 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 252


It took me 42 hours of actual muskie fishing to land my first muskie. I was replaying catching that fish today in my mind while fishing on the river.
krazyk
Posted 1/15/2012 10:24 PM (#533130 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 45


Caught a 37"r on the Lower Manitou speed trolling for pike and that was 32 years ago....I can't believe that I'm still fishing for these toothy devils...oh no it's not an addiction !!!
Guest
Posted 1/16/2012 1:52 PM (#533246 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?


Took me a minimum of 50 hours on a really tough lake with near zero visability. It's was a 37"er caught in the lilly pads in less than a foot of water on a 6" Grandma. At that point that fish was a monster to me!! On another massive system it took me nearly 100 hours to boat my first fish at 49.5" and lost upwards of 6-8 fish prior to landing my first. What cracks me up is I decided to take my Dad Muskie Fishing for the first time and he's not a real big fisherman, let alone chases Muskies. Sure enough his very first 2 hours of fishing Muskies with me he boats a 50"er on a topraider. His very first Muskie and first time ever fishing them. I was so happy but it also was very humbling..... It made me feel like I was trying too hard but I had to take some credit for fishing the spot, my boat, my rod/reel, my bait choice for him and my determination to convince him to come out and chase these fish with me the day prior to July 4th. Ha!! Seriously, I was super thrilled for my dad and told him some guys chase a 50"er casting for many many years.
joemsanderson
Posted 1/16/2012 2:18 PM (#533253 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 150


Location: Central Minnesota
I finally got mine half way into my third season. My suggestion for you is to keep optimistic and try to learn something every time you go out. Muskie fishing is all about learning how these fish act. Every year you will become a better muskie fisherman. Make sure that you and your friends work as a team on the water, remember, any fish boated is a success for the entire boat party. Good luck and keep working the figure 8's
dtaijo174
Posted 1/16/2012 2:32 PM (#533257 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: RE: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 1169


Location: New Hope MN
It took me 3yrs, but I was fishing with my dad who is an awful fisherman. He still hasn't caught one, but I have to give him a big thanks for allowing me to chase these dang fish even when it wasn't his thing.

Here's a pic of my first "big one". I was 13 (1994) Pretty rough shape pic, but I don't have any left from that period of my life No clue where they went.


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(youngD.JPG)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments youngD.JPG (19KB - 155 downloads)
Nupe
Posted 1/17/2012 7:31 PM (#533517 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 519


Location: Bloomington, IL
A 34" in 1997 for me. I had been to Canada several times as a kid, but not muskie fishing. In 1997, I finally made it back up to Canada when a guy worked with invited me up with his group. We went to a lake in the Vermilion Bay area. On the way up, I bought a Cisco Topper, a couple Mepps, and a 6" Hi-Fin Trophy Minnow (in Orange Tiger). I caught a 34" my first day on that Trophy Minnow. In fact, I caught 3 my first day on it. I caught 9 for the trip my first trip up there muskie fishing (all on a 6'6" MH spinning rod), capped by a 44" toward the end of the trip - by far the biggest fish I had ever caught at the time.

Needless to say, I was hooked on these freakin' fish for life, and have been going back up with that group ever since as they are now great friends of mine.
J.Sloan
Posted 1/18/2012 6:49 AM (#533566 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Location: Lake Tomahawk, WI
Don't really remember when I caught my first muskie. Caught several as a kid while icefishing for pike, and a bunch while walleye/bass fishing in the summer. First one I caught while targeting them was about 10 minutes in to my first time trying. Had a purple Rizzo Whiz and was fishing one of my pike lakes that I knew had muskies. Was fishing alone and hooked/landed a 44" on about the 5th cast. I put the fish in the livewell, turned the pumps on and motored about 100 yards to another boat. I asked the gentleman if he'd mind getting in my boat and snapping a picture of my 'first' muskie. He did and I need to see if I can find that pic. Haven't thought about it in awhile.

JS
CM_IA
Posted 1/19/2012 10:31 PM (#533926 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 59


I fished muskies maybe 12 different times for probably 30-40 hours before I caught my first, a 43, off the dock at AML on a lure I made for a class independent project. Best first muskie I could imagine. My dad caught his first last fall, a 49. He has many more hours in than I do in both pike fishing lakes with muskies and targeting muskies.
muskie-don58
Posted 1/20/2012 5:27 AM (#533937 - in reply to #533926)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 213


Location: FIB land
It's like gambling, the worst thing you can do is win; muskyhuntin' - worst thing you can do is catch one ! Then the insanity begins...
Stan Durst 1
Posted 1/20/2012 7:16 AM (#533951 - in reply to #533937)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 1207


Location: Pigeon Forge TN.
Caught my first one, by accident, while fishing for walleye when I was 13 ( 56 years ago). It was at that time a seven footer ( through young eyes) but probably more around 28 to 30 inches for real. I remember that I caught it on an orange Shyster spinner bait as I used them a lot back then.
Caught my second one 13 years later when fishing in Canada with my Dad for musky.




Edited by Stan Durst 1 1/20/2012 7:17 AM
ShutUpNFish
Posted 1/20/2012 9:33 AM (#533971 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Posts: 1202


Location: Money, PA
Caught 6 on my first trip to the Kawarthas, after that, I was hooked for 20+ years!
JKahler
Posted 1/20/2012 5:38 PM (#534056 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?




Posts: 1289


Location: WI
My first took a long time since I mostly fished from shore. Finally caught a huge 18 incher at a small lake, then a few mid 30's with a friend at a numbers lake. Once I got my own boat it didn't take long, but I mostly fished numbers lakes for the first season.
dfkiii
Posted 1/20/2012 7:16 PM (#534067 - in reply to #531904)
Subject: Re: How long did it take you for your first?





Location: Sawyer County, WI

Once I started targeting musky, it took about 3 weeks. The odd thing was I wasn't fishing for them when I landed the first one.

I was fishing off the dock in the mid day sun, throwing a small spinner bait for largemouth when I hooked a small 14 inch bass. As I was reeling the bass in I saw this shadow coming in and it struck like a lightening bolt, t-boning the bass. It turned and headed for deeper water with the bass in its mouth stripping the 6 lb mono off of my spinning reel. After about 30 seconds it lets go and I reel in a bass with its head nearly severed from the body. I was shaking as I'd never seen anything like this before, but had the sense to put down the spinning rod and pick up the musky rod and start casting. I tossed the crank bait out in the direction the musky went and got a follow on the first cast. The fish saw me on the dock and took off again. After a few more casts I was beginning to feel pretty dejected that I lost a chance at my first musky but I finally got a strike and landed the 35 incher. Every season since I've managed at least one off the dock, but now I'm fishing for them.