Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune
Slamr
Posted 1/6/2012 2:56 PM (#531621)
Subject: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 7011


Location: Northwest Chicago Burbs
If you were to be dropped off (of course w/ full rigged boat, your rods/reels with you, and pants on) to anywhere in the muskie range...and you dont get to choose the lake, the time of year, only that boom you fish this lake from 6AM to Midnight....what 10 baits do you take?
Yes, this question has come up in years past, but I like this one, and it's winter, and we talk about alot dumber stuff all the time around here...

Personally, I'm using the same 10 I've always named as my top ten:

1. Double 10, black tail, smoke/nickel blades
2. Straight Depth Raider, Perch
3. Magnum Bulldawg, Black/Orange (or walleye)
4. Suick, 9" weighted black/white sucker pattern
5. Weagle, Black
6. TopRaider, Blackbird
7. Rad Dog Spinnerbait (black w/ an added extra large willow blade in glow and a white twister tail)
8. 10" Jake, Tennessee Shad
9. 8" Hughes River glider in Shad (if it's spring, 6" hughey in okaboji perch)
10. Bomber Long A Mag in Shad color.

jakejusa
Posted 1/6/2012 3:28 PM (#531626 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 994


Location: Minnesota: where it's tough to be a sportsfan!
1. black bucktail/Mepps #6 french
2. spinnerbait safety pin style 1/2-3/4 oz. bright color
3. jig/reaper tail
4. Reef Hawg
5. Swimbait thumper Tail
6. Top Raider
7. Twichbait/ Gold & black
8. Walk the Dawg topwater/black
9. Suick or Burt
10. Glidebait larger 8"-10" red /gold
Mullhead
Posted 1/6/2012 3:31 PM (#531627 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 286


Location: VA
1. Double 10 Smoke/black
2. 10" Foil Glider Sucker
3. 10" Jake Gold Carp
4. 10" Red October Tube Dirt
5. Pounder Dawg Eel Pout
6. Double D Smallmouth
7. Nimmer Prop Dog Plus Frog
8. Shack Attack 11" Curly Sue Gold/Black Sucker
9. Shallow Invader Black
10. Bondy Bait Black

Works for me
muskellunged
Posted 1/6/2012 3:32 PM (#531628 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Location: Illinois
White Shallow Invader
Silver HellHound
Bondy Bait 2.0 (Vomit Shad/Orange Tail)
PurpBluGreen DC-10 w/ silver blades
Loon Whopper Plopper
Chartreuse BabyGirl
Perch HardHead
Willow Blade Nutbuster Spinner Bait
Cisco Pounder
Black Creeper
esoxaddict
Posted 1/6/2012 3:53 PM (#531631 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 8732


Well.. Slammer's already got 8 of my 10, with the exception of #8 and #10. For #8 I'd say a 9" Grandma in perch. For #10? #8 Shumway Flasher, black w/orange blades. Or Nickel blades. As I said in the other thread, I could fish the whole season with nothing more than those.

lucky
Posted 1/6/2012 4:23 PM (#531636 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune


10- 10" weighted black Suicks. They work everywhere a lot of the time.
Jeff Hanson
Posted 1/6/2012 5:06 PM (#531640 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 937


1. Cobra perch MuskieTrain MX6
2. Big Joe black and yellow
3.Mag Bulldawg B.L (my custom color)
4.Baby Squirko goldfish
5.Big game 7" twitch in perch
6.10" weighted suick firebass
7.Monsterlures One Eyed Willy black
8.Muskietrain MX9" Perch prism
9.Double 10 Spanky My Bluegill
10. B.S willy Creeper
Jeff Hanson
madisonmuskyguide.com
Guest
Posted 1/6/2012 7:05 PM (#531654 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune



Rad Dog.
Water Chopper.
October Tubes.
Jointed Believers.
Bull Dawgs.
DBL 10 Glittertails.
Baby Girls.
Buzz Dog.
wtd. Suick.
BNelson Quick Strike rig.

JS
MD75
Posted 1/6/2012 7:20 PM (#531656 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 682


Location: Sycamore, IL
Here is my Top-Ten:

1. Mepps Magnum Muskie killer(black with gold blade)
2. DCG (black with orange blades)
3. Shallow Invader(walleye)
4. Super Shad Rap(gizzard shad)
5. 9" Suick(black sucker)
6. Sub-Walk(lemon head)
7. Depth raider(perch)
8. Yo-Zuri Crystal Minnow(chrome/rainbow)
9. Weagle(Cash)
10. Nut Buster(white with silver blades)

Matt
mskyhntr
Posted 1/6/2012 7:23 PM (#531658 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 814


1. Lee lures chopper/ loon
2. Weagle/ stink pickle
3. 6" squirrelly phantom/perch
4. Depth raider jointed/perch
5. Mag bulldawg/walleye
6. Suick/ gold/orange
7. Jake 10" /walleye
8. Big Joe/ ball licker
9. Shumway flasher/ black/ Nickle
10. Double 10 black/ smoke

Rudedog
Posted 1/6/2012 7:26 PM (#531659 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 610


Location: S.W. WI
Mag Bulldawg- Walleye
Mag Bulldawg (shallow) Walleye
dbl 10 Cowgirl- any with shiney blades
Big Game 9"- Walleye
Topraider- Black
Jr.Cowgirl- Black Chartruess
7" Crane twitch- perch
Mepps Maraboo- Black/Chartruess
9" Doc topwater- black
Manta- Hang Ten- white
-Jon

Edited by Rudedog 1/6/2012 7:34 PM
jonnysled
Posted 1/6/2012 7:33 PM (#531660 - in reply to #531658)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 13688


Location: minocqua, wi.
1. Weagle - black
2. Straight Depth Raider - orange-belly perch
3. Shallow Invader -
4. Pacemaker - black
5. DDD - perch
6. Baby Depth Raider - orange-belly perch
7. Grandma - tennessee shad
8. Hellhound - perch
9. Double 10 - christmas-tree/smoke
10. Nelson's fancy Quick-Strike Rig
h2os2t
Posted 1/6/2012 8:55 PM (#531674 - in reply to #531659)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 941


Location: Freedom, WI
1. Large HardHead with extra tails and a few accessories for it in a more natural pattern.
2. Small HardHead in a bright color.
3/4/5. 6", 7", 8" Nitro glide bait in Mr. Bluegill.
After all these years and lures that's all I really need.
Since I can have 10 maybe throw in a couple of some kind of topwater and a blade bait
6. Walk the dog style Weagle/Recon
7. Da MuskRatt
8/9/10. A few of my friend Scotts blade baits in double 8s, 9s and 10s
Ronix
Posted 1/7/2012 9:32 AM (#531728 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 977


good post...interesting read
Mine are:

1.) 10" Monster Tube in lemon head rigged jerkbait style
2.) 12" Big Sexy tube walleye rigged jerkbait style
3.) 7" Ninja Tube in white rigged jerbait style
4.) 9" weighted sledge in copper sucker
5.) Grimp Reaper Big Cat Spinnerbait in bubblegum
6.) 9" Lunge Lumber Lures Prowler in perch
7.) 9" Big Game Balsa Twitch
8.) 9" Grandma Twitch in alewife
9.) 7.5" Phantom Soft tail in hot crappie
10.) 10" Hell Hound in perch
KSauers
Posted 1/7/2012 9:46 AM (#531731 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 743


1 Blk/blk Double 10 or 12
2 Blk Weagle
3 Blk/ Ong Little Polly wog
3 9" Big Game or 8" Surface Twitch
4 DepthRaider
5 Jointed Baby Depthraider
6 Talonz Claw
7 Talonz Mag Claw
8 homemade Rizzo Whiz ( make one color that has caught fish everywhere tried)
9 Old Bucher Babytail ( french blade)
10 Old 8" Sharpnose Hughes Hughie in Baby Musky

Edited by KSauers 1/7/2012 10:20 AM
muskie_man
Posted 1/7/2012 11:03 AM (#531741 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 1237


Location: South Portsmouth, KY
1 Medussa
2 Medussa
3 Medussa
4 Medussa
5 Medussa
6 Medussa
7 Medussa
8 Medussa
9 Medussa
10 Medussa
thats al
Guest
Posted 1/7/2012 1:47 PM (#531761 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune


Black Bondy Bait
Black Bobbie 10" weighted
Mepps Musky Killer -white or black
Jake/Grandma
Fudally Reef Hawg

IAJustin
Posted 1/7/2012 4:58 PM (#531779 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 1973


double cowgirl
double showgirl
weagle
DDD
6" phantom
a couple of sizes of spinnerbaits (1 oz - 4oz)
mag dawg

thats all I would need for casting anywhere at anytime of year.
dougj
Posted 1/7/2012 6:09 PM (#531785 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 906


Location: Warroad, Mn

Just thought I'd reflect on this some.

In my 45 years or so of muskie fishing I'll bet that my top ten lures has changed at least 20 times.

Here's my current ten:

DCG's or similar, all colors seem to work at times

Large spinner-baits (no one seems to make them any more, but the big M&G's are deadly)

10 Jakes, both casted and trolled. Grandma work also

10" unweighted suicks

8" Big Game (twitched)

Tail spinner top waters (lots of good ones, topraider is my favorite)

Smaller spinner baits (Rad Dogs, Grinders, and the like)

Small bucktails (real speed lures), Vibrex, Harassers, Mepps, Buchers and many others)

10" believers both solid and jointed (very versatile, can be cast or trolled, good in weeds)

Soft plastics. Bulldogs (I like magums, but Im old). There's lots of great stuff out there.

I can both cast and troll with these, I sort of feel I should have a jigging option like a Bondy Lure or a Fuzzy Duzzit, guess I better get at least one of each!

Wonder what this will look like 10 year from now?

Doug Johnson

 

 

 

Macdaddy
Posted 1/7/2012 7:04 PM (#531792 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune


Badwater Baits Mogambo
Badwater Baits Quick Set rig
Cow Girl
10" weighted suick
Hard head
Mepps marabou
Big game
Jr cow girl
Top raider
Hog wobbler
jackpotjohnny48
Posted 1/7/2012 7:16 PM (#531793 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune


1. Jackpot (black and silver)
2. Grandma (9 inch black and silver)
3. Curly Sue (9 inch sinking, in lumina black color)
4. Suick (9 inch original with Fudally screw in weights)
5. Manta (perch color)
6. Top Raider
7. Creeper (Hi Fin)
8. Ghostail Inline bucktail (with 4 inch Power Grub attached as a trailer)
9. Cowgirl
10. Triple D

"Jackpot" John Schroeder
Chasin50
Posted 1/7/2012 7:33 PM (#531796 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 380


Location: Michigan
In no specific order...
1. Red October Tubes
2. Dawgs
3. Wabulls
4. Voodootail Bucktails
5. Spanky Bucktails
6. Musky Treats
7. Topraiders
8. Hellhounds
9. Wileys
10. Perch Baits

Edited by Chasin50 1/7/2012 7:34 PM
wisriverrat
Posted 1/7/2012 9:36 PM (#531824 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 368


Location: On the River
DCG 10,s
DCG 8's
Mepps Maribou
Shallow Invader
Phantom Squirrley Tail
Reef Hawg
Hellhound
Pacemaker
Hawg Wobbler
Mag Bulldog
Big Fork Pulsator
Ranger
Posted 1/7/2012 11:53 PM (#531833 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 3797


Big Timberwolf Glider (black/orange)
10" Jake (walleye w/weighted rear shank)
7.5" Grannie (weighted to suspend, twitch bait)
Topraider (the sqeeeeeky one)
Poes Giant Jackpot (the one that hooked me)
Unweighted Suick (nat perch w/ death wobble)
Raddawg (black/silver)
Buchertail (purple/firetiger w/ doubled blades)
Mepps Muskie Killer (all black or all hot pink)
Jig/Creature ("every color as long as it is black")
JKahler
Posted 1/8/2012 12:48 AM (#531835 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 1284


Location: WI
jr cowgirl (chart)
wood pacemaker (yellow/brown)
creeptonite (org)
hellhound (walleye)
9" grandma jerk (silver)
cyco spin (chart)
cyco spin (org)
suick unweighted (chart or org)
12" big game (org)
inhaler (blk/org)
Top H2O
Posted 1/8/2012 10:39 AM (#531843 - in reply to #531835)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 4080


Location: Elko - Lake Vermilion
Pounder cisco and walleye
Double Dawg cisco and brown, gold
Hellhound chartreuse,black
Weagle black/orange/white
Double 8 White and brown/orange
5" Crane black/silver glitter
Mag Dawg creamsicle
Reef Hawg orange
Mag Madussa walleye
Soft tail Phantom

Jerome
Mak51
Posted 1/8/2012 11:36 AM (#531850 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Location: MN
Tough question, so many favorites depending on time of year and lake but here's the general list in no particular order.

1. Big Blade (13s/10s/9s)

2. Burner bucktail - Musky Buster Bulger Boo, Shumway Screamer, Showgirl, or #5 French Blade (Bluefox or Mepps MK)

3. Shallow Invader - Walleye

4. Soft Body Swimbait (Lifelike Perch or Zilla)

5. Phantom Softail

6. Hawg Wobbler or Similar - Black

7. Prop Topwater (Lowrider/Pacemaker/Topraider)

8. Pounder/Homemade "Under-Dawg"/Monster Medussa - (Walleye/Something "Hot"/Black/Cisco)

9. Mag Dawg/Medussa (Walleye/Something "Hot"/Black/Cisco)

10. 10" Slammer or Jake - Walleye or White



Edited by Mak51 1/8/2012 11:47 AM
JakeStCroixSkis
Posted 1/8/2012 12:25 PM (#531853 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 1425


Location: St. Lawrence River
Dc-8, black/purple/blue tail, nickel blades.
Double showgirl, red/pink tail, nickel blades
Topraider, loon
Lee lures chopper, black
Rad dog spinnerbait, green yellow red
Spanky dbl 10, red black tail, gold blades
8" Manta, orange/black
9" Suick, chart/black
Weagle, stink pickle
10" believer, finlander or perch

No order
thrax_johnson
Posted 1/8/2012 4:14 PM (#531887 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 313


Location: Bemidji, Lake Vermilion
No particular order to these

Hawg Wobbler (black)
Jr DCG (chart/black)
Thury Supernatural (perch)
Thury Headlock (Lac Seul perch)
10 in Jake (walleye)
Double Showgirl (chart/black)
Wood Pacemaker (black)
Mag Dawg (black)
Pounder (walleye)
Wades Wobbler (gold)
BenMuskyHunter247
Posted 1/8/2012 5:58 PM (#531905 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 86


Location: Wauwatosa, Wisconsin
1.hellhound 2.depthraider 3. super d 4. dc 9 5. top raider 6. weagle 7. 8in jake 9. cowgirl 10. shallow invader
figure 8
Posted 1/8/2012 6:56 PM (#531922 - in reply to #531905)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 238


1. topraider loon
2. Black and Char cowgirl double 10
3. Firetiger Medussa
4.Firetiger mx9
5.10" weighted black suick
6.Jackpot
7.Black and Nic showgirl
8.White big Joe
9.10" Jake
10. Walleye mag bulldawg

Edited by figure 8 1/8/2012 6:58 PM
Joe Meyer
Posted 1/8/2012 7:08 PM (#531926 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 7


Location: On the Sconnie!!!!
1. double 10s
2. phantom 6in.
3. hellhound
4. mag dawg
5. shallow raider
6. shalllow invader
7. weagle
8. prop style top water
9.red october tube (new jerkbait kind)
10. bobbie bait
mulligan. big game twitch
Beaver
Posted 1/9/2012 6:31 AM (#531973 - in reply to #531926)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 4266


1-2 Varying Ghosttails. #9 Walleye Gold/Copper, #9 Something darker Orange/Gold blades
3-Weagle/Custom paint
4- 9" Suick/ custom color and weight
5-Loon Top Raider
6-7, 2 of my gliders 1-Perkette-Pearl Prism, 1 Redwood 8"-Sucker/Chub
8-One of Nates Swim Baits or one of His Shadilacs...Cisco if the lake's deep, or else Perch
9- Mike Kings 9" casting lure in Whitefish or Shad
10- Legend Perchbait Deep Jtd Perch

Edited by Beaver 1/9/2012 7:01 AM
Blake
Posted 1/9/2012 11:45 AM (#532019 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 55


Location: Coon Rapids, MN
Soft tail Phantom (whitefish)
DCG (Black with silver blades)
Show girl (Blue/silver or Black)
Prodawg (walleye)
Jackpot (black/silver)
Shallow invader (white)
Couple Spinner baits
Musky buster bulger (black flame)
tomcat
Posted 1/9/2012 2:55 PM (#532062 - in reply to #531660)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 743


JohnnySled, have you even caught ONE musky on each of the baits below? or is this just what you feel/think would be best for the situation Slamr posted? that would be at least 10 muskies...
1. Weagle - black
2. Straight Depth Raider - orange-belly perch
3. Shallow Invader -
4. Pacemaker - black
5. DDD - perch
6. Baby Depth Raider - orange-belly perch
7. Grandma - tennessee shad
8. Hellhound - perch
9. Double 10 - christmas-tree/smoke
10. Nelson's fancy Quick-Strike Rig


Edited by tomcat 1/9/2012 2:56 PM
joe m
Posted 1/9/2012 3:04 PM (#532063 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 330


Location: Pittsburgh, pa
1st 5 are casting. 1- Hellhound 2- 9" weighted suick 3- buchertail 4- muskie treat 5 - Leo Jerkbait

for trolling 1- Wiley headshakers 2- Legend Perchbaits 3- Tuff shads 4- Wiley fatbodys 5- Baker Baits
Guest
Posted 1/9/2012 6:27 PM (#532097 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune


In order
1. 9" weighted suick - black
2. DCG - natural colors
3. Magnum Bulldawg - white/chartruese
4. Top Raider - Black
5. Mid-size phantom softail - black
6. Shallow Invader - firetiger
7. CJ Spinners - Green/yellow
8. 6" Baby Shallow Raider - chrome perch
9. Weighted tubes - natural colors
10. Hawg Wobler - black
kodiak
Posted 1/11/2012 1:14 PM (#532372 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 1224


Location: Okoboji
1. swamp donkey
2. 10" unweighted suick chartruse
3. 9" weighted suick perch
4. 11" curly sue
5. mag dog black/orange
6. 7.5" softail phantom black
7. purple on purple dcg
8. cady weagle
9. twisted sister
10. double showgirl
cluelessfisherman
Posted 1/11/2012 2:49 PM (#532390 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 52


Location: Bemidji
1. Spinnerbait - M&G or Northland Booty Call - black/orange
2. double Harasser - black/orange
3. 8" Phantom - perch
4. 8" Phantom - Canadian Crush
5. 8.5" Dunwright Dancer - Neon Perch
6. unweighted Burt - walleye
7. unweighted Burt - glitter perch
8. Twisted Sister - black
10. 10" unweighted Suick - sucker
tswoboda
Posted 1/11/2012 3:46 PM (#532395 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 349


1. Rad Dog/1 oz single french blade black and orange
2. Phantom Softail/6" orange belly perch
3. DCG/.75 oz bell sinker black and nickel
4. Mag Dawg/walleye orange tail
5. Giant Jackpot/bullfrog
6. Topraider/blackbird
7. Blue Fox Vibrax bucktail/black and orange
8. 10" DDD/walleye
9. Hang 10 Manta/walleye
10. Weagle/black
Doonan
Posted 1/12/2012 12:50 PM (#532527 - in reply to #532395)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 153


Location: Storm Lake, IA
Double Cowgirl
Double Showgirl
Super Model
Big ace tandem
Rad Dog
Medussa
8" Big Game
Mag Dawg
Shallow Invader
Chopper
Hammskie
Posted 1/12/2012 1:02 PM (#532529 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 697


Location: Minnetonka
Slamr - 1/6/2012 2:56 PM
...only that boom you fish this lake from 6AM to Midnight.

1. Double 10, black tail, smoke/nickel blades


I drive around a lay icons until 4:00 pm and I bring only Slamr's #1.
Sled
Posted 1/12/2012 6:31 PM (#532576 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune


Tommy ... I'm mostly a netman, when you get a minute cruise the tackle guy sites and you will see one from I think s DDD I think I netted that one so we can at least count one.

at least most fish I catch are from my own boat ... muskies, bass, pike n perch too.

Must suck living in Indy eh?
jonnysled
Posted 1/12/2012 10:20 PM (#532615 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 13688


Location: minocqua, wi.
the view facing southeast looking toward indianapolis ...


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(393568_2799394176825_1017653061_2897668_1931488933_n.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments 393568_2799394176825_1017653061_2897668_1931488933_n.jpg (10KB - 234 downloads)
Herb_b
Posted 1/13/2012 1:05 PM (#532677 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 829


Location: Maple Grove, MN
If I go by what we actually threw this year and how the lures produced, it would go like this:
1. Large CJs willow tandem (multiple fish caught)
2. Small CJs skirted tandem (multiple fish caught)
3. Large CJs colorado tandem (multiple fish caught)
4. Large CJs skirted single blade (multiple fish caught)
5. Small CJs willow tandem (multiple fish caught)
6. Small CJs hair colorado tandem (one fish caught)
7. Various double 12, 11, 10 and 8 bucktails (one fish caught)
8. Various double 10 spinner baits (many follows and several lost fish)
9. various Rad Dogs (good Pike action and some follows)
10. various plastics (lots of follows, no fish caught)
djwilliams
Posted 1/14/2012 8:05 PM (#532911 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 759


Location: Ames, Iowa
Rumbler black/orange
6" Slammer walleye
Jackpot silver/white
Showgirl black silver
Regular Bulldawg glitter motor oil/orange
9" Wtd Suick black perch
Reefhawg gold glitter
9" Slammer trolling
Homemade tandem spinnerbait trolling
Red October tube white/orange
whynot
Posted 1/19/2012 10:46 AM (#533785 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 897


1. Junior Cowgirl
2. TopRaider
3. Funky Chicken or M&G spinnerbait
4. Shumway Flasher
5. Phantom
6. Depth Raider
7. Mag Double Dawg
8. 10" Weagle
9. Pacemaker
10. Super Shad Rapala
muskytom50
Posted 1/19/2012 12:00 PM (#533805 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 64


Bulldawg
Weighted Reef Hawg
Double 10
Wiley's
Sucker
Little Claw
Depth Raider
Shallow Raider
Jake
Burt
Steve Jonesi
Posted 1/19/2012 12:44 PM (#533815 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 2089


Medussa
9"Big Game
Cowgirl
Raddog
Mepps Tandem Musky Killer
Wobbler-Wolly Pog or Jinkerson
6" Phantom Softtail
Faceraker
DDD
Krisco
10" Wtd. Suick
Weagle
That covers it, fast/slow, top to bottom. 10? Make it a dozen!
Kirby Budrow
Posted 1/19/2012 1:39 PM (#533826 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 2283


Location: Chisholm, MN
Cowgirl Black Nickel
Jr. Cowgirl Black
Hog wobbler
Pacemaker
Walleye mag dawg
Pounder
Red Oct tube rigged deep
Maybe a showgirl
Squirelly Phantom
Jointed Shallow Raider

Seems the general consensus is a black cowgirl and some sort of bull dawg.
Farmer Rick
Posted 1/19/2012 2:43 PM (#533842 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Location: Not far enough north!
In no particular order:
Perch Depthraider
10" Jake Black Perch
8"Jake Pearl
Hellhound
Pacemaker
Spanky Double Ten
Large Hard Head
Mag Dawg
DDD
Thumper
Will Schultz
Posted 1/19/2012 2:52 PM (#533847 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Location: Grand Rapids, MI
Pounder
Magdawg
Shallow Magdawg
Medussa
Weagle
Suick
DDD
Grandma 9"
Jake 10"
VooDooTail
The Swan
Posted 1/20/2012 10:11 AM (#533977 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune


This is really tough--variety is the spice of life--and I have to leave all jerkbaits off my list, even though I would want some jerks along on any mid-summer through autumn trip. I am going to go over the limit on various sizes though.
--Jake 6 and 8
--Wiley 5.5 and 6.5
--Believer 7 and 8
--Grandma 7 and 9
--Depthraider 6 and 8
--M. Giant Killer, single and tandem
--M. Musky Killer, single
--M. Magnum Musky Killer, tandem
--Topraider
--Baby Doc
ShutUpNFish
Posted 1/20/2012 10:20 AM (#533981 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 1202


Location: Money, PA
No specific order...completely situational.
- Leo 6" Jerk
- The HAMMER
- Wiley Jerk
- Wiley 8" jnt'd
- Wiley 5.5" jnt'd
- Wiley 6" jnt'd
- Double bladed bucktails Gold blades black tail
- Double bladed bucktail yellow tail nickle blade
- Wiley Fatbody DD
- Latiano Ready Eddie - Black or Silver

Edited by ShutUpNFish 1/20/2012 10:21 AM
Guest
Posted 1/20/2012 10:35 AM (#533983 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune


Bondy Bait-Pearl
Bull Dawg-Walleye
Suicks-black
Inhaler Original in black
Suzy Suckers
edalz
Posted 1/20/2012 12:19 PM (#534005 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 458


10" Hellhound-Superman
Bondy Bait-Redhorse Sucker
Spanky Fireball-Black skirt orange blades
Pacemaker-Black/Wood
10" Softtail Phantom-Perch
7" Hellhound-Walleye
Red October 12" Big Sexy-White
Red October 14" Twisted Tube-Pumpkin and white
Shumway flasher-Black skirt and nickel blades
Weagle-Blue and white
msky3
Posted 1/20/2012 12:45 PM (#534008 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 309


Location: Elgin IL
these will get it done


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(top 10_1.JPG)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments top 10_1.JPG (53KB - 218 downloads)
ESOX Maniac
Posted 1/20/2012 12:47 PM (#534011 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 2752


Location: Mauston, Wisconsin
1 -> 10 = Odd stuff that no one else is throwing.

Maybe Todd Forcier put it best: "I've never seen anyone fish a lure like that before." I don't know if it was a comment on the lure itself or my fishing technique or both! I suspect the latter, and I think he was also being kind in his choice of words.

Have fun!
Al
NateOz
Posted 1/20/2012 1:06 PM (#534013 - in reply to #534011)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune





Posts: 400


Location: North/Central WI
Medussa
8" or 10" boot tail swimbait (Castaic, Huddleston, or Reaction Strike)
Straight Depthraider
DDD
Big Joe
Dbl 10
Mag Dawg
Hellhound
Bondy
11" Martin
BigMo
Posted 1/20/2012 2:10 PM (#534027 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 617


Location: Clintonville, WI
Double Ten - orange & smoke blades / gold skirt
Mag Dawg - glitter walleye with white belly and orange tail
Hellhound (original size) - chartreuse with navy blue stripes
Hard Head (second largest size) - red horse with pearl tail
Long Tale (largest size) - custom walleye pattern / mag gold willow blade
Jake 10" - white/chartreuse tiger
DDD (original size) - miller perch
Top Raider - black with orange tail
Weagle 8" - rat belly
Muskie Treat (small) - multi sport athlete
Dub Nics
Posted 1/20/2012 4:36 PM (#534051 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: RE: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune


1.9" big game, chartruese tiger.
2.9" big game, chartruese tiger.
3.9" big game, chartruese tiger.
4.9" big game, chartruese tiger.
5.9" big game, chartruese tiger.
6.9" big game, chartruese tiger.
7.9" big game, chartruese tiger.
8.9" big game, chartruese tiger.
9.9" big game, chartruese tiger.
10.9" big game, special perch.
rbiwer
Posted 2/2/2012 8:39 AM (#536266 - in reply to #531621)
Subject: Re: Top 10 Lures - Anywhere, anytime on the roulette wheel of muskie fortune




Posts: 113


Location: Twin Cities
Pacemaker- black
Softail Phantom- some natural color
Weagle- stink pickle
Musky Buster Bulger- copper blades
Weighted Suick- black or perch
Bulldawg- ball licker
Double Dawg
Double Cowgirl
Triple D- holo bluegill
Bondy Bait
Only 10 is tough!