Posted 12/22/2011 9:30 AM (#529767 - in reply to #529696) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Stan Durst 1 - 12/21/2011 7:47 PM Leaves me out, I am just a painter, I don't make baits. There are a lot of very good ones out there.
I hear ya Stan, I’m more of a bait maker than a painter. Maybe we could have shared time with a trophy? Like the STANley cup – ha ha. I have work off next week and may spray something up for it. As long as you have a deep epoxy coat with some glitter in it you should be in the running – lol
Posted 12/30/2011 12:02 PM (#530664 - in reply to #530597) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 77
Thanks guys!
I am just starting to put a bait together. I still have not figured out what color yet. I have had a couple suggestions of submitting my Black Spotted Sucker. I was thinking possibly a walleye. I think I will make both, and see which one turns out better.
Posted 1/4/2012 11:28 PM (#531449 - in reply to #530683) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 4266
Will there be catagories among catagories? I've been making quite a few CA Redwood gliders that only require some belly paint. Is it strictly a beauty contest or do they have to go through a tank test? Just wondering, because if I have to make THE BEST LURE IN THE WORLD, I better start. How many can I enter? Gliders, Surface, Crankbait? I'm so confused.....but it's gonna be cool as hell.
Beav
Posted 1/5/2012 10:45 AM (#531479 - in reply to #531475) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
How do you guys interpret rules #1& #6? Can I enter a lure in both the crankbait and jerkbait categories or do I need to decide which one I want to enter?
Posted 1/5/2012 12:20 PM (#531489 - in reply to #531479) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 44
Hi Guys,
Sorry for any confusion about the rules. Trying to make it as simple as possible and we would like only 1 lure submitted per contestant, and we would like the lures sent to me by the 31st of January so we can be prepared and display the lures effectively and know what kind of space we are going to need. If you do submit a lure you still will need to pay to get into the show, but remember for each paid admission you can vote for your favorite lure and also all of the proceeds are going to benefit kids musky fishing events. I hope this helps, and please email me with any questions, we are open to any suggestions and want to promote these amazing baits while still having fun and benefiting kids fishing events.
Posted 1/5/2012 1:06 PM (#531497 - in reply to #531492) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 4266
You guys have made it pretty tough on us guys. Picking one lure is tough enough, but after going through my basement, I've found several contenders, but all of them have hook rash and some have tooth marks, that's why they are my favorites. Will people be able to handle them? I have other lures for consideration that have Kameleon scale or cheek patterns that look different from every angle, hang them on a wall and they lose that effect. Maybe I'll have to go out to the garage and paint up a couple of fresh ones. I'm glad it's warm in the painting room.....decisions, decisions? :/
Posted 1/5/2012 7:45 PM (#531534 - in reply to #531497) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 44
I thought about that and a stand or display would detract from the features and hard work you put into a bait. We may think of that for the future and will take that suggestion into consideration, but for this year we are going to stick to just the lures. We will have the lures displyed on a wall with velcro and will be able to be taken down and examined under supervision of course. This will allow the voters to check out the smallest of details.
Posted 1/7/2012 1:53 PM (#531762 - in reply to #531733) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 4266
For the 'Suggestion Box' for next year. Don't limit it to one lure, but limit it to one type and allow multiple entries in that catagory. If fact, make it a rule that you must submit 3 lures in the catagory that you choose. I have lures from 6-12 inches in a myriad of body styles and colors. I tried to narrow it down yesterday and wound up with 15. Do I get penalized for a beautiful 6" lure because it gets lost in the array of larger lures. Do I submit a 10 Smallmouth made from figured Redwood with very little paint that looks just like a Smallie or will that be viewed as cheating? Stencils vs No stencils. Fins and gill plates vs a Red Head Jailbird? :/
Whisper
Posted 1/7/2012 9:39 PM (#531826 - in reply to #531534) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
We will have the lures displyed on a wall with velcro
Posted 1/8/2012 11:34 AM (#531848 - in reply to #531826) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 44
You can send the lures to me at the address below.
John Breivogel
308 Oakwood Drive
Manitowoc, WI 54220
lundzeio
Posted 1/8/2012 3:07 PM (#531877 - in reply to #529320) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Seems to be advantageous for local bait makers, good if you like home cooking. There is nothing to gain for non local and/or high end bait makers. How about a space at all the big muskie shows per season for a popularity contest? Or a panel of qualified judges? For a world championship, fairness should at least be considered.
on the fence
Posted 1/8/2012 3:19 PM (#531878 - in reply to #529320) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
I like the overall idea of the competition. I do have one thing that is keeping me from slaving away in the basement:
It seems like the opportunity exists for this to be more of a regional "popularity" contest than an actual competition. What I mean by that, Let's say that Beav finally makes up his mind on what lure to submit. He tells all of his friends and Muskies Inc buddies to vote for him. I send in a a lure from somewhere other than the Milwaukee area. I am playing at a loss already.
Have you thought about having it be a rotating competition? Maybe do the rounds of all of the shows. Or have it be an actual judged competition. have Guys that are known as topnotch lure builders. You could even have the judges be specialist. Like larry Dahlberg be the innovation judge, Joe Peterson judge artistic quality, Jim Saric judge the action, etc etc
I would sign up for that.
on the fence
Posted 1/8/2012 3:21 PM (#531879 - in reply to #531878) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Whooaa
scary. that was not me posting twice. looks like I am not the genious I thought I was someone else already thought about it.
Posted 1/9/2012 1:35 AM (#531965 - in reply to #531879) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 4266
Yes, judges would be better than a popularity show.....Let me make it clear that I have more friends than enemies, so I'm not at an advantage in Milwaukee or anywhere. Submit 'anonymous' lures to be judged by a panel of guys including guys from The Basement! We know how hard it is to build a lure that lasts, has good action and will catch fish. If it's a beauty contest, I'm putting boobs on mine. This is no easy task, but a great idea. I applaud the guys who came up with it, but think they should spend a week in the basement post/contest looking for input. But just like building lures can be too much work at times, we have to make it a friendly arena for all envolved.
Posted 1/9/2012 9:41 AM (#531992 - in reply to #531965) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Given the format, yes it will be somewhat of a popularity contest, but if it were a panel of judges one could say musky politics are involved. It’s the first year and things will evolve as it continues. I’m curious to know what does this ballot looks like and what’s the “average Joe” going to be looking for and judging on? I do wish you could enter more than one bait though. I can’t decide if the intricate details of 3D surfacing with a 1/64” ball cutter on my crankbait would be more appreciated that the overall complex geometries of my jerkbait. Well I’m in it for the fun so whatever happens, happens. Good luck everyone!
When and where is the auction? Online?
Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Posted 1/9/2012 12:20 PM (#532026 - in reply to #531992) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 44
Thanks for all of your input, I am making notes of all of your suggestions, I think this will grow year after year and will accomodate most bait makers. We would really like the most participation as we can get this year so we can have a good base of participants for future years. The success of this years show depends on participation and ideas of how we can grow the contest. I am really looking forward to see how we can influence the sport. Keep the ideas coming. Thank you!!!
Posted 1/9/2012 12:24 PM (#532028 - in reply to #532026) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 44
I beleive the auction will be around 3pm after we announce the winners.
2 many questions
Posted 1/9/2012 2:44 PM (#532058 - in reply to #532028) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Looking over the entry form, I think that I'll take a pass this year strictly based on criteria. I remember when the basement was a happy little place.
"Eyes" are a criteria? Some guys, or should I say most are limited to whats available on-line, period.
"Realistic Features"...so is this going to turn into a decoy carving contest? Firetiger, Bumblebee and more get tossed out because they have no realistic features, but they catch lots of fish.
"Overspray", Overspray is how you create colors by blending 2 or more. Does this penalize guys who use tape and stencils because of a lack of overspray?
"Durability", are you going to throw it on the floor 100 times?
What is a "Professional/Basement"? Guys who sell a few lures? How many lures makes you a pro/basement? I give more to outings and clubs than I sell, do I get a deduction?
"Hand Crafted Musky Lures", so guys who use CNC machines to duplicate blanks are not allowed?
I think its a cool thing, but there are 2 many questions. No catagory for guys that do restoration and repaints? Why not? You're eliminating some great artists right off the bat.
It'll be interesting to watch, I'll say that much.
The fix is in...
Posted 1/9/2012 3:44 PM (#532069 - in reply to #529320) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Am I understanding this correctly that the proceeds from the lure auction will be donated to the National Professional Anglers Association?
2 many questions
Posted 1/9/2012 4:05 PM (#532071 - in reply to #532069) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
That's a Charity?
Other things have come to mind. If you pay to enter a contest, doesn't that make you a professional?
One bad thing I can see coming out of this is the guys that make less than 100 lures a year and sell 50 or more to defray costs are going to have an IRS bullseye on their backs. I pay sales tax on everything that I buy to make lures, and sell them exclusively to muskiefirst members. I'll continue to do that and keep my anonimity while making lures for m1st members. Manufacturers and professionals have their businesses set up and fill out the appropriate forms. I am a "hobbyist" pure and simple, and I'm not putting my name out there for the Feds to start looking at me, especially at a show where they check every booth the way it is. This should be a display pure and simple. If you want guys to see your wares, have a place where you can do it. Afterall, that is what The Basement was meant to be in the beginning, but I guess we've lost our way.
Posted 1/9/2012 6:55 PM (#532106 - in reply to #532071) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 44
Thanks for the opinions and suggestions!
The criteria that I listed is just guidelines and are things that the voters could look for, but are definitely not limited to. They can vote for their favorite lure and take into consideration other factors as well.
Realistic features is another guideline not a limitation.
Overspray is definitely not blending and this comes into how neat the lure is created without getting paint where it is not intended. Stencils and taping may be an artists tool to create a certain look and is their interpretation how a lure should look and should definitely not be penalized.
Durability is subjective but should be considered. For example you don't want thin wire hooks on a musky lure or a flexible bill on a lure that should dive 20 feet.
We are looking for originals at this point, however a cnc bait that is an original should be considered.
We thought about a repaint division, and may be considered for future years, however we want to stick to originals this year.
This is a contest to highlight the amazing craftsmen and artists that create works of art which also can catch muskies. More importantly this competition is going to support the kids involvement in musky fishing and may not be for everyone. If this doesn't trip your trigger, you don't have to enter. Fishing and lure making is a sport to enjoy and have fun and to introduce young people to an awesome hobby!
Posted 1/10/2012 12:01 AM (#532162 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 32886
Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
The NPAA does exceptional non-profit work in bringing youth into the sport.
The NPAA is a non profit comprised of hundreds of Pro anglers, Guides, and other involved fishermen and women who's mantra for 2012 is ' Look to the Future!'
OutdoorsFIRST Media is a Gold Level supporting partner and I am a member of the NPAA.
Last year, NPAA Kids and Family fishing events staffed by volunteer Pro anglers at MWC, AIM, and FLW events put over 300 rod and reel combos into the hands of kids who would not otherwise have them, a free T shirt for the Pros to sign, and many times even more. Not a penny for an aspiring young angler to attend, learn how to fish, and walk away with a nice new rod and reel.
Total Kids and Family Fishing support from the NPAA was over $30,000 last year, including dozens of programs hosted by Pros in communities across the country.
That's investing in the future of the sport, and OFM is proud to be the main media source covering the Kids and Family Fishing events.
At this year's conference the NPAA announced a new foundation that will actively engage youth bringing hundreds of kids into the sport. Our good friends at he JJ Keller Foundation and a dedicated group of investors put up the seed money to make the efforts of the NPAA even more effective, and the Membership of the NPAA will step up to make this an incredible success.
So yeah, the NPAA would meet the criteria.
From today's NPAA 2012 Conference Press release:
'With nearly 40 Supporting Partners and newest partner Warrior Boats, Pat Neu said the NPAA is poised for growth (and has even been growing in this tough economic climate). The Future Anglers Foundation will be a 501C3 non-profit foundation with the goal of supporting individuals and organizations that share their passion via schools, events and other outreach efforts to attract more anglers to the sport. "Last year, thanks to many sponsors and funding from NPAA, we gave away $40,000 worth of rods, reels and tackle to kids. We must continue to reach them and their parents," he said. "That's the reason for the Foundation."
Additional news from the conference will be discussed and shared on the NPAA website and in future news releases.
The NPAA is a non-profit organization focused on growing the sport of fishing and increasing the professionalism of its members. Supporting Partners include: Navionics, Mercury Marine, Evinrude Outboards, Yamaha, Lund Boats, Ranger Boats, The Next Bite, Oahe Wings and Walleyes Guide Service, Outdoor First Media, Pure Fishing, Fish On Kids Books, Advanced Tex Screen Printing, Worldwide Marine Insurance, FLW Outdoors, AIM, North American Media Group, Frabill, John Butts Outdoors, J.J. Keller Fishing Team, The Reel Shot, U.S. Forest Service, Great Lakes Sea Grant, FPS Financial Planning Services, Off-Shore Tackle, Fin-Tech Tackle, Kingfisher Boats, Liddle Marketing, Mutual of Omaha, Northland Fishing Tackle, Optima Batteries, Simms Fishing Products, Pasha Lake Cabins, National Fleet Graphics, Arrowhead Promotion, G2 Gemini, and High Tech Fishing. More NPAA member and association news can be viewed at www.npaa.net.
Call Pat Neu, executive director, 920-856-6151 with questions.'
----
No one said anyone here HAS to enter. If you don't wish to, by all means, then don't, but allow that the idea is a good one and that there are plenty of lure builders who might want to. It IS 'just a display', not a booth where the baits will be for sale, and by the way, it's the MuskieFIRST booth. No bullseye of any kind anywhere, the lures are advertised as Basement Bait creations or customs if that's the category and not available for sale at the show in most cases.
Posted 1/10/2012 12:03 AM (#532163 - in reply to #532162) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 32886
Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
2011 Brimley Michigan NPAA Kids and Family Fishing Event
OFM was in the field 8 Saturdays last year covering the events who hosted the NPAA Kids and Family Fishing events, and working with the NPAA to promote kids and family fishing.
I personally think it was worth the time in spades.
Posted 1/10/2012 4:43 PM (#532246 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 910
Location: Hastings, mn, 55033
I'm still on the fence deciding whether to enter or not. Reading that baits "built" using a cnc will be allowed is a little troubling to me. To me "handcrafted" means just that....starting with a chunk of wood and using hand tools to shape the lure, be it a lathe, sander, dremel etc. Programming a cnc to cut/shape a bait just doesnt cut it as "handcrafted" in my humble opinion.
Also not completely understanding what separates an amateur from a professional/basement builder from a manufacturer. Perhaps setting some criteria for each would be a good idea. It doesnt seem like a level playing field if a guy that makes 25 baits a year can end up in the same category as someone making hundreds. Call me cynical, but I can see some fellas entering the amateur category thinking they will have better odds of winning, even if they arent really "amateurs".
Posted 1/10/2012 7:11 PM (#532267 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 114
Location: Central Wisconsin
Yikes, I didn't know this would get this serious. For those unsure whether or not to enter... Please ship your baits to me... I will personally test them over the next couple years to see if they work. I will personally email you testing results and whether or not you should enter future lure building competitions. Keep in mind I will base judging criteria strictly upon the number if fish I can catch with your lure. If it doesn't catch fish, I will put it on eBay and the highest selling price will earn a consolation 2nd place. My comments are of course a joke, so please don't bash me. Everybody has there own way of doing things, even as the aforementioned screw eye guest anonymously stated . Take it for whats its for, but I think looking at this booth will be well worth the admission fee in itself.
PS: last guest please note Castmaster profile pic, assuming he built that, it looks nice he knows what he's doin'
Posted 1/10/2012 11:10 PM (#532300 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 32886
Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
Don't enter if you think there's some sort of conspiracy. (There isn't)
There's THOUSANDS of attendees at the show from all over the Midwest. Many will vote because the display will interest them, and I promise you, most will have NO CLUE who you are. How in Hades is this even close to possible to be made a 'popularity contest'? You think some bait builder is going to pay hundreds of random people to vote for him? Get real, and login if you want to complain.
A manufacturer is one who distributes large numbers of baits through retailers. That's easy.
Posted 1/11/2012 1:48 AM (#532305 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 501
Location: Norway
A handcrafted lure would IMO be a piece of wood and a knife. Whether one uses a CNC or bandsaw/router, its not very hand crafted compared to a knife. Besides, how many in here can actually model in 3d, and program a cnc?
Being a former 3d modeller, I would easily sayt that carving out gills and such details with a knife is far easier than doing it on a computer in a CAD program, quicker aswell. Yes I use CNC, but when it comes to carving details, I dont. I cut out blanks, after I have made and tested some handcrafted prototypes.
As for the contest itself, I think its way cool, even tho I find some of the negative arguments here to be true or plausible. I hope I find the time, and a way to transfer the entry fee, so I can represent Norway here If not I will enter next year...
Posted 1/11/2012 5:31 AM (#532308 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 248
Location: Xenia, Ohio
I’m sure there has been a lot of people working very hard to put this event together You should be thankful you’re getting an opportunity to compete in such a prestigious event, win or lose it’s going to be a tremendous event, seeing all of this talent in one place, just use good common sense when entering your bait, and follow the rules, I made my lure from a block of wood turned it on the lathe shaped it the way I wanted it, built everything from scratch including the metal work and then put my artistic ability’s to work on my paint job all sense the competition was announced and as far as professional/basement verses Amateur each of know your own ability’s, I paint about 4 or 5 bait per year and just started two years ago, but my ability is in the professional/basement division, I feel that the Amateur division is for the new guys just starting out, use your best judgment, and enjoy these masterpieces these talented artist have painted for you and compete if what to or stop complaining.
Posted 1/11/2012 10:31 AM (#532344 - in reply to #529320) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
I questioned what the definition of “handcrafted” was on another thread about the contest and whether I could participate or not. I was told yes I can as a manufacturer. So that’s fine, I sold less than a hundred lures last year, but maybe that’s just my laissez-faire business manner. I do have a full time job in order to pays the bills. I have the lure biz because I enjoy it as a hobby. I love developing lures and love musky fishing. I do use a CNC to make my baits. I spent many many hours CAD designing, CNC cutting prototypes out of wood, testing, dremmeling, weighting, measuring, re-designing, re-cutting until I finally had the shape and action I wanted in the final prototypes. I then made a mold from steel and spent many more hours coming up with a material mix and processing the molding machine to get the density I wanted. Does this make me less of a craftsman than someone with a lathe and band saw? I don’t think so. I just use a different set of tools. To me it’s all about the creativity, craft, and talent of the individual. I think that’s a key point too, the bait maker submitting the bait needs to be the one who designed, made, and painted it. It’s not like I called up china and said copy this bait or send me a stock item, I did it all myself. Unless we are all handed the same block of wood and knife, or handed the same blank to paint, there are way too many different techniques to regulate and their concept of categories seems pretty good IMO
Posted 1/11/2012 4:00 PM (#532398 - in reply to #532344) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 4266
It's always been said that lures catch more fishermen than fish, we're about to see how correct that statement is.
I went through my glider box the other day and found a few that I would like to enter, but that would have meant putting new clear coat on them to cover the rash and other marks. Besides, when I make lures for myself, I don't care if it's sanded to perfection and that it looks flawless. Back in the day when I was selling some lures to muskiefirsters, I was way more particular. If I ever feel that I can spend hours on end out in the garage, I'll start making more lures and put them up for sale here, exclusively.
So, during the last 2 days, I spent a couple of hours a day out in the garage making a few lures to consider for display, so I was very tedious. Band saw, router, sander, weighting and balancing and then priming and painting. I have yet to clear coat them, but I'm proud of all of them and have one favorite, so I guess I'll have one fresh one for the display. Do I care if I win or place? Hell no. Any lure that has ever left this house I have been proud of. Whether selling a few or donating them to outings, I always try my best, and though I will never make it as a manufacturer, or get rich selling the lures I make, I don't care. It's my hobby, my passion, and which ever one hangs on the wall in the booth, I'll be proud of it. I will probably bid on my own lure so I can get it back.
They are auctioning off all of the entries, correct? Or just the winners?
Posted 1/11/2012 8:07 PM (#532441 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 531
Location: Hugo, MN
I'd like to enter the contest, but no guarantees. 3 kids under 5 makes it tough for me to finish anything on a schedule. If nothing else, I can't wait to see pictures of all the entries. There will surely be some amazing baits entered.
Posted 1/22/2012 2:00 PM (#534303 - in reply to #529320) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 44
Just a reminder that there is less than 3 weeks left until the first ever Musky Lure World Championship and less than 2 weeks until the lures need to be submitted. I have been getting some great entries - looking forward to seeing the different creations.
Posted 1/23/2012 7:53 AM (#534410 - in reply to #529320) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 77
I am finishing up my lure in the next day or so.. I should have it in the mail by thursday.
Guest
Posted 1/23/2012 3:14 PM (#534475 - in reply to #534303) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
jbreivogel - 1/22/2012 2:00 PM
Just a reminder that there is less than 3 weeks left until the first ever Musky Lure World Championship and less than 2 weeks until the lures need to be submitted. I have been getting some great entries - looking forward to seeing the different creations.
Posted 1/23/2012 7:10 PM (#534518 - in reply to #529320) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 44
I'm sorry, missed that one. From what I understand there will be a video crew covering the expo as well as the lure contest. Being that this is the first event of its kind I am going to try to get as much coverage as possible.
Posted 2/2/2012 5:06 AM (#536240 - in reply to #535122) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 4266
Are they auctioning all of the lures or just the winners??? This will be a determining factor in how much cash I bring or don't bring. Do we demo our own lures? I know there used to be a rule that you couldn't use the tank if the lure wasn't for sale.
Posted 2/13/2012 8:29 PM (#538568 - in reply to #531534) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 910
Location: Hastings, mn, 55033
jbreivogel - 1/5/2012 7:45 PM
I thought about that and a stand or display would detract from the features and hard work you put into a bait. We may think of that for the future and will take that suggestion into consideration, but for this year we are going to stick to just the lures. We will have the lures displyed on a wall with velcro and will be able to be taken down and examined under supervision of course. This will allow the voters to check out the smallest of details.
PLEASE TAKE THIS AS INTENDED.....Simply a little constructive criticism.
One of the reasons I chose not to enter, as well as several other builders I have talked to, is that it just didnt seem like there were really set rules etc and that it was more of a thrown together deal. An example of this is your quoted reply to the person asking about using a display stand. Those builders getting their info from you on this site were told that no stands were allowed. Yet in the pics from the show there are lures on display stands, including Mr Nimmers creeper on a motorized and mirrored turntable! Now not being present in person I surely dont know how that may have affected anyones vote, but I know such things have a way of catching peoples eye and "enhancing" a product. heck if they didnt folks wouldnt go through the trouble of using things like that. The dragon believer displayed MUCH better sitting on that stand than it would have velcroed to the wall.
Hopefully these were just things that will be improved on for next year. I for one would love to see this develop into an annual deal that draws the best builders out there.
Posted 2/14/2012 4:27 AM (#538612 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 248
Location: Xenia, Ohio
I agree because I was there, I fell for it hook line and sinker, I think it turned into more of an popularity contest
then a fair competition, and here is the reason why I say that, I work for a very large company and very well know, and we have a United Way car show fund raiser every year at work there are employees here who have 80k wrapped up in there show cars, and then there are employees who bring a motorized bar stool they place an empty can in front of the vehicles or bikes and all the employees get to vote on the cars or bikes they like by placing a dollar in the can and I have seen it over and over the person that campaigns the hardest or has the most friends or is really popular win the event that motorized bar stool has won the car show the last two year in arrow.
Posted 2/14/2012 8:10 AM (#538628 - in reply to #529320) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 44
Sorry for being late, here are the winners. I do not have the votes for each due to giving the paperwork (which the information was written) to the winners of the auction, also is to the limited helpers. As for the total number of votes I would say there was about 600. Thanks again for all of your support this year, and please email me with any suggestions for next year.
2012 Musky Lure Building Championship Winners
First Place Amateur/Topwater, Phil Urbanski
• Entry 002
• Wakemaker
First Place Amateur/Crankbait, Mark Wright
• Entry 006
• Just Wright
First Place Professional/Basement/Crankbait, John Eversoll
• Entry 007
• Betsy Bait
First Place Amateur/Glide/Jerkbait, Ed Kott
• Entry 012
• Muskies For Life 11” Walleye
First Place Manufacturers/Glide/Jerbait, Jeff Prust
• Entry 013
• Musky Chew
First Place Professional/Basement/Glide/Jerkbait, Steve Pray
• Entry 018
• Belly Up Sucker
First Place Manufacturers/Crankbait, Drifter Tackle
• Entry 019
• Slime Dragon 13” Beleiver
First Place Professional/Basement/Topwater, Greg Nimmer
• Entry 020
• The Alpha & Omega
Chicken Dinner
Posted 2/14/2012 8:35 AM (#538634 - in reply to #538628) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Could you please post pictures of each entry?
8 winners when there's only 18 entries seems generous.
I heard John Eversol's minnowbait had the highest vote total of any of the winners, so perhaps you should consider giving a "Best of Show" award on top of the various "Best of Class" winners.
John is one of the most generous and kind people you'd ever want to meet, and makes incredible pieces of art. No smoke and mirrors, just cool. Well-deserved win, John!
Guest
Posted 2/14/2012 5:01 PM (#538756 - in reply to #529320) Subject: RE: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posted 2/14/2012 10:04 PM (#538838 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 910
Location: Hastings, mn, 55033
So Greg Nimmers creeper that was featured up front and center on a motorized and mirrored turntable beat out a Joel Wick creeper velcroed to the wall. Who'd of thunk it!
Any explanation on why you stated pretty clearly on this site, in this thread, that no dispay stands were allowed but then let Mr Nimmer and others use stands? Heck, at least 2 of the 8 winners were baits displayed on stands, right up front on the table instead of on the wall.
Edited by castmaster 2/14/2012 10:07 PM
pepsiboy
Posted 2/21/2012 5:55 AM (#540127 - in reply to #529320) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
how about a routered cranks for the 1st place,ok paint job was nice but man it take 5 min do to that.
maybe only lures buiders,must to be judges.
the spinning top water lure was funny,was just missing the gold and diamonds........
Posted 2/21/2012 7:08 AM (#540140 - in reply to #540127) Subject: Re: Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
Posts: 4266
With so few lures, wasn't there plenty of room to group the lures in the catagories they were entered so people could compare apples to apples? With the show breaking attendance records, how many votes were actually cast, I saw a ton of ballots in the garbage. I didn't see the interest that I expected from lure-makers or the public. I stood around that area for a while and heard the comment,"That's it?" several times.
Like I posted elsewhere, why the limit on lures? This is a fundraiser, but you are putting limits on the funds being raised by limiting guys to one lure. I'm sure that Tigger could enter gliders and crankbaits if he was so inclined. And what about the criteria set forth to the builders? Where were the tests conducted for durability and proof that the lure actually functioned as intended? Who is checking the entries? I love the amateur from Ohio who sells hundreds of lures on ebay and even holds a plaque in a picture in his ad, "Vote Ohios Best Lure Maker"
This should be a show and auction, period. Make some funds, not just a little. Let's see a 100 lure auction. Let's see an auction of some of the lures each day.
Next year I am going to make more lures and donating them as prizes at the swap, and I will donate lures for the Veterans Fishing Trip and give them to the veterans or who eve wants to keep them. I'd rather see them full of scratches and memories, things that really make a difference. I bet you'd get more of us basement boys behind giving lures to vets and lures used as door prizes than being restricted as far as what and how many you can make.
No bucktails/ double 10's or rubber. The lures you find in every boat in muskieland but none on display. Why the no-show for those guys? We have a giant soapbox from where we can do lots of good, and the first thing we do is limit the contributions......why? Open the doors and let the flood gates open. Let those who want to enter a box full of lures do as they like, don't limit them.
And while we're at it, lets do something good for The University of Wisconsin fishing team. They get no University help, so lets help them with a fund riser.
Basement Baits World Championship, Submit Your Lure!
someone else already thought about it.
