1700T osprey vs 165 Navigator Tiller
mbani
Posted 3/9/2011 1:09 PM (#486057)
Subject: 1700T osprey vs 165 Navigator Tiller




Posts: 145


I'm strongly considering purchasing one of these two boats. I love both layouts but I'm not sure about going aluminum or going with the 1700 which can only run a 60HP.

How much better will the 1700 fish in wind (i.e boat control and drift)?

Can the 1700 tiller be converted to an esox like the console versions?

I spoke with a dealer who has a non-current 1700. He claimed he had a sticker from Tuffy and he could put a 70 HP Yamaha on it. Sounded kind of shady to me. Is there any way this is possible or legal?

Also, what was the price point on a new 1700 tiller with a 60?

Any info would be greatly appreciated.

Matt



Edited by mbani 3/9/2011 1:11 PM
esoxaddict
Posted 3/9/2011 3:29 PM (#486081 - in reply to #486057)
Subject: Re: 1700T osprey vs 165 Navigator Tiller





Posts: 8782


I've known a few people who have done that. Probably not legal, and probably more common than you think.
shaley
Posted 3/9/2011 5:10 PM (#486101 - in reply to #486081)
Subject: Re: 1700T osprey vs 165 Navigator Tiller





Posts: 1184


Location: Iowa Great Lakes
The glass will be much better in wind and rough water, having owned both I'll never go back to alum after owning glass. You will get a much drier and smoother ride out of the Tuffy, while I don't own a Tuffy my boat uses the same hull and have been able to stay drier and stay out longer than guys in 618 Rangers.
sworrall
Posted 3/9/2011 9:02 PM (#486141 - in reply to #486057)
Subject: Re: 1700T osprey vs 165 Navigator Tiller





Posts: 32886


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
What year is the 1700? If it has the rear 52" livewell, it can be converted to an Esox Deep V from an Osprey model. The boat is rated at 60 tiller and 135 console.
mbani
Posted 3/9/2011 9:28 PM (#486146 - in reply to #486141)
Subject: Re: 1700T osprey vs 165 Navigator Tiller




Posts: 145


It's a 2009 1700. I'm guessing I'll have to add the deep V casting deck (if possible) or something like a just encase to make a nice rear casting deck.
sworrall
Posted 3/9/2011 10:00 PM (#486150 - in reply to #486057)
Subject: Re: 1700T osprey vs 165 Navigator Tiller





Posts: 32886


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
The rear of that rig fishes OK without a deck because the transom and livewell offer some foot room, but I'd go with a Just Encase; lighter than the Tuffy deck and doubles as superb lure storage.
lambeau
Posted 3/10/2011 8:11 AM (#486192 - in reply to #486057)
Subject: RE: 1700T osprey vs 165 Navigator Tiller


since you're looking at a tiller, you do need to consider seat location for the driver. a seat base can be installed in the top of Esox/Tuffy deck extension...but i don't think you could mount one in the top of a Just EnCase box.
sworrall
Posted 3/10/2011 11:35 AM (#486227 - in reply to #486057)
Subject: Re: 1700T osprey vs 165 Navigator Tiller





Posts: 32886


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
You could leave the seat where it is and build the Just Encase box to fit so just less than half the seat is over the top...add a slide and the seat slides away from the box when fishing or needing access.