Why do muskie lures allways weight so much
Muskie-kid
Posted 2/9/2009 11:56 PM (#359881)
Subject: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much





Posts: 87


I was just wondering why the average lure weights 2-5 oz??
sworrall
Posted 2/10/2009 12:06 AM (#359883 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much





Posts: 32892


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
Because they are large, literally. Big lures, lots of material.
Muskie-kid
Posted 2/10/2009 12:10 AM (#359884 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much





Posts: 87


thats what i thought, but the reason i ask this question is because i like to use muskie sized lures for pike and was hopeing there where big yet light lures that i could use any suggestions btw i live in Ontario
sworrall
Posted 2/10/2009 12:13 AM (#359885 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much





Posts: 32892


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
Spinnerbaits, Big Game and Slammer Cranks, for a couple. largr lures less the large weight!
Muskie-kid
Posted 2/10/2009 12:16 AM (#359886 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much





Posts: 87


thanks for the great tip if only are lakes weren't frozen....
muskynorth
Posted 2/10/2009 12:49 AM (#359887 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: RE: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much




Posts: 61


Location: Sioux Lookout On Canada
Shumway Funky chickens all the way.
About ten years, Colin Gosse, a great guide in the area, introduced me to the Shumway products. Amen to you Colin.
A very strong lure and with a good size profile yet, really light bucktail.
You should be able cast this bucktail all day long.

chartreuse blade/chartreuse feathers
orange blade/black feathers
orange blade/white feathers
If you want to throw bigger, try the flasher. It is fishable all day long.
My personal best northern was caught on a Shumway Funky Chicken. I have caught walleyes and bass on them.
After multiple fish ; you would think that the lure was no good but, even without all of the feathers, they still produce fish.
Lindy makes a small 5 inch bucktail with a round blade. My friend Brian Thompson, of Sioux Lookout, has caught many incredible fish on small bucktails. His personal best 57", I believe, was caught on a small bucktail.
These two examples are heavy enough to use with 100lb test leaders and heavy braided line.
Awesome...

Neil Michelin
SpencerBerman
Posted 2/10/2009 1:37 AM (#359888 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much




Posts: 202


Basically your best bet for light musky lures are, minnow baits like Big Games, Grandmas and Jakes along with bucktails and spinnerbaits. Also most topwater baits are on the lighter side as well. In your search for lighter lures don’t forget that big lures normally mean big weight however they also mean big fish as well so try not to let that be the determining factor in what you fish.
Tackle Industries
Posted 2/10/2009 6:06 AM (#359889 - in reply to #359888)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much





Posts: 4053


Location: Land of the Musky
Big Lures = Big Fish

For topwaters its nice to have the weight too to stay away from as many blow outs as you can. Weagles are a perfect example of a good sturdy topwater with some weight. IF it weighed only 1.5oz and was the same size I have my doubts about it catching such great fish. I think the wake alone from a big fish would simply push it away prior to a hit. That weight keeps it there for this fish to hit it. JMO
James
PIKEMASTER
Posted 2/10/2009 7:14 AM (#359897 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: RE: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much





Location: Latitude 41.3016 Longitude 88.6160
BIG BAITS MOVE MORE WATER !!!!!!!!!!!!
Cast
Posted 2/10/2009 8:03 AM (#359905 - in reply to #359884)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much


Muskie-kid - 2/10/2009 12:10 AM

thats what i thought, but the reason i ask this question is because i like to use muskie sized lures for pike and was hopeing there where big yet light lures that i could use any suggestions btw i live in Ontario

A few suggestions:
--6" Bomber Long A (with hooks changed to brass or steel color); red and white
works for me;
--6" Jake or Grandma (I downsize my hooks on the Jake to #1, to get more
action);
--6" Believer;
--6" Depthraider in Miller Perch or Firetiger;
--Mepps muskie Killer (I want to try red and white blade with brown or white tail);
--Mepps Giant Killer;
--Dardevl spoons in 1 oz. size.
Guest
Posted 2/10/2009 11:17 AM (#359938 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: RE: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much


9" Suick doesn't weigh very much at all, yet has a bigger profile.
rpike
Posted 2/10/2009 11:51 AM (#359941 - in reply to #359938)
Subject: RE: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much




Posts: 291


Location: Minneapolis
Guest - 2/10/2009 12:17 PM

9" Suick doesn't weigh very much at all, yet has a bigger profile.


And pike love them!
Tackle Industries
Posted 2/10/2009 1:01 PM (#359958 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much





Posts: 4053


Location: Land of the Musky
Love the Suick but thats differnet IMO vs topwaters since its underwater most of the time. I get incredible hookups with the Suick! Love the weighted version the best due to the loooonger hang time.
Hunter4
Posted 2/10/2009 1:50 PM (#359964 - in reply to #359958)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much




Posts: 720


Kid,

If you want a lure with some size or I assume your looking for something with a little bigger profile in the water. Try throwing a Sand Cat by Big Fork Tackle company. I would go with the 6" model and 8" model. Its a great dive and rise jerkbait. That when you let come back all the way to the surface and pop back down is a deadly little trick.
JKahler
Posted 2/10/2009 3:18 PM (#359982 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much




Posts: 1289


Location: WI
I don't mind the weight usually, it's easier to lob cast em' way out there.
esoxriebe
Posted 2/10/2009 6:34 PM (#360021 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much




Posts: 95


if you are looking for a great light lure try S.S shad very light large profile. They are made of balsa wood
JimtenHaaf
Posted 2/10/2009 7:41 PM (#360039 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much





Posts: 717


Location: Grand Rapids, MI
Whenever I take my dad out, there is always a handful of baits I set aside for the old-timer!! ----- Squirley Burt, Suick, Blue Fox Bucktail, 6" Grandma.
esox69
Posted 2/10/2009 9:21 PM (#360056 - in reply to #360039)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much




Posts: 802


let's not forget the rizzo wiz! small, easy to cast and retrieve all day, and catches everything from big ski's to pike, bass, and even walleye.
woodieb8
Posted 2/11/2009 4:44 AM (#360076 - in reply to #359881)
Subject: Re: Why do muskie lures allways weight so much




Posts: 1530


for big pike i prefer a smaller woodie 51/4 version. undr 2 ounces. my main killer is big spoons. johnson silver minnow and little cleos have caught thousands of pike for me. when in summer doldrums, shiners under a float in deeper holes.