Preconceived notions
Pathfinder44
Posted 6/5/2008 2:17 PM (#321131)
Subject: Preconceived notions




Posts: 79


Location: S.E. Wisconsin
I would like to hear any you may have about muskies? I acually am stubborn and have many, but one that sticks out and was disproved was that fish do NOT eat top water on presurred lakes.
THA4
Posted 6/5/2008 2:28 PM (#321134 - in reply to #321131)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions





Posts: 468


Location: Not where I wanna be!
I dont catch enough muskies because im cursed.......

MuskyTaleMike
Posted 6/5/2008 2:32 PM (#321136 - in reply to #321134)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions





Posts: 314


Location: Bristol, IN
Indiana waters are heavily pressured and they do eat topwater baits.
Grass
Posted 6/5/2008 3:07 PM (#321138 - in reply to #321136)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions




Posts: 620


Location: Seymour, WI
"Clear water muskies will not hold out in very shallow water"

That one cost me a place in a tourney once.

Grass
reelman
Posted 6/5/2008 3:15 PM (#321139 - in reply to #321131)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions




Posts: 1270


You can't catch a musky in Iowa on a Bucktail so it doesn't pay to trow anything except a Wades Wobbler.
Willis
Posted 6/5/2008 3:41 PM (#321142 - in reply to #321139)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions




Posts: 227


Location: New Brighton, MN
So far I haven't found a notion that hasn't been contradicted by someone else's notion.
They're all preconceived
JohnMD
Posted 6/5/2008 3:48 PM (#321143 - in reply to #321142)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions





Posts: 1769


Location: Algonquin, ILL
At some point in time during a week long fishing trip SLAMR will fall into the lake

Ranger
Posted 6/5/2008 4:13 PM (#321151 - in reply to #321131)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions





Posts: 3867


I guess the pre-concieved notion I disagree with most is the idea that CPR doesn't hurt the fish. I believe all of these things can't be anything but negative for the fish: hooking the fish, the fight, (sloppy) release technique. Who can disagree that an unhooked fish is healthier that a free swimming fish.

Now don't go throwing PETA stones at me, I know people have the priveldge to catch and release (or keep) a fish. I'm not suggesting any further restrictions than what are already in place in each state. The less laws the better; but people must view themselves as stewards of the resources with with we are blessed. And behave accordingly.

But hooking a fish hurts the fish, period. (I hope to hook one this evening!)
C_Nelson
Posted 6/5/2008 4:28 PM (#321154 - in reply to #321131)
Subject: RE: Preconceived notions





Posts: 578


Location: Sheboygan Falls, WI
That musky tastes like chicken. LOL
sworrall
Posted 6/5/2008 5:07 PM (#321170 - in reply to #321131)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions





Posts: 32885


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
Willis nailed what i was going to say.
big island dude
Posted 6/5/2008 9:35 PM (#321228 - in reply to #321154)
Subject: RE: Preconceived notions




Posts: 10


C_Nelson - 6/5/2008 4:28 PM

That musky tastes like chicken. LOL


lol
lambeau
Posted 6/5/2008 9:47 PM (#321230 - in reply to #321131)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions


most times out i have a preconceived notion that the muskies will bite.
most trips end up more like reality bites!
Shep
Posted 6/6/2008 7:57 AM (#321257 - in reply to #321151)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions





Posts: 5874


Ranger - 6/5/2008 4:13 PM

I guess the pre-concieved notion I disagree with most is the idea that CPR doesn't hurt the fish. I believe all of these things can't be anything but negative for the fish: hooking the fish, the fight, (sloppy) release technique. Who can disagree that an unhooked fish is healthier that a free swimming fish.

Now don't go throwing PETA stones at me, I know people have the priveldge to catch and release (or keep) a fish. I'm not suggesting any further restrictions than what are already in place in each state. The less laws the better; but people must view themselves as stewards of the resources with with we are blessed. And behave accordingly.

But hooking a fish hurts the fish, period. (I hope to hook one this evening!)


Linda? Linda McCartney? Is that really you? Have you been reincarnated as my favorite lib, Ranger? But I must say, he is sounding more conservative these days. Less laws are better? That's a pretty extreme position for you to take, Ranger. Robert Byrd is going send the Klan after you!

Edited by Shep 6/6/2008 7:58 AM
mikie
Posted 6/6/2008 8:52 AM (#321274 - in reply to #321131)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions





Location: Athens, Ohio
There are no big muskies in Wisconsin (well, you can't prove it by me, but I've seen some of Norm's!). m

ps - Shep, watch out dissin my man Bob Byrd. Remember, WV fought for the North!

Edited by mikie 6/6/2008 8:53 AM
JBush
Posted 6/6/2008 10:11 AM (#321294 - in reply to #321274)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions




Posts: 311


Location: Ontario
Fish only look at #10's (or any other bucktail) if you bring it back to the boat at 275 mph.
I like 'em slow and low some times, or tied beefy and bulged slow too.

Ranger
Posted 6/6/2008 1:29 PM (#321357 - in reply to #321131)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions





Posts: 3867


Sorry Shep, no Linda's here. Don't know anything about her.

As you know, Shep, I'm pretty liberal on some issues and not so muchon others. I hope to support comon sense, but of course first I have to build my capacity to recognize it when it comes by. I'm trying.
Shep
Posted 6/6/2008 3:34 PM (#321380 - in reply to #321357)
Subject: Re: Preconceived notions





Posts: 5874


Maybe you didn't get those commercials featuring Linda McCartney in the UP. Featured her crying about how hooks cause the fish pain. Ran during Gillespie's show. What a hoot!

And I know you ar e trying, Ric. I knew I talked some sense into you while watching those spearers set up there TeePee on Roberts!

How is Tim? Eric is playing Legion baseball now, and went 5-0 for JV HS team this year. He's nearly as tall as me!

Edited by Shep 6/6/2008 3:35 PM