Poll Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes
Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes
OptionResults
100% Muskies
95% Muskies
90% Muskies
85% Muskies
80% Muskies
75% Muskies
70% Muskies
65% Muskies
60% Muskies
55% Muskies
50% Muskies
45% Muskies
40% Muskies
35% Muskies
30% Muskies
25% Muskies
20% Muskies
15% Muskies
10% Muskies
Less than 9% (aka, what is a muskie and why am i here?)

PepperFlake
Posted 1/2/2008 10:44 PM (#291665)
Subject: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes




Posts: 3


I love the muskie, love it very much, but I fish other fishes too. Just wondering how much y0u guys fish for muskies versus other fishes.
Derrys
Posted 1/3/2008 5:55 AM (#291689 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes


I picked 50%. I fished for Muskies 10 times last year. I had 4 strikes and boated all 4 fish. Nothing big though. Next year I plan on concentrating my efforts toward bigger fish instead of numbers, by using larger baits more often. It seems to work for my brother. He caught 60 or 61 Muskies this year and at least 19 of them were 49 inches or larger, including 10 or 11 fifty inchers. Wish me luck.
muskyhunter63
Posted 1/3/2008 7:26 AM (#291696 - in reply to #291689)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes




Posts: 706


Location: Richland Center, WI.
I have found in the last year that my fishing for panfish, walleye and bass has suffered due to the fact that all I want to do is fish for musky! Had a terrible year in 2007 with no fish caught but did see some so it was not a total loss. I am trying to catch up with the panfish during ice fishing but still feel the majority of my fishing will be for musky once the season opens. I will publicly appologize to my kids here for the musky fever but hey kids, one musky and you will be hooked too! Right Nathan?
sworrall
Posted 1/3/2008 10:39 AM (#291730 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes





Posts: 32934


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
60%. Love my bass fishing and need crappies and bluegills to eat, too. Salmon is good...walleyes are good...
muskellunged
Posted 1/3/2008 11:14 AM (#291749 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes





Location: Illinois
95%. I do some ice fishing for panfish and northern. This upcoming year I'd like to try for some Salmon and if that goes well then I might become a 90/10 type.
Mike Witowski
Pointerpride102
Posted 1/3/2008 11:21 AM (#291750 - in reply to #291749)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes





Posts: 16632


Location: The desert
muskellunged - 1/3/2008 11:14 AM

95%. I do some ice fishing for panfish and northern. This upcoming year I'd like to try for some Salmon and if that goes well then I might become a 90/10 type.
Mike Witowski


My thoughts exactly.
PIKEMASTER
Posted 1/3/2008 11:25 AM (#291752 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: RE: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes





Location: Latitude 41.3016 Longitude 88.6160
95% of the time, the other 5% I fish for CRAPPIE I love deep fried CRAPPIE.
dandy
Posted 1/3/2008 11:39 AM (#291755 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes




Posts: 8


Location: northern Maine
65% of the time for muskie,the other 35% I fish for wild brookies or landlocked salmon especially after ice out . Brookies and salmon are the primary fish in this area, muskie are the fish of an illegal stocking some 30 years ago so they are a new fish in this area . love your forum for info on this fish dan




VMS
Posted 1/3/2008 11:46 AM (#291758 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes





Posts: 3508


Location: Elk River, Minnesota
When the season opens, it's 100% muskies, unless the fishing gets really slow...then I'll wade into some weeds and catch some bass for a while, just to take the edge off, then head back to the real fish. Walleyes happen only on trips that are targeted specifically for them, and that is usually before Muskie season starts.

Steve
JimLang
Posted 1/3/2008 11:51 AM (#291760 - in reply to #291755)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes





Posts: 170


I plugged 95%....possibly a bit less, but doubtful. Once the ice leaves Winnebago, I get in on the early walleye bite (not a river rat...find the fish that don't run the river). During the month of May, I spend time on the water up in Iron county and fish walleyes for a short stretch...once the green light goes on for muskies, the walleye gear begins the cob web gathering process.
McChou28
Posted 1/3/2008 11:54 AM (#291761 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes




Posts: 9


I only went 30% muskies ... but that's b/c I don't own a boat (yet) ... so most of my time fishing is for more accessible species like retention pond bass, river smallies and catfish (30lb carp on 6lb test line is fun too!) I can't afford to rent boats or constantly hire guides, so muskie fishing is more of a special occasion thing for me.

now if you ask me what ratio my investments are muskie vs other species ... it's more like 75% muskies as they are my favorite fish to target!
Ranger
Posted 1/3/2008 7:27 PM (#291877 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes





Posts: 3913


most years it's been 95% muskie, even thru the summer doldrums. But last season I fished muskies in the spring and fall, and spent most of the summer trying to learn how to catch walleyes. So last season 15% muskies and the rest walleye.
ToddM
Posted 1/3/2008 9:21 PM (#291907 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: RE: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes





Posts: 20258


Location: oswego, il
I took about two hours and bass fished a local lake near my house. High water and I wanted to see if this catch and release only lake recovered from being overharvested. Poachers who did not even care the lake was posted catch and release. It had, I caught nine bass and lost two. That was the only time I did not fish for muskies this past year.

Edited by ToddM 1/3/2008 9:22 PM
NateSki
Posted 1/3/2008 9:26 PM (#291909 - in reply to #291907)
Subject: RE: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes





Posts: 48


Location: New London, MN
I'd say around 75%... Fish alot of walleyes in the winter months but once muskie season opens, its on like kong
Manta18
Posted 1/3/2008 9:58 PM (#291919 - in reply to #291909)
Subject: RE: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes




Posts: 375


Location: Browerville, Minnesota
85% of the time.  Now that my kids are getting a little older, I spend more time taking them out after pannies.  My youngest son is becoming a HUGE muskie nut, so hopefully that % will increase!
ron f
Posted 1/4/2008 5:07 AM (#291949 - in reply to #291665)
Subject: Re: Percentage of Time Fishing Muskies vs. Other Fishes


musky 100% when the season is open,but before that im 100% pike