Sucker fishing? or Lures??
coach7373
Posted 10/25/2007 9:58 AM (#281188)
Subject: Sucker fishing? or Lures??




Posts: 23


I am still new to the fall Muskie fishing scene. I have heard many different theories on what to throw at this time of year. The lake I am fishing is currently at 60 degrees and has not turned over yet. What should I be throwing? Is it practical to buy suckers? Should I focus on Top Water? Bucktails? Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated... Also are muskie shallow or deep at this time of year...?
asteffes
Posted 10/25/2007 10:31 AM (#281195 - in reply to #281188)
Subject: RE: Sucker fishing? or Lures??




Posts: 454


It really depends on the lake. There are some lakes that I fish only in the shallows in the fall and others where I find the fish deeper. If they are up shallow toss double cow-girls or big spinner baits, jerkbaits, and even topwater.

For deeper fish I love throwing pounder bulldawgs and other soft plastics.

I wouldn't start with suckers until the water cools a bit more. I usually have more luck in the low 50's with suckers.

Good luck.
AWH
Posted 10/25/2007 10:33 AM (#281196 - in reply to #281188)
Subject: Re: Sucker fishing? or Lures??





Posts: 1243


Location: Musky Tackle Online, MN
Given the conditions you mentioned, I would be looking shallow first. Top water can be outstanding just before turnover. Bucktails, shallow minnow baits, anything really, can get them going if they're still in shallow.

Aaron
big gun
Posted 10/25/2007 12:00 PM (#281206 - in reply to #281188)
Subject: Re: Sucker fishing? or Lures??




Posts: 462


Location: Madison Wi. Chain
I like very shallow especially if there is a great deal of Milfoil and you get get over the top of it. However, the first suckers of the season on a specific body of water can be deadly. Take both and see what the fish want. GOOD LUCK! BG
TTurn
Posted 10/25/2007 8:48 PM (#281273 - in reply to #281188)
Subject: RE: Sucker fishing? or Lures??





Posts: 91


I have been fishing suckers for a few weeks in 55 to 60 degree water right on the outside weed edge and tossing cowgirls and pacemakers as far to shore as I can fishing both side s of the edge most fish have come on deep side 60% suckers 40% cowgirls seen 18 fish in 3 outings from 3:30 to 6:30 only caught one not bad for only 9 hours totall time on the water