What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?
Renaldo
Posted 3/16/2007 7:26 PM (#245264)
Subject: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 101


Location: Northern Illinois
I caught a 5 1/2 lb walleye on a green Suick in 3 ft of water in heavy weeds. A friend caught a large crappie on a bucktail, and it wasn't a small bucktail either.

Edited by Renaldo 3/16/2007 7:27 PM
ShaneW
Posted 3/16/2007 7:40 PM (#245265 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 619


Location: Verona, WI
I can't tell you how many rock bass I have caught musky fishing on bucktails when they are spawning. Aggressive little things. I've caught my biggest walleye, largemouth, and smallmouth while musky fishing as well. I also snagged a 68" sturgeon trolling once. That was a lot of fun. Thought I had the WR.

Shane


Edited by ShaneW 3/17/2007 6:11 AM
Tiger
Posted 3/16/2007 7:46 PM (#245267 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 221


Location: ohio
Caught a snapping turtle on a bucktail, snagged him in the foot, Thought I had a nice one till i got him up top,
He ended up being Deep fried....
walleye slyr
Posted 3/16/2007 7:52 PM (#245268 - in reply to #245267)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 37


Location: searchin for the first legal.
i havent caught anything unusaul that i can think of, but my dad caught a catfish on a spinnerbait and my mom caught a dogfish.
missourimuskyhunter
Posted 3/16/2007 8:00 PM (#245270 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 1316


Location: Lebanon,Mo
caught catfish on spinnerbaits

caught crappie on 6 inch jerkbaits

had follows from large gar with a suick

follows also from large shad with bucktail....that makes you wonder>>>>
c44hmusky
Posted 3/16/2007 8:39 PM (#245281 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 229


Location: Plover, WI
I once caught a 75' Oak Tree on a bucktail. Bit me off though...

TJ DeVoe
Posted 3/16/2007 8:44 PM (#245284 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 2323


Location: Stevens Point, WI
Last fall, I managed to hook a sucker that was obviously a wild sucker from the lake I was fishing on the actual sucker rig I was using. Had my sucker that I bought hooked and then I had this other sucker that some how hooked itself perfectly through the mouth like it was trying to share the hook with the bought sucker. Quite an ordeal, don't have a clue how it happened.
muskyboy
Posted 3/16/2007 8:45 PM (#245285 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?


A 10 pound Catfish trolling a Legend Plow
ToddM
Posted 3/16/2007 8:48 PM (#245286 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 20218


Location: oswego, il
Here is a fine trophy catch on a cranky nitro, an ernie and a dunwright dancer:



Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(06drum.jpg)


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(01dadcatfish.JPG)


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(41605 003 (2).jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments 06drum.jpg (51KB - 138 downloads)
Attachments 01dadcatfish.JPG (35KB - 139 downloads)
Attachments 41605 003 (2).jpg (38KB - 141 downloads)
Ranger
Posted 3/16/2007 9:01 PM (#245292 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 3867


Threw a bucktail toward a swirl I caught out of the corner of my eye, and like Tiger above, snagged a BIG snapping turtle in the rear leg. At first I thought I hooked a monster muskie, man he was tough to get to the boat.
Dan
Posted 3/16/2007 9:24 PM (#245296 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?


How bout a Loon and a 32" walleye.
jmuskieking
Posted 3/16/2007 9:35 PM (#245299 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 170


Location: Valparaiso , Indiana
I once caught a 55 inch gar on a glide bait! I thought I had a big musky until it started jumping out of the water like a Tarpon.

My brother once snagged a 8 foot Sturgeon! This thing dragged our boat around for 45 minutes before we even seen it! If you look at the pics below that's a mag bulldawg and a 20 in. sucker hanging off the side of it's head! That will give you a pretty good idea of just how big this fish was!


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(01.jpg)


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(02.jpg)


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(03.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments 01.jpg (32KB - 154 downloads)
Attachments 02.jpg (34KB - 166 downloads)
Attachments 03.jpg (54KB - 140 downloads)
Slimeball
Posted 3/16/2007 11:32 PM (#245307 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 332


Location: Michigan
Caught this chinook while casting a bucktail on the French River Delta a few years ago.


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(Chinook.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments Chinook.jpg (54KB - 147 downloads)
woodieb8
Posted 3/17/2007 5:18 AM (#245313 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 1529


chinook on lake st clair. lots of channel cats also.
DAHLTAILS
Posted 3/17/2007 9:31 AM (#245339 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 27


Location: FORT ATKINSON
I cought a rock bass on a creeper at night. I have also cought catfish on rattle baits.
Lone Stone
Posted 3/17/2007 10:06 AM (#245342 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 477


Location: Iowa
very large shad on a grandma, my largest largemouth on a buck tail and an 11 pound catfish on a DDD, the catfish had me going untill I saw what it was, sure was good in the frying pan though.
A-ROZ
Posted 3/17/2007 10:14 AM (#245346 - in reply to #245342)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 281


Location: Girdwood, Alaska
caught a gar on a weagle once... caught a chinook on a glider in the Fox River (De Pere) from shore, caught some big shad on a top H2O there also.
Decoy
Posted 3/17/2007 10:52 AM (#245349 - in reply to #245346)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 67


Caught a Tadpole on a bucktail, well actually snaged it. Good release though.
Musky53
Posted 3/17/2007 12:19 PM (#245357 - in reply to #245349)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 255


Put me down for a rock bass too! What is the deal with that. Also, picked up a nice jumbo perch. Both on large bucktails.
muskyboy
Posted 3/17/2007 12:39 PM (#245360 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?


Here's a snagged Shad


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(Shad.JPG)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments Shad.JPG (51KB - 142 downloads)
Big Perc
Posted 3/17/2007 2:21 PM (#245364 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 1185


Location: Iowa
A a 4 foot bull snake once one 10" believer...my biggest walleye on a jake...and one of my biggest largemouths on a ghostail...and a 25 lb anchor trolling a big bait...

Big Perc

Edited by Big Perc 3/18/2007 6:02 PM
Mike Wallace
Posted 3/17/2007 2:27 PM (#245365 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 37


I had a 10 lb Bowfin, or Dogfish, whichever you prefer, nail a bucktail on Minnetonka. Let it go and later found out it was close to the state record.

Mike
Rockin' SV
Posted 3/17/2007 2:33 PM (#245366 - in reply to #245365)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 425


Location: Elkhart, IN
I've caught both shad and perch on musky lures.
jonnysled
Posted 3/17/2007 3:49 PM (#245370 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 13688


Location: minocqua, wi.
a beaver and a pelican
muskie_man
Posted 3/17/2007 5:24 PM (#245379 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 1237


Location: South Portsmouth, KY
Throwin a Squirrely Burt over a weedbed once and set the hook and hauled in 2 largemouth bass on the same lure at the same time. Both bass were about 4 pounds each! Pretty cool!
jtroop
Posted 3/17/2007 5:47 PM (#245382 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 177


Location: Cohasset, MN
Dogfish on a big Eagle Tail and perch on a Bulldawg.
Rockin' SV
Posted 3/17/2007 8:13 PM (#245401 - in reply to #245299)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 425


Location: Elkhart, IN
jmuskieking - 3/16/2007 9:35 PM

I once caught a 55 inch gar on a glide bait! I thought I had a big musky until it started jumping out of the water like a Tarpon.

My brother once snagged a 8 foot Sturgeon! This thing dragged our boat around for 45 minutes before we even seen it! If you look at the pics below that's a mag bulldawg and a 20 in. sucker hanging off the side of it's head! That will give you a pretty good idea of just how big this fish was!


Hey Jeff, how many baits did you throw at that sturgeon? LOL
Will Dykstra
Posted 3/17/2007 10:26 PM (#245410 - in reply to #245401)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 113


How about a 32" walleye on a jackpot 12 noon in 2 feet of water.........High sun

Rock bass on a Creeper at night

Edited by Will Dykstra 3/17/2007 10:28 PM
ToddM
Posted 3/17/2007 11:01 PM (#245414 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 20218


Location: oswego, il
I should have added this one too to my earlier post, on a zam:



Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(TURTLE~11.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments TURTLE~11.jpg (89KB - 111 downloads)
Marshall
Posted 3/18/2007 7:18 AM (#245427 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 406


Location: Stones throw away...finally!!
Several crayfish on LOTW with bucktails over shallow rocks, and yes they actually had a hold of it. Fiesty little guys.
erico
Posted 3/18/2007 7:59 AM (#245432 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Location: Hayward WI
Got a buffalo on a baby bulldawg, didn't snag it, the fish had the lure in it's mouth.

Edited by erico 3/18/2007 8:04 AM
curleytail
Posted 3/18/2007 8:50 AM (#245442 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 2687


Location: Hayward, WI
Caught a 34" catfish trolling a jointed shallow Raider. Really crushed it too. Not much else too crazy. Caught about a 7 inch largemouth on a 9 inch Suick.

curleytail
Renaldo
Posted 3/18/2007 9:52 AM (#245450 - in reply to #245427)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 101


Location: Northern Illinois
I remember this one from many moons ago. We were standing on the pier waiting for the rest of the guys, when my buddy wanted to show me the action on his new homemade bait. It was sort of a grey Suick type jerkbait. He cast it out from the pier, jerked it once, when a huge osprey came swooping down from a pine tree and picked it up and tried to fly away with it. Luckily it let it go when it felt the tension from the line. I wouldn't want any part of trying to extricate hooks out of that thing.
GOTONE
Posted 3/18/2007 12:56 PM (#245476 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 476


Location: WI
most unusual species...12 lb achor on Eagle River Chain. It wanted to stay deep and I had a hard time getting it in.

I kept her too.

GotOne
Jer Sondag
Posted 3/18/2007 6:56 PM (#245529 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 4


Location: Pelican Rapids, MN
Last summer on Leech Lake I was casting a white Sili Girl in some sparce cabbage when I felt dead weight on the end of my line. To my surprise it was a 33 inch eel pout that was hooked in the top of the head.
EsoxRookie
Posted 3/18/2007 7:43 PM (#245546 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 107


Location: milwaukee
I hooked a ~20-lb carp in the back with a spinnerbait. I'm bringing it up sideways with a mass of weeds on it. Hadn't caught a muskie before that, so I'm thinking I have my first. And also thinking, 'geez these things don't fight *that* hard'.

Also a 31" walleye on a Lil' Ernie.

Boat partner caught a 4" largemouth on a Top Raider.
nutty4muskies
Posted 3/18/2007 8:21 PM (#245560 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 32


Had an osprey take a dive after a client's 10" crappie colored Jake as it lay on the surface during a backlash remedial moment...I saw the bird start to dive but jerked the line hand over hand to take it away...didn't want to deal with removing the hooks from such a beautiful and ferocious bird if it was ticked off...

Al Nutty
Kinkaid Lake Guide Service
Been Nutty all my life...the insanity is a recent affliction!!
c44hmusky
Posted 3/18/2007 8:45 PM (#245564 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 229


Location: Plover, WI
Why just yesterday, I was with Slamr trolling the big pond when he screamed "There's a fish!" After a good fight, he pulled in a 7' landing net. What a beautiful specimen!!!

Of course, we weren't muskie fishing, but I had to share that.

Edited by c44hmusky 3/18/2007 9:07 PM
Lightning
Posted 3/18/2007 8:54 PM (#245567 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 485


Location: On my favorite lake!
I caught a 25 in sucker in Kentucky. After I threw the thing back the guy that was down the bank from me said it was probably close to a record.
Jer Sondag
Posted 3/18/2007 9:55 PM (#245585 - in reply to #245427)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 4


Location: Pelican Rapids, MN
Also had a Bowfin hit a brown Harasser.

Edited by Jer Sondag 3/18/2007 10:02 PM
Muskie Junkie
Posted 3/19/2007 7:11 AM (#245619 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 250


3 years ago I caught this 30 inch dogfish. It hit a chartreuse clown Viper. Pretty ugly fish.


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(30_Dogfish_Mohawksin_605041.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments 30_Dogfish_Mohawksin_605041.jpg (28KB - 117 downloads)
nwick
Posted 3/19/2007 3:40 PM (#245745 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 59


Location: WI
A friend of mine snagged a bald eagle casting. Had a devil of a time releasing it, but it did fly away.
The Nate
Posted 3/19/2007 8:10 PM (#245817 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Homo sapien (aka the guy in the front of the boat)...................actually I can't take credit for this as it was my friend that did the actual hooking. Now the point in time when you realize you are a lesser man is when the person hooked gets out his pocket knife and tries to cut it out instead of heading in, in order to save some fishing time. Alas once hooks penetrate bone they apparently don't come out very easy......as the emergency room doctor even had a hard time.


Edited by The Nate 3/20/2007 7:02 AM



Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(bob and bulldawg.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments bob and bulldawg.jpg (30KB - 182 downloads)
sworrall
Posted 3/19/2007 8:13 PM (#245819 - in reply to #245817)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 32886


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
OWWWWWWWW!
Brett Carroll
Posted 3/19/2007 9:23 PM (#245832 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 696


Location: Northern Illinois
While fishing our home lake we were hitting the docks and my Uncle cast towards it. He istantly had a hit and set the hook. I jumped down and got the net ready and then it was just tight. He said, "Nevermind...I'm caught!" Then all of a sudden it started fighting. He yelled, "I do have one! Get the net!" I got back up there and the same thing happened. We went over towards where he was caught and he had a Northern around 29-30 inches hit his bait. Problem was that the Northern was already on a stringer! I couldn't believe it! Goes to show that a Northern will hit in any situation!
MuskieMedic
Posted 3/19/2007 9:27 PM (#245837 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 2091


Location: Stevens Point, WI
Bowfin on a topraider!
BRAINSX
Posted 3/19/2007 9:59 PM (#245848 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?


Snapping Turtles (3), Crayfish, 50"/50# Sturgeon, Huge bass & Walleye, Gar, Great Blue Heron (jackpot), a Booby (Australian bird), Frigate Bird, almost a loon & some seagulls, a few ski boats and a ski tow line, a waverunner, Gizzard shad, white bass, perch, 32# carp, and of course myself!
rpieske
Posted 3/20/2007 6:09 AM (#245870 - in reply to #245427)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 484


Location: St. Louis, MO., Marco Is., FL, Nestor Falls, ON
I've caught water snakes, many large walleyes, rock bass, lake trout and this really big snapping turtle.




Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(Turtle2.JPG)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments Turtle2.JPG (21KB - 117 downloads)
Magruter
Posted 3/20/2007 6:56 AM (#245883 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 1316


Location: Madison, WI
Can't believe that guy has a smile on his face!!!! That looks painful!
dedicated angler
Posted 3/20/2007 9:47 AM (#245917 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?


In no particular order -
A rock, the hook lodged in a little crack in the rock. The rock was successfully released.
A fishing rod- Kept - Grannie
A rug - Believer
A old school steel beer can - Grannie
A tennis ball - trolling 25' on a ernie

I hooked a bunch of Perch Snagged some, and had one eat a bucktail.

Pointerpride102
Posted 3/20/2007 4:04 PM (#246016 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: Re: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 16632


Location: The desert
I landed a rock when I was about 5. My dad and I were fishing pelican and I had my little zebco rod with the push button reel. Set the hook on the rock and somehow got it off the bottom of the lake. As kids will do I was moving my rod around side to side trying to fight the 'fish' which caused the rock to swing back and fort, which felt like a giant fish running. Even my dad was excited as he had the net all ready, once I finally gained enough line he saw it was a rock, but netted it for me anyways. We released the rock back at the dock.

Also my buddy and I rented a boat from smokey's on Pewaukee to do some fishing. I was trolling a big jake and landed a Berkley Lightning rod. On the very next pass I landed a bucktail. This passed year I got out with Ben Keung and we landed a ski tow rope.

I have also caught a bunch of crayfish, snails, clams, bass etc.
Mr Musky
Posted 3/20/2007 6:24 PM (#246047 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?





Posts: 999


I had a 14 inch Smallmouth bass attack my quickset 14 inch sucker rig and it somehow got caught on one of the trebles. I didn't know it until I seen my sucker line going crazy so I reeled it up and the smallie attached right along side of it!

Mr Musky
rpike
Posted 3/21/2007 8:52 AM (#246210 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 291


Location: Minneapolis
Two perch simultaneously on a fuzzy duzzit. Both were impaled in their mid sections. I was definitely jigging near the bait fish that day!
semper esox
Posted 3/21/2007 3:43 PM (#246296 - in reply to #246210)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?




Posts: 217


Location: ladysmith, wi
1. A CAR TIRE 2. A LIFE VEST THAT GAVE ME ONE HECK OF A FIGHT WHEN IT HIT THE CURRENT. 3. LOON 4. A OWL NIGHT FISHING FOR BASS. AND MY BOAT PARTNER ALSO HOOKED A BIG SNAPPER
Muskaluck
Posted 3/21/2007 8:13 PM (#246372 - in reply to #245264)
Subject: RE: What's the most unusual species you've caught while muskie fishing?


Large catfish on a surface bait.