What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?
BruceKY
Posted 2/15/2005 8:24 PM (#135161)
Subject: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Posts: 392


Location: KY
This one is for you guides. What lure do you snap on for a client that has almost no experience fishing? Lets assume they can handle a rod well enough to cast without backlashes and can get a sinking lure moving before it buries itself in weeds. Is there one lure that can’t be fished wrong? Is it a topwater, a bucktail, a spinnerbait, a bulldawg or ___?
nwild
Posted 2/15/2005 9:17 PM (#135167 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Posts: 1996


Location: Pelican Lake/Three Lakes Chain
If the fish are the least bit active the two baits I have clients use the most are bucktails and topwater. They are both very easy baits to work, basically just a straight retrieve. The bucktail is a very high percentage hooker, and the topwater is the best as far as excitement.
muskyboy
Posted 2/15/2005 9:34 PM (#135173 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?


Bucktails
Spinnerbaits
Topwaters

All very easy to use and productive
sworrall
Posted 2/15/2005 10:49 PM (#135177 - in reply to #135173)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Posts: 32935


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
For easy, nothing beats a Spinnerbait. Basically weedless, can't be worked improperly if it's moving. Just cast and crank no matter the cover, slop, wind, or other variables.
Chartertalk
Posted 2/16/2005 5:04 AM (#135183 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?




Posts: 71


Location: Lake St. Clair
I have to go with the spinnerbait too. Inline are a close second.
The Handyman
Posted 2/16/2005 6:05 AM (#135186 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?




Posts: 1046


I am not a guide, but will go 100% with the spinnerbait! Very underated tool!
Dacron+Dip
Posted 2/16/2005 6:47 AM (#135190 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?


Another vote for a spinnerbait. Inlines gotta be moving fwd to work, and some need a 'jump start' to get the balde working. Even when a spinnerbait's falling it's working for you. Great hookers, far more customizable than an inline (trailers, trailer hooks, blades and skirts all easy to modify). And a spinnerbait runs cleaner all round, too. Spinnerbait's a way better trolling tool than an inline, in my opinion also. Grim Reapers, Fudally, Shumway.
Gander Mt Guide
Posted 2/16/2005 8:27 AM (#135203 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Posts: 2515


Location: Waukesha & Land O Lakes, WI
Obviously spinner baits and lipped cranks are going to be your easiest to use right out of the box. Even if you don't "bulge" your spinners or "snap-tug-pause" your crank, you can still catch fish.

Gliders and Jerks is where the technique comes in. Personally, I'm new to gliders, but last season, especially the end of last season, all I threw were glide baits. The easiest glider to use in my opinion???

Wood on the Water Power Probe, the mini especially. All you need to do is turn the crank and she starts swaying like a drunken 16 year old girl on the dance floor! So simple that you won't believe it's runnng right, but it is.
pgaschulz
Posted 2/16/2005 9:21 AM (#135208 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Posts: 561


Location: Monee, Illinois
Not a guide but SS Shad cast it and reel it...
marine_1
Posted 2/16/2005 9:27 AM (#135210 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Posts: 699


Location: Hugo, MN
1) Spinnerbait
2) Small Bucktail
3) Top Raider
4) Salmo Slider
Pete Stoltman
Posted 2/16/2005 11:08 AM (#135233 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?




Posts: 663


One of the best is the 7" Crane in my opinion. Can't goof it up and it's a fish catcher.
Netman
Posted 2/16/2005 11:36 AM (#135243 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Posts: 880


Location: New Berlin,Wisconsin,53151
I have to agree with GMG, the Power Probe is one of the few baits that will sway by just cranking it in. Another is the Weagle (good luck getting one) if your fishing top water, you can crank in, pause and crank again. Great surface presentation. Cady do you want to sell me some blanks?

Netman
Guest
Posted 2/16/2005 2:49 PM (#135288 - in reply to #135243)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?


What time of year and under what conditions do you use the Power Probe?
Gander Mt Guide
Posted 2/16/2005 2:52 PM (#135289 - in reply to #135288)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Posts: 2515


Location: Waukesha & Land O Lakes, WI
PP's can be used at any time. Early spring, go with the mini. It's a countdown glider so it can be used over weeds and structure at any depth you want.
jlong
Posted 2/16/2005 2:59 PM (#135292 - in reply to #135289)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Posts: 1938


Location: Black Creek, WI
For guides to hand a novice client, I would think a topwater such as the Topraider would be the best. The topraider casts well... and floats so backlashes are less of an issue with snags. It is visual so the angler knows what his lure is doing... and where it is.... at all times. The guide can HEAR if the client is using it properly (speed) without having to keep his eye on it.

For times when topwater won't work well enough to make a client happy (cooler water periods?)... the Depthraider/Babyraider is probably a good choice... along with a spinnerbait.

Just a few ideas...

jlong
Muskydr
Posted 2/16/2005 3:01 PM (#135293 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?




Posts: 686


Location: Tomahawk, Wisconsin
Can't go wrong tossing small bucktails and I have yet to have a client that could not master a small twitch bait such as an AC Shiner, I have my 5 year old son throwing various topwaters....... fish on!!!!!!!!!
saint1
Posted 2/16/2005 3:03 PM (#135295 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?




Posts: 332


Location: Neenah, WI
In my opinion I think the bucktail or a spinnerbait are the easiest to use and are good Hookers.

Topwater run a close second (topwaters with rotating tails- Tally wackers and Topraiders)
Mark H.
Posted 2/16/2005 3:25 PM (#135301 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?




Posts: 1936


Location: Eau Claire, WI
Topwater, spinnerbaits/bucktails, and the easiest to work and catches fish like a mother.... jerkbait has to be the magnum or 8" Slow Tease from Hawgseeker Tackle.

And let's not forget Slammer and Big Game twitch baits... Hardly a right or wrong way to use these.

I guess if they can cast I can usually have them working most baits in short order... It's the ones who have challenges casting that are a bit more entertaining to coach...
Lightning
Posted 2/16/2005 4:04 PM (#135313 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?


Spinnerbait. One hook easy to see. Doesn't catch a lot of weeds.
BNelson
Posted 2/16/2005 4:18 PM (#135320 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?





Location: Contrarian Island
Not a guide but I've taken out my share of novices..
Nothing beats a TopRaider or other inline topwater for ease of casting and they usually have fun listening and watching the bait.
If the topwater bite isn't on I'd go with a shallow running crank.
If over deep water where weeds aren't an issue a depth raider or Triple D.
good luck
Reef Hawg
Posted 2/16/2005 4:26 PM (#135327 - in reply to #135161)
Subject: RE: What is the easiest lure to use and catch fish?




Posts: 3518


Location: north central wisconsin
No doubt it would be a tail type topwater. Though I have seen lakes and more so rivers in WI where spinner type lures just did not produce, I have not seen a water where muskies ignore a surface lure. easiest lure for a novice to cast, and as jlong said, one can pick out a lash and the lure is usually right where you left it(or just downstream from). Next in line would be a crane bait or small granny as someone else mentioned, and a spinnerbait would be my third pick.

If I were choosing for MN, it would be a spinnerbait. Those fish eat them more readily over there than on the lakes I fish here for some reason....

Edited by Reef Hawg 2/16/2005 4:28 PM