If you could only bring 3 baits.......
Thrasher330
Posted 8/19/2004 2:06 PM (#115787)
Subject: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 146


Location: Wayzata, MN
OK, maybe it's just because I'm still on the DL with a back injury [hope to get back at it next week]...
but, it's time for some banter...

QUESTION: If you could only have THREE baits total in your boat, what would they be?

Me?
1) Single treble bucktail, black hair with a little brown & red, with a gold blade
2) 8" Topraider [black & orange]
3) 10" Jointed Believer [redhead, I affectionately call the 'pink steel']
marine_1
Posted 8/19/2004 2:12 PM (#115788 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 699


Location: Hugo, MN
1) Silver/Blue Lilly Tail
2) Bubble Gum Lilly Tail
3) Viper with Sucker pattern.
muskymeyer
Posted 8/19/2004 2:16 PM (#115789 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 691


Location: nationwide
I hate to think this hard but here it goes.

6" white perch crane bait
7" black pacemaker
flame colorado blade, black haired bucktail - Rabid Squirrel has been hot this year for me

Not for all lakes, just the two I fish alot.

Corey Meyer



Edited by muskymeyer 8/19/2004 2:17 PM
Gander Mt Guide
Posted 8/19/2004 2:17 PM (#115790 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 2515


Location: Waukesha & Land O Lakes, WI
Large Black w/ Nickel Rizzo Whiz
7" Walleye Slammer
Jointed Depth Raider...Bob Zilokowski custom paint job....orange with black dots and gold scale pattern. My new favorite bait.
Slamr
Posted 8/19/2004 2:23 PM (#115792 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 7119


Location: Northwest Chicago Burbs
Easy answer, because I usually only bring 10 (at most) in the boat anyways....though the list changes from lake to lake, but I'll give it a go here:

1. 10" Jake in Tenn Shad
2. Bucher Straight Depthraider in Perch
3. 6" Hughes River Shaker in Whitefish.

I can work the baby shaker fast, slow, deep, rythmically or erratically, and can even troll it. The big Jake is just a giant killer, no questioning that, and it can be worked in a zillion different ways like the shaker. The d-raider can be trolled, cast straight, or twitched shallow. And come on, Muskies love perch.
It was hard not to put a Violent Strike spinnerbait or Voodoo Tails bucktail up there, but those generally only get the summer treatment, while I will use the above three choices all year round.
Steve Jonesi
Posted 8/19/2004 2:23 PM (#115793 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 2089


Weagle-Perch
M/G Spinnerbait-Black/Gold
Weighted 10" Suick-Sucker

I love these threads!

One more....Cisco Mag Dawg
B420
Posted 8/19/2004 2:32 PM (#115794 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 382


1. Crappie phantom
2. Walleye Viper
3. Black and gold mepps musky killer

one more- cisco regular bulldawg
KOMER
Dacron+Dip
Posted 8/19/2004 2:32 PM (#115795 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......


10" Jake or Believer, TN Shad, Glitter Perch, Finlander, Walleye.
9" bootail, gold on blk/orng
10" weighted Suick black w/goldfleck back/ hot org belly or 8" white belly perch Bobbie, weighted.
Blackbird pattern TopRaider (OK, that's 4 baits total)
muskiemachinery
Posted 8/19/2004 2:37 PM (#115797 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......


6 inch MRG Custom Atomic Perch Cobb CD
10 inch Jake-old style Walleye finish
M&G Lunker Single Spin-Brown/orange with a magnum Colorado brass or orange blade



Novak DD Zip Glider-Okoboji Walleye

Edited by muskiemachinery 8/19/2004 2:54 PM
muskihntr
Posted 8/19/2004 2:39 PM (#115799 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 2037


Location: lansing, il
mag dawg blk/org
cobb drop belly glider purple/silv/blk
top raider any color
Phish Killer
Posted 8/19/2004 2:45 PM (#115801 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 827


Location: Minneapolis,Minnesota
1) Large red Pacemaker -once I figure out the trick to keeping big fish pinned on this bait it'll be a good producer. It's my most chewed up bait that has yet to bring one to the net.

2) Crappie Weagel -I will retire the one I have as soon as I can get another one. Mine looks like it's been thru a mortar attack.

3) White/nickle Snowcrest Willow buck -good color pattern for all types of water. Burns easy and can be worked deep if need be.

That would be my three for now...next year it might change to three other baits. If I had a few more I would throw in a 6" HR Hughey, a J-Mac jig and a Suick.
jlong
Posted 8/19/2004 2:46 PM (#115802 - in reply to #115799)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 1939


Location: Black Creek, WI
Hmmmmm.... these posts always make you think.

I'd be happy from opener to ice-up with:

1. 10" Jake (some sort of sucker flavor)
2. TripleD (some sort of cisco flavor)
3. Homemade Bucktail (don't really care what color)

Awww heck... I could probably be content with the Jake and Bucktail if need be. Despite that, I still bring 10,000 lures along JUST IN CASE (heh heh).

jlong
Beaver
Posted 8/19/2004 3:18 PM (#115811 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 4266


CJ spinnerbait in Crappie
Small Pacemaker in black
8" Shaker in Bluegill, or one of my new gliders
Beav
Mike K
Posted 8/19/2004 4:40 PM (#115819 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......


1) Black /Ornge Ace Tandem
2) large Pacemaker
3) Jackpot/Viper

Evar D
Posted 8/19/2004 5:11 PM (#115824 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 184


Location: Rockford Il 61108
Mepps magnum-yellow bucktail

Dancin raider- Bucher

Shallow raider- perch pattern
muskyboy
Posted 8/19/2004 5:45 PM (#115826 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......


Custom Pearson Pearch colored DDD
CJ's Spinnerbait Crappie Pattern
Magnum Lowrider

100s of others to mention, so how about a what's your top 100 question?

Steve
pgaschulz
Posted 8/19/2004 7:20 PM (#115836 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 561


Location: Monee, Illinois
1. SS Shad (Custom Color) White/Black Spots
2. Jack Pot/Black Orange Belly
3. Sledge/Green Black Dots

Heck do I throw anything else?

Ask Mike Hubert and Chris Walker (Guides) If I throw anything else.

P.S. Mike did you notice I didn't say Grey Ghost or Weagle

Pgaschulz AKA SS Bob
AFChief
Posted 8/19/2004 8:24 PM (#115840 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 550


Location: So. Illinois
Rapala Super Shad
8" Jointed believer
Musky Buster Top Walker

Chief
Kevin Mahlberg
Posted 8/19/2004 8:58 PM (#115847 - in reply to #115840)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 156


Location: Oconomowoc, WI
yellow/black Crane 207
black/orange Topraider
black hair/orange blade MuskieCatcher floating bucktail
ToddM
Posted 8/19/2004 9:21 PM (#115852 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 20281


Location: oswego, il
I could not do it. I would be lucky if I could bring 3 bait boxes.
Mauser
Posted 8/20/2004 5:46 AM (#115895 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 724


Location: Southern W.Va.
Tough question but here goes:

1) Red perch 9" unweighted Sledge [ LOTW Killer]
2) tandem Mepps Musky Killer spinner bait , gold blade / black& orange hair
3) Topraider

But like everyone else, I COULD take 3 or 4 BOXES and still wish I had more .

Mauser
phil phillips
Posted 8/20/2004 6:50 AM (#115900 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......


1) TRIPLE D - Bumble Bee
2) RAD DOG - Black/Orange
3) PACE MAKER- Black

That is all I will ever need.
tuffy1
Posted 8/20/2004 7:53 AM (#115907 - in reply to #115900)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 3242


Location: Racine, Wi
The custom Kly Weagle
A black and gold jointed Grandma
Cisco bulldawg.

Matter of fact, those will be the 3 I am throwing this weekend. (aside from the other 10K baits I will likely bring.

I hate this trolling/casting bite at the same time. Too many baits in the boat. (did I say too many??!!) Not enough baits in the boat. LOL
Reef Hawg
Posted 8/20/2004 8:27 AM (#115913 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 3518


Location: north central wisconsin
<p>Rad dog spinnerbait(green)</p><p>Topraider(any color)</p><p>10" Jake(t-shad)</p><p /><p>Maybe trade the spinner bait for an inline bucktail of choice, and maybe trade the jake for 6" reef hawg at times.</p>
sorenson
Posted 8/20/2004 8:52 AM (#115918 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 1764


Location: Ogden, Ut
In no particular order...(Utah waters only; if I fished elsewhere, this list would probably suck)

J-13 Rapala; firetiger or perch
Mepps Muskie Killer; black/gold
spring dawg; black/orange tail (or all black)

I can pretty much cover all of my local needs w/ those 3...despite bringing along as many as 3 boxes...

K.
firstsixfeet
Posted 8/20/2004 9:01 AM (#115920 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......


I would have to have a pull bait, something with a spinner, and a surface bait and a deeper bait.

Pull bait would have to be a burt in original rainbow, but if somebody stuck me with a fooler, suick, or small Bobbie, I could live with those.

I probably err by not taking a spinnerbait, but need to have the highspeed option available, so gotta take something with a #5 aglia blade in chartreuse(good all around color)and a black tail definitely black, somewhat close to magnum bootail specs, weight and size wize and have to carry 2 sets of trebles.

Deep and high are left and though it is not the BEST tool for either, I could live with a jointed depth raider, black or natural, no black. Crank it slow and it is appealing, crank it deep and it makes contact. If somebody made me take a straight depth raider instead or a triple D, I could work with either.
dedicated angler
Posted 8/20/2004 9:34 AM (#115931 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 24


Da Gooch - Blk and red Tallywacker
Durst Custom 9" Granny in Sunset Carp
Mepps Giant Killer Gold Blade over perch colored hair
C_Nelson
Posted 8/20/2004 1:33 PM (#115966 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 578


Location: Sheboygan Falls, WI
Weagle- Perch, I guess that's what it is anyway. Steve Jonesi knows the color
Mepps Musky Marabou- White Pearl Blade/Black-White tail
Mepps Musky Marabou- Chartreuse Blade/Black-Chartreuse tail

I would take those 3 so everyone could see, then I would sneak in a Top Raider (BullFrog), Hawg Wobbler (Black) and a Shallow Invader (Walleye). I would also sneak in a silver Mepps Musky Marabou blade, no tail needed as I would put it on the black and white tail.

Just look at those Mepps; and to think that I do not even work for the company anymore. Working for them or not, they are still producing fish for me.

Chuck
Goonga Moonga
Posted 8/20/2004 11:13 PM (#116034 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......


Black/Orange Grim Reaper Bucktail
Black/White Jackpot
J.A.L. from Musky Nut (perch)
nwick
Posted 8/21/2004 12:20 AM (#116040 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 59


Location: WI
Globe
Creeper
Flaptail
Alternate: Thumper
You know whose.
greenduck
Posted 8/21/2004 8:11 PM (#116072 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 354


1. Joel Wick Creeper
2. Eagletail - red hair/yellow blade
3. Bulldawg
BillC. aka the greenduck
lobi
Posted 8/21/2004 11:39 PM (#116083 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......





Posts: 1137


Location: Holly, MI
Here we go again huh? Beats picking one.

Jointed Perch Wiley (trolling)
Jointed Believer (troll, twitch, surface crawl, crank)
Slow sink glider (I think I'll keep my home made upside down perch)


Zoom - | Zoom 100% | Zoom + | Expand / Contract | Open New window
Click to expand / contract the width of this image
(sucks7.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments sucks7.jpg (10KB - 81 downloads)
Buckeyefan
Posted 8/22/2004 9:12 AM (#116098 - in reply to #115787)
Subject: RE: If you could only bring 3 baits.......




Posts: 37


1. Crane 207 (crappie)
2. Reef Hawg (green flame)
3. Spinner Bait (Black with silver willows)