Muskie article from Kennebec, Maine
djwilliams
Posted 2/22/2004 3:58 PM (#98066)
Subject: Muskie article from Kennebec, Maine




Posts: 787


Location: Ames, Iowa
Guys- Read this article found on the Muskie First homepage. I rarely pay attention to these and go straight to the message board. Very different opinion of muskies than we have, and interesting.
Don
firstsixfeet
Posted 2/22/2004 9:42 PM (#98098 - in reply to #98066)
Subject: RE: Muskie article from Kennebec, Maine




Posts: 2361


Isn't this just the wildest most exciting news in muskydom?

Imagine a pioneer population of wild strain, hopefully great lakes musky establishing natural reproduction in new waters and eating trout and salmon. This Basely must absolutely be the most uneducated fishery biologist in the world. How in the world does he equate a musky population with the doom of the brook trout? This is pure and simple false information put forth by the department and villifies the fish rather than treats them as a brand new resource. These guys are public relations idiots. What better shot in the arm for areas that need economic input than to have a new game specie that grows far and away bigger than anything in the country. Surely the trout that subsist with northern pike in many waters would be able to tolerate musky as a neighbor. With our luck, that same Canadian bunch will decide to stock northern pike next and then not only will the trout fishery be gone but also the brand new musky fishery. Who wants to go to Maine before they're all gone? I gotta boat!
tomyv
Posted 2/23/2004 8:51 AM (#98120 - in reply to #98098)
Subject: RE: Muskie article from Kennebec, Maine




Posts: 1310


Location: Washington, PA
That story reminds me of the arguments I've had with countless groups in PA. They want the muskies gone from the streams, because they "want to restore the resource back to it's natural state" yet, upon further research, they think the muskies are eating the hatchery stocked trout. To funny. I know it's differant, but it hit's close to home.
gimo
Posted 2/23/2004 9:11 AM (#98122 - in reply to #98066)
Subject: RE: Muskie article from Kennebec, Maine




Posts: 342


Location: Passaic, NJ - Upper French River, ON
I'll be emailing that article to Paul McKeown at the New York State DEC, maybe they can talk biologist to biologist.
Anybody else have some sources - maybe from the Canadian side as well ?
lobi
Posted 2/23/2004 1:01 PM (#98160 - in reply to #98066)
Subject: RE: Muskie article from Kennebec, Maine





Posts: 1137


Location: Holly, MI
From the article.."There is no size or bag limit on muskies. The Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife recommends that anglers catch and kill all muskies, no matter what size."

Bummer!

However, also from the article.."Unfortunately, there are anglers throwing them back when they catch one, hoping they'll grow bigger next winter," said Basley. "I've seen ice fishermen throwing muskies back that weigh 15 pounds." <--you go guys!!!