Top 5 Trolling baits under $40
T3clay
Posted 7/2/2018 7:10 AM (#911315)
Subject: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 770


For all you trollers out there I was wondering.if you would.list your top 5 Trolling baits under $40 each
tkuntz
Posted 7/2/2018 11:32 AM (#911338 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 815


Location: Waukee, IA
In no apparent order
Grandma
DC10
Slammer Minnow
Believer
Shallow raider
supertrollr
Posted 7/2/2018 12:24 PM (#911345 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40


believer
depthraider
wiley deepdiver
original cedar bk chubbies (not riverrun plastic one)
wrangler
ToddM
Posted 7/2/2018 1:03 PM (#911352 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 20219


Location: oswego, il
Lures are tools, what you need to know is what are the best tools for a specific situation.
pklingen
Posted 7/2/2018 7:13 PM (#911409 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 864


Location: NE Ohio
4" BAKER
5" BAKER
5" TUFF SHAD
8" TUFF SHAD
REPEAT

T3clay
Posted 7/2/2018 10:41 PM (#911426 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 770


Supertroller is that the cisco kid Wrangler?

I have never caught a muskie trolling and rarely do it. Right now when I do troll it's pretty half cocked.... I would like to get a few good trolling baits so that when I do troll I'm not just aimlessly trolling one of my casting cranks. I have a few depthraiders straight and jointed. But don't ha e a ton of confidence in them. I would like to get a few believers and maybe headlock or two some day down the road but would like other suggestiins

I do also have a few Grandma's.
Marc_Grattan
Posted 7/2/2018 10:42 PM (#911427 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 136


Grandmas, Wileys, Tuff Shads, Boss Shads, Ziggies. Plus many more...
IAJustin
Posted 7/2/2018 11:13 PM (#911429 - in reply to #911427)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 2015


I’d definitely get a couple of 10” Jakes and a 10” jointed believers..I don’t troll much (maybe 10% of my Muskie Fishing time) but have several 100 trolling those two baits over the years..
supertrollr
Posted 7/3/2018 9:07 AM (#911448 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40


yes
JakeStCroixSkis
Posted 7/3/2018 5:38 PM (#911474 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 1425


Location: St. Lawrence River
10" straight believer, 10" jointed believer. You will have 4 baits right there, with these two lures. And should be able to get it done.
supertrollr
Posted 7/3/2018 7:25 PM (#911477 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40


t3 you cheat ,headlock worth more than 40.now if you want to play with lures over 40 you absolutely need at least a perchbait for sure
T3clay
Posted 7/4/2018 8:41 AM (#911494 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 770


I'm not buying a headlock anytime soon....
Lizmorea
Posted 7/5/2018 12:11 AM (#911553 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 29


I only troll late fall when it's too cold to cast.
I only run 2 baits.
Chewies and river slicks.
ToddM
Posted 7/5/2018 5:00 AM (#911555 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 20219


Location: oswego, il
Bagley monster shad
Bagley DB6
Depth raider
Bably depth raider
4" Tuff shad
Masqui-ninja
Posted 7/5/2018 8:46 AM (#911560 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 1247


Location: Walker, MN
For under $40 you can't go wrong with Jakes, Grandmas and Believers.
My dark horse would be a Bomber CD 30.
tyler k
Posted 7/5/2018 9:48 AM (#911566 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 409


Location: Almond, WI
Another vote for the 10" jointed Believer, it is my #1 trolling confidence bait. It is a bait I truly rave about, for only $20 and I can buy them at Fleet Farm it's hard to go wrong. Be careful when storing them, I've had some 8" Believers pop at the top seam from overheating in a clear box (10" have not been a issue so far but be careful anyway).
10" Slammer.
Troll those Grannies.

I'd like to experiment more with Mag Shallow Invaders, I think they have potential.

There's a bit of a split among the answers here. Most of the Northwoods fisherman pick big baits, the Southern shad based fisherman pick small baits. Doesn't mean a bait won't work in both--I know some excellent Southern reservoir fisherman that love 10" Believers, and I caught one on an 8" Believer last time I was in MN.

You can make minnow style baits "walk." Take your pliers or lure tuner and bend the two belly hook hangers in opposite directions. I first learned this from an old Spence Petros article, and it works.
T3clay
Posted 7/5/2018 10:11 PM (#911632 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 770


Thanks everyone, looks like I need to invest in some believers,. How deep will they run?
IAJustin
Posted 7/6/2018 6:50 AM (#911635 - in reply to #911632)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 2015


I run them anywhere from 5-15 feet deep.. Lots of factors to how deep a lure will run trolling , A lot of times I like keeping them up.. running them behind boards with 20-40 feet of line behind the board for suspended fish ..
supertrollr
Posted 7/6/2018 11:17 AM (#911663 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40


imo if you want to troll you have to buy muskymike's trolling secrets
tyler k
Posted 7/6/2018 12:10 PM (#911667 - in reply to #911663)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 409


Location: Almond, WI
Personally I like to fish high in spring/early summer, I run baits 4 to 10 feet. I usually run my Believers at 6 feet deep, with a 10" Believer I think that's 25' with 80lb braid and 36' with 50lb mono (top of my head). Believers have both deep and shallow settings, plus some of the East Coast guys add split rings to both eyes and snap them together creating a mid depth setting.

Don't just think this is an open water mid-lake thing; hit the secondary breakline, hit the deep weed edge, hit the gap between the weedline and breakline if there is one.

Like Supertroller said, get a copy of Musky Mike's Trolling Secrets. I've found it accurate. It has dive charts for most common baits and line combinations. You can download it off of Drifter Tackle's website last I checked. I think it's about $20.
T3clay
Posted 7/6/2018 2:09 PM (#911678 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 770


Cool, thanks everyone
T3clay
Posted 7/6/2018 4:01 PM (#911681 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40





Posts: 770


Cool, thanks everyone
danmuskyman
Posted 7/6/2018 4:20 PM (#911683 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 633


Location: Madison, WI
Check out JBo baits if you like baits that walk. Can be had for $35-$45
supertrollr
Posted 7/6/2018 7:48 PM (#911689 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40


it's really strange no 53 inch story?
TheShow
Posted 7/10/2018 6:41 AM (#911940 - in reply to #911689)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 351


Location: Vilas County, WI
Are you guys using the shallow eye on the Believers more so than the deep eyelet?
supertrollr
Posted 7/10/2018 8:40 AM (#911947 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40


both but mostly deep. the straight 10 incher can't handle it sometimes
djwilliams
Posted 7/10/2018 10:33 AM (#911954 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 770


Location: Ames, Iowa
I troll a lot of spinnerbaits. I would suggest in the summer trying that on beaches, edges, flats to cover water. I troll larger Slammers and prefer them over Grandmas as I think they are better built and hold together over time. We have twitched the lips right off Grandmas. The 10-13 inch crankbaits run about 14-16 feet at 3.5 mph. I am usually trolling water 10-18 feet deep, and use the Spinnerbaits for anything under 12 feet. Caught a couple trolling beaches last summer.
southern comfort
Posted 7/10/2018 10:44 AM (#911955 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 393


Try Supermodel DCG bucktails and Shallow Invaders.
woodieb8
Posted 7/10/2018 6:44 PM (#912008 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 1529


Georgie,chewie,and shaggin shads..,each size has a time and place.
tackleaddict
Posted 7/11/2018 11:41 AM (#912048 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40




Posts: 431


ziggies were my favorite back in my trolling days. straight 6" and straight 8".
supertrollr
Posted 7/11/2018 7:56 PM (#912100 - in reply to #911315)
Subject: Re: Top 5 Trolling baits under $40


have never try them but he paint the nicest walleye pattern i have ever seen.