Water temp for blades
25homes
Posted 3/10/2017 4:01 PM (#852883)
Subject: Water temp for blades





Posts: 983


So in early season at what temp does water need to get to b4 blade baits will be effective? Bucktail and spinner baits mainly even to slow roll them
esoxaddict
Posted 3/10/2017 4:04 PM (#852884 - in reply to #852883)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades





Posts: 8835


33
IAJustin
Posted 3/10/2017 4:56 PM (#852887 - in reply to #852883)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades




Posts: 2068


I rarely throw blades in the spring until water reaches 60 degrees, I just have more confidence in other presentations. In the fall I'll slow roll blades with water temps in the 40's and fish chew them.. no hard rules with muskies, can you catch a muskie on blades at ice-out? Sure why not?

Edited by IAJustin 3/10/2017 4:57 PM
Fishysam
Posted 3/11/2017 7:26 AM (#852928 - in reply to #852883)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades




Posts: 1209


33 and soft.
25homes
Posted 3/11/2017 8:10 AM (#852935 - in reply to #852928)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades





Posts: 983


Fishysam - 3/11/2017 7:26 AM

33 and soft.


soft?? mind expanding? thanks
danmuskyman
Posted 3/11/2017 8:56 AM (#852940 - in reply to #852883)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades




Posts: 633


Location: Madison, WI
Soft water - meaning not frozen
Junkman
Posted 3/11/2017 9:51 AM (#852945 - in reply to #852883)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades




Posts: 1220


As always, you don't want to look at what is "possible" as much as you want to look at what is "likely." If a hundred guys on the water opening day are tossing big blades and 3 get a fish, you can certainly, and correctly, point out that three fish were caught on big blades. And, if five other guys were tossing some sort of smallish twitch bait and got two fish, you could correctly point out that the blades out-fished the twitch baits by a 50% margin. And, you are also perfectly within your rights not to validate that 40% of the twitch bait users got fish compared to only 3% of the blade tossers. That's because we have a right to believe anything we want to, seeing only our particular way of interpreting the data to suit our preconceived notions. For me, I'd just tell the guy to put the big blades away until the water gets warm, and then put them away again when the water gets cold. It's not a fool-proof assertion, just decent advice!
esoxriebe
Posted 3/11/2017 10:16 AM (#852947 - in reply to #852883)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades




Posts: 95


My number one bait on opening day in Wisconsin is a bucktail

Edited by esoxriebe 3/11/2017 10:17 AM
tbaatz
Posted 3/11/2017 10:16 AM (#852948 - in reply to #852945)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades





Posts: 140


Location: Scandia MN
Junkman - 3/11/2017 9:51 AM

As always, you don't want to look at what is "possible" as much as you want to look at what is "likely." If a hundred guys on the water opening day are tossing big blades and 3 get a fish, you can certainly, and correctly, point out that three fish were caught on big blades. And, if five other guys were tossing some sort of smallish twitch bait and got two fish, you could correctly point out that the blades out-fished the twitch baits by a 50% margin. And, you are also perfectly within your rights not to validate that 40% of the twitch bait users got fish compared to only 3% of the blade tossers. That's because we have a right to believe anything we want to, seeing only our particular way of interpreting the data to suit our preconceived notions. For me, I'd just tell the guy to put the big blades away until the water gets warm, and then put them away again when the water gets cold. It's not a fool-proof assertion, just decent advice!


You have a great future in Washington - - - -
gregk9
Posted 3/11/2017 10:28 AM (#852950 - in reply to #852947)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades





Posts: 797


Location: North Central IL USA
esoxriebe - 3/11/2017 10:16 AM

My number one bait on opening day in Wisconsin is a bucktail


What's the water temperature typically at that time?
Muskie Gal
Posted 3/11/2017 11:27 AM (#852957 - in reply to #852950)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades




Posts: 199


It appears you can slow roll a revolution slower than any other bucktail.
esoxriebe
Posted 3/11/2017 11:43 AM (#852960 - in reply to #852957)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades




Posts: 95


50-60 degrees we catch them burning small bucktails sometimes even when they are still spawning. Not just a few either every guy in the boat throws a bucktail. Where ever there is a closed season for Muskie bucktails work from the first day till the last day
25homes
Posted 3/11/2017 12:53 PM (#852970 - in reply to #852883)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades





Posts: 983


when is opening day in wiscon
esoxriebe
Posted 3/11/2017 2:48 PM (#852976 - in reply to #852883)
Subject: Re: Water temp for blades




Posts: 95


12:00 am Saturday on Memorial Day weekend
Zib
Posted 3/12/2017 5:46 PM (#853090 - in reply to #852883)
Subject: RE: Water temp for blades





Posts: 1405


Location: Detroit River
On Michigan inland lakes I'll be using them on April 29th & on LSC, DR & SCR I'll be using them on June 3rd.