Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure

Posted 4/15/2003 4:48 PM (#67025)
Subject: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure


I was thinking about buying a (top water)walk the dog type lure.
Which is the easiest to use
Thanks in advance
davep
Posted 4/15/2003 5:05 PM (#67026 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure




Posts: 642


Location: mount prospect illinois
The jackpot is easy but i really like the Doc. Both have the same movement and you fish them pretty much the same.
Shep
Posted 4/15/2003 5:21 PM (#67028 - in reply to #67026)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Posts: 5874


Weagle. But make sure you resharpen the hooks if you get it from Thick Shady.
ToddM
Posted 4/15/2003 7:37 PM (#67043 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Posts: 20269


Location: oswego, il
The ones above are good. So is a floating power probe on top especially the small 6" one.
Beaver
Posted 4/15/2003 7:57 PM (#67047 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Posts: 4266


HR Top Prey.
Rides a little lower in the water. More hook ups with less blow ups.
Beaver
Musky Fever
Posted 4/15/2003 9:14 PM (#67051 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Location: Illinois-Indiana
My personal favorite is the ole jackpot, I've caught more fish on this lure than any other topwater lure.
MUSKYJ
Posted 4/15/2003 9:49 PM (#67052 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Posts: 276


Location: in front of my comp
Jackpot, Doc or the dancin Raider
sworrall
Posted 4/15/2003 10:09 PM (#67055 - in reply to #67052)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Posts: 32950


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
The Musky Buster Topwalker is the easiest I have ever used. No matter how lazy I get, the lure behaves well, and seems to hook up pretty well.
MuskieMedic
Posted 4/15/2003 11:38 PM (#67058 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Posts: 2091


Location: Stevens Point, WI
One of my first muskie baits I ever owned was a jackpot, I think it is a very easy bait to work. I also really like the Dancin Raiders too.
Wood
Posted 4/16/2003 12:53 AM (#67060 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure




Posts: 24


Location: Monroe WI
My vote goes to the Slammer Top Dawg
divani
Posted 4/16/2003 1:23 AM (#67062 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Posts: 2061


Location: Belgium
I've tried a few but to me the easiest one to fish is the jackpot
theedz155
Posted 4/16/2003 5:43 AM (#67064 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Posts: 1438


I have two of the Viper's (before Odessy bought em) and they work great. Advantage to these is that with the weight system you can get em to run deeper too.

Scott
Luke_Chinewalker
Posted 4/16/2003 6:00 AM (#67065 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure





Location: Minneapolis, MN
Another vote for the HR Top Prey
7Islands
Posted 4/16/2003 9:38 AM (#67090 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure




Posts: 389


Location: Presque Isle Wisconsin
All good answers above for you;but why are you looking for the easist one to work instead of the most effective one for the type of water you fish? Every body of water has its own peculiarities and certain lures will be favored over other similar types.Try a variety of surface lures before becoming addicted to one because they work for someone else on their lakes.Some people can work a Jackpot or Top prey and some just never get it right(im that way with suicks ). If you like those lures and find them effective on your lakes remember to T the hooks and shrink rap the rear treble shank for better hook ups.
one of the perverse and cruel rules of musky fishing is that the harder it is to work the lure,the more the damn thing fouls up, the more it makes your wrists feel like they have run over by a bus, then the more muskies it attracts
darcyfish
Posted 4/16/2003 3:14 PM (#67127 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure




Posts: 119


Location: Sioux Narrows
The Jackpot is my first choice then the Doc and also the z180, what I throw varies with what I fell will work, but I must admit that my old Jackpot is my fav.

D'arcy Finlan
Darcy's Guide Service
mikes
Posted 4/16/2003 7:40 PM (#67145 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure




Posts: 125


Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota
I have had good success with the jackpot, but fish do tend to miss it.
Reef Hawg
Posted 4/16/2003 8:26 PM (#67146 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure




Posts: 3518


Location: north central wisconsin
Jackpot has been the easiest(least amount of work) for me, also the most consistant producer. I like a super spook too. Though a bit smaller, fish still nail it. Need to beef up the hardware, and use lighter equipment though. Good for action(smaller fish) waters.
MNSteveH
Posted 4/16/2003 10:44 PM (#67161 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure




Posts: 113


Location: Shoreview, MN
The Jackpot is my #1 confidence bait - when I can't move a fish any other way a Jackpot will. Unfortunately I'm also quite cinfident that the fish will usually miss it! (but all topwaters are like that to some extent - at least you know where they are)

saint1
Posted 4/17/2003 11:30 AM (#67198 - in reply to #67025)
Subject: RE: Which is the easiest walk the dog (top water) lure




Posts: 332


Location: Neenah, WI
Hey, If you want to try a very easy to use and versatile bait try the
Oddesy VIPER it walks the dog as well as the Mania DOC.
In addition you can use to the change a weight system to make the bait in to a walk the dog glide bait.