Baby pike or muskie?

Posted 4/14/2003 5:24 PM (#66899)
Subject: Baby pike or muskie?


My little boy and I were fishing at a local pond in a park and my little boy caught a 12-14" fish. I thought it was a baby muskie buy am unsure since I have heard pike don't get there white dots until they get older. This fish had vertical black lines and was definately from the pike or muskie family, any guesses as to what it was? I thought it was a muskie but talked to a park ranger who said they had confirmed pike in there. I couldn't believe it we were chucking Storm Thundersticks for bass and next thing I know my little 6 year old is screaming pike. It was funny and that thing got it pretty deep in, had to get the pliers to get it out, but the coloring looked more like a muskie than a pike to me.
davej
Posted 4/14/2003 5:51 PM (#66900 - in reply to #66899)
Subject: RE: Baby pike or muskie?




Posts: 216


They could have been Pickerel, a few small ponds around here [south east WI] are over run with the little buggers.
ESOX Maniac
Posted 4/14/2003 6:35 PM (#66907 - in reply to #66899)
Subject: RE: Baby pike or muskie?





Posts: 2754


Location: Mauston, Wisconsin

Rockin' SV- Check this website out-anything match?

http://www.dec.state.ny.us/website/dfwmr/fish/fishspecs/piketext.html

"All Water is Zalt Water"

Al Warner

http://www.zaltnad.com

 

Schuler
Posted 4/14/2003 8:32 PM (#66916 - in reply to #66899)
Subject: RE: Baby pike or muskie?





Posts: 1462


Location: Davenport, IA
The thunderstick is the secret baby esox weapon! I caught a spotted muskie that was 16-18" a couple weeks ago on a 2.5" thunderstick when i was fishing for bass. Maybe I shouldn't let the secret out.

Posted 4/14/2003 8:44 PM (#66921 - in reply to #66907)
Subject: RE: Baby pike or muskie?


Originally written by ESOX Maniac on 2003-04-13 7:35 PM

Rockin' SV- Check this website out-anything match?

http://www.dec.state.ny.us/website/dfwmr/fish/fishspecs/piketext.html

"All Water is Zalt Water"

Al Warner

http://www.zaltnad.com

 


Well, not exactly it had dark green in it like the pike but black lines like the tiger muskie only alot darker. I guess I'm lost. In a couple of weeks when the film is used up and I get them developed I post a pic and let you guys see if you have any ideas. Thanks
Sponge
Posted 4/14/2003 9:25 PM (#66927 - in reply to #66899)
Subject: RE: Baby pike or muskie?




Gave my favorite Thunder Stick to my brother a couple years ago to use, and he caught a musky on it; broke the lip off and ripped out the front treble! I had caught a bunch of rockfish on that bait, and something about that certain bait made it better than other T Sticks I had, even the same size and pattern. Wish I had just said NO!!!
RAZE1
Posted 4/14/2003 10:22 PM (#66937 - in reply to #66899)
Subject: RE: Baby pike or muskie?





Posts: 938


Location: NeverNever Lake
Bout 4 yrs ago a 54 1/4 " 45# Ski was taken on a Thunderstick jr at Piedmont............nice fish!

Posted 4/14/2003 11:10 PM (#66951 - in reply to #66899)
Subject: RE: Baby pike or muskie?


Raze 1, when you say Thunderstick jr. surely your not talking about the 2 1/2" one are you? I think a muskie that big would destroy that little lure, much less get them little hooks through the roof of his mouth. I've had good luck with the little Thundersticks though, I've caught quite a few small mouth and walleye on them and today was using it for large mouth and caught 3. Thanks for all the replies all. Mark
sworrall
Posted 4/15/2003 5:47 PM (#67030 - in reply to #66951)
Subject: RE: Baby pike or muskie?





Posts: 32955


Location: Rhinelander, Wisconsin
I have caught 20 pound plus pike on Thundersticks. A few years ago, I got a near 50" fish on the Goon fishing smallmouth bass with a Jr. model.